Articles from around the Web
Top 35 quarterbacks charted for 2015 with scouting notes. PDF only $9.99
Click here to buy PDF version
Like our page on Facebook and get Football Outsiders links directly in your Facebook feed.
Official Account: @fboutsiders
Scott Kacsmar: @FO_ScottKacsmar
Ben Muth: @FO_WordofMuth
Aaron Schatz: @FO_ASchatz
Vince Verhei: @FO_VVerhei
-- plus --
Bill Connelly: @SBN_BillC
Cian Fahey: @Cianaf
Brian Fremeau: @bcfremeau
Tom Gower: @ThomasGower
Andrew Healy: @AndHealy
Rivers McCown: @RiversMcCown
Chad Peltier: @CGPeltier
Rob Weintraub: @robwein
Sterling Xie: @SterlingXie
31 Aug 2013
If only someone had called this a few months ago...
Posted by: Rivers McCown on 31 Aug 2013
35 comments, Last at
04 Sep 2013, 12:55pm by
If McDaniels couldn't convince BB to keep his pet around, I think this may finally be the end of this story. How fast did ESPN and FS1 get on the phone to his agent to acquire his brilliant insight for college football coverage?
Truthfully, the "cut quarterback" release I'm more intrigued by is Vince Young, from a substantive football standpoint. The Packers signed him, ditched last year's backup (Harrell), played him in all four games, and then settled on Coleman instead. I'm genuinely curious about what's going on there, since that's all over the backup job, as opposed to whether the Patriots were going to keep a third-stringer.
(That said, as a Dolphins fan, I can't help but feel an eentsy bit of schadenfreude, since it was Miami's last-two-minute collapse that led to the Legend of Tebow being created in 2011. Without those two minutes, that'd have been two ugly, ugly losses in a row for Denver, with the Detroit game, and the experiment would likely have been over in the "He had a chance, he was awful, now let's get back to real football" sense.)
I'm hoping the Packers plan on picking up another QB off waivers. Coleman isn't that good. At least with Young, the Packers had a chance of being competitive if Rodgers was injured. Just because a QB can't master a hundreds-page thick playbook in less than four weeks is no reason to cut him, especially when it is still obvious he's the second-best QB on the roster.
It is if the observed work habits of the player are poor. I'm not saying I know it is the case, but they obviously saw something that they didn't like.
my theory is the packers brought him in to teach him the offense, and if rodgers ever gets hurt he will be on the team the following day. in the meantime they save a roster spot.
It might be one of those, "We saw some things we like but frankly you're not quite talented enough to get by on the work habits you're displaying."
Yes, you're right..."real football" isn't beating the #1 pass defense in the playoffs in your 15th start...when the team you're playing for was the 2nd worst in the league the year before. That Miami game illustrated a point over & over again...real football IS NOT what John Fox was playing the 1st 3 quarters of any Tebow game...& Tebow's QB rating (& production) was over 100 in the 4th Q., when Fox stopped the Mickey Mouse offense (as he did the Pitt playoff game...he continued it in the NE playoff game, however). The fact that Tebow put up an 82.1 rating in 3 starts in 2010, running a fairly conventional offense to me further disproves this notion that Tebow has to run an antiquated offense to succeed. Definitely not a pocket passer, & he's gonna have to get better @ that, just like Elway said. But I just love that the league (& Tebow's former team) would pick up utter failure Brady Quinn today, because he plays more like "an NFL QB" (never mind posting a rating 10 points under Tebow, whether you agree with the passer rating or not).
Yeah, and then Tebow was subsequently shown to be the sham that he is by being trounced 45-10 by the 31st-ranked defense just one week later.
You should really look at that Bronco season with a little more thought. That 'miracle' win against the Dolphins was pretty questionable. Thomas' TD catch was a review play that could have gone either way, and the big play to Fells on the tying TD drive maybe should have been called back for illegal blockers downfield -- the announcers pointed it out in the play by play. One could easily infer that the Dolphins were screwed by the officials in a game that they otherwise had in control.
Then look at how the Broncos finished the season - who they beat and who they lost to - and then come back with a more reasoned commentary on Tebow's performance.
But I don't expect thoughtful commentary from Tebowistas any more than I expect it from Scientologistas.
This warrants an Extra Point? New England bias!
Aaron told me to post it right after we completed our daily phone call about Tony Eason.
That warrants a phone call? Bad quarterback bias!
Nice, nice, rejoinder.
This is funny because there is a hint of truth to the idea. Somehow Aaron Hernandez didn't warrant an EP for at least a week (and many hijacks in other threads). But Tebow getting released, now that warrants an EP within hours. hmm...
Well originally we had planned to do XP's on every New England player that was released or waived, so consider yourself lucky.
I laughed again. Its even more funny because Aaron Hernandez was a starter, pro-bowl caliber player, while this Tim guy was mopping up in the 4th quarter of the 4th preseason game. So clearly FO's standards for XP's are set in stone.
No, you're right...most 3rd string QBs are National Champion, Heisman-winning, 1st round picks whose last 2 starts were playoff games. Why run a special news item on this Tebow character?
Because it has been stated many times that an the news needs to have impact on the field for it to become an XP.
So yeah, Tebow was almost* beating Tom Brady for the starting QB spot - this was totally within the criteria.
That and bacause Tebow = traffic and comments.
Well it's mostly because we wanted to give a little head nod to Mike Tanier for calling this months ago and generally being awesome at writing. (See: the link.)
But okay, back to the part where we are biased and evil corporate tools for not putting up an Aaron Hernandez or Brian Urlacher retirement XP immediately while on book deadline. You'll show us yet!
Tanier for calling it? About 90% of the football watching public didn't think he was going to make the roster.
They should have written entertaining articles about it too, then.
Also, well played in this chain Rivers.
Because he's terrible...hasn't that been established yet? OMG he won a Heisman? Why won't anybody give Gino Torretta another shot? Or Jason White? Don't you know that those awards are the guarantee of stardom?
They also released Zoltan Mesko. Space Emperor was his title, if I recall correctly.
This will have more impact on the field, than releasing Timmah.
That's awkward timing for Zoltan. Whedon just announced Ultron for Avengers 2 like, a month ago.
With that name, Zoltan totally had a shot if he'd been free.
Will he shuffle off to Buffalo?
I thought for sure the NFL was going to force the Patriots to start him all year so the AFC EAST wouldn't be decided by halftime of week one.
Oh, is Brady getting injured again?
Patriots No Longer Interested In Tebow’s “Sack, Loss, ‘n Dashes” Approach To Quarterbacking
The Patriots. They're a football team based in Massachusetts. You may have heard of Massachusetts in history class.
Since I took history classes in Massachusetts, and I was visiting my parents there in my boyhood home last month, I feel I have a rudimentary knowledge of the Commonwealth.
Oh, then you must have been confused about who Tim Tebow was. :-)
That's quite understandable. He used to play professional football. But that was a couple of years ago. He made an otherwise quite good offense look decidedly below average.
No comment on any other aspect of this, but to say that trainwreck of an offense was "otherwise quite good" is way off base.
Never made any sense, on any level. He didn't even play in one of the games and they never tried anything creative with him, which would have been the only logical use. Was McDaniels hoping to keep that stuff under wraps and spring it during the regular season?
Yes. That's still the plan, but it's going to be Brady executing it now.
In which the FO staff tries to make sense of whatever the hell the Titans are doing.
See All XP | NFL XP | College XP
Need help on FanDuel or DraftKings? Purchase a subscription from the website that specializes in daily fantasy.
© Football Outsiders, Inc. // Site powered by Stein-Wein // Partner of USA TODAY Sports Digital Properties