Writers of Pro Football Prospectus 2008

24 Sep 2009

Should I pick up Laurent Robinson or Mike Sims-Walker?

In general, for the rest of the season, would Laurent Robinson or Mike Sims-Walker be better than D.Mason, J.Gage or W.Parker? (1pt for 20yds rush and 10yds rec). Thanks!

Posted by: CheeseHead on 24 Sep 2009

2 replies , Last at 24 Sep 2009, 6:07pm by Zheng

1
Re: Should I pick up Laurent Robinson or Mike Sims-Walker?
by Red Hedgehog :: Thu, 09/24/2009 - 3:34pm

If Sims-Walker becomes Jax's top receiver, then he's better than Gage or Parker. But it's probably too early to tell. I think Robinson is probably going to be slightly better than Gage for the rest of the season, so I might make that move.

If you can sell high on Gage, I'd do so.

2
Re: Should I pick up Laurent Robinson or Mike Sims-Walker?
by Zheng :: Thu, 09/24/2009 - 6:07pm

I'd certainly replace Parker and maybe replace Mason with either of those. Parker's not getting it done and might get the hook, although Mendenhall isn't exactly setting the world on fire. Mason seems like he always puts up exactly six points a week.

Of the two I like Walker slightly over Robinson. Similar situations, both talented, but Walker's QB is a little better. But I may not have any idea what I'm talking about.

Login or register to post comments