Articles from around the Web
PDF VERSION NOW AVAILABLE
Click here to buy PDF version.
Click here to buy PDF version
Official Account: @fboutsiders
Scott Kacsmar: @FO_ScottKacsmar
Ben Muth: @FO_WordofMuth
Aaron Schatz: @FO_ASchatz
Vince Verhei: @FO_VVerhei
-- plus --
Bill Connelly: @SBN_BillC
J.J. Cooper: @jjcoop36
Cian Fahey: @Cianaf
Brian Fremeau: @bcfremeau
Tom Gower: @ThomasGower
Rivers McCown: @RiversMcCown
Chad Peltier: @CGPeltier
Matt Waldman: @MattWaldman
Rob Weintraub: @robwein
08 Feb 2011
Tennessee continues to pursue a makeover of their staff; offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger has now been let go.
Posted by: Bill Barnwell on 08 Feb 2011
17 comments, Last at
14 Feb 2011, 5:20am by
I thought promoting Munchak was an effort at continuity, but I guess not.
Are there any notable cases of a former OL coach succeeding as a head coach without coordinator experience? I can only think of Art Shell and Tom Cable, and neither one was wildly successful except for Shell with the 1990 Raiders.
Mike Tice was the Vikings OL coach when he took over after Denny Green.
Joe Bugel coached the Cardinals from 1990-93; he certainly wasn't successful but, as I'm sure 1991 DVOA will confirm, his team faced arguably the hardest schedule ever: ten ten-win teams and only a couple of opponents with a losing record.
Tony Sparano had no NFL OC experience when he took over the Dolphins. He was Asst. HC while in Dallas but never OC. He was a college OC for 4 years though in the early 90s.
Not exactly burning down the AFC East, but he's the only one (besides Cable) I could think of.
So Munchak just fired his boss? Or was Fisher his boss?
Isn't Dinger getting chemo for cancer? Maybe firing him is actually better for him because he's still technically under contract and gets his salary and medical coverage.
1. Heimerdinger was diagnosed with cancer late last year. He began a chemotherapy regimen in November. I do not know where he is currently in his treatment.
2. I have yet to see Heimerdinger described as anything other than "respected" and "well-liked". This move strongly suggests that Mike Munchak is an asshole. Good luck, Titans.
3. If Heimerdinger were still employed, he would also have salary and health insurance. How is this in any way "better for him"?
Stay classy, Mr. Adams.
from an AP story:
"The Titans defended firing Heimerdinger, saying they immediately offered to extend the coordinator's contract when he was diagnosed with cancer so he would not have to worry. Heimerdinger was under contract for 2011."
HGeimerdinger is quoted as saying his health played no role in the decision, and that his prognosis was good, even though he has two rounds of treatment remaining.
If Heimerdinger were still employed, he would also have salary and health insurance. How is this in any way "better for him"?
I can't imagine being an NFL coordinator is good for your health.
Gilda Radner: "Cancer is probably the most unfunny thing in the world". And, yet, that post was funny. You make a good point; getting away from the grind might be a real benefit. I stand corrected.
I have yet to see Heimerdinger described as anything other than "respected" and "well-liked".
A column here called him out for his god-awful playcalling this year. It had nothing to do with him as a person, of course, but it's clear that he was not good at his job. I have no idea where you get off assuming "Mike Munchak is an asshole" just because he fired a bad coach.
The backstory behind VY getting benched against the Steelers, which neither MikeT nor I knew when we wrote what we did, was VY had skipped meetings (plural) during the week and was making calls in the huddle that weren't in the playbook. Even before that came out, I changed my opinion from that in my initial reaction post to VY had, due to uncertainty, stopped trusting what he thought he saw and was unwilling to throw with any anticipation at all, which effectively immobilized the Titans' passing offense.
I had arrived independently at the conclusion that the Titans offense was crippled by bad playcalling, and then saw the linked article which strengthened my conclusion at the time. I didn't see that bit about VY calling his own plays, so I had assumed that Heimerdinger was to blame. And perhaps he still shares a lot of the blame, but I guess it's more complicated than I originally thought.
I don't know where you get off concluding that Heimerdinger was a bad coach on the basis of an article by Mike Tanier about one game. Here's what Tanier actually wrote:
"Heimerdinger is a good coordinator, and Jeff Fisher certainly deserves the benefit of the doubt, but coaches have bad games, just like quarterbacks."
Thanks for providing the link, but it would have been better if the article had said what you claimed it did.
It's interesting how quick Jim Washburn has been to say, when prompted, what the difference between Philadelphia and other teams was. Bear in mind that this is a Defensive Line Coach who seems pretty big on loyalty within the coaching fraternity, it's still fairly unequivocal:
'Philadelphia has a Quarterback. That's it. Tennessee hasn't had a Quarterback since Steve McNair left.'
Harsh words from someone inside the organisation. I'd think that Heimerdinger's rep is probably going to remain intact, and down the line, Vince Young will seem more and more like the problem.
Sorry to hear it for Heimerdinger. He's responsible for one of my favorite football-related lines of all time. Earlier this decade, someone asked him why it was that he kept getting head coaching interviews, but never seemed to make it to the finalist stage. Heimerdinger replied with "owners want a big name, not a long one"
How dramatic was Jay Cutler's improvement from the first half to the second against San Francisco?
See All XP | NFL XP | College XP
© Football Outsiders, Inc. // Site powered by Stein-Wein // Partner of USA TODAY Sports Digital Properties