Writers of Pro Football Prospectus 2008

Most Recent FO Features

ReplayIns14.jpg

» Scramble for the Ball: Getting it Right?

Instant replay review is one of the cornerstones of the modern NFL. The process and its myriad special rules have been internalized and constantly debated. Mike Kurtz wonders: is it worth it?

04 Aug 2011

Four Downs: AFC East

by Sean McCormick

One effect of the lockout is that teams don’t have as good a feel for their roster as they would in normal years. No one has conducted OTAs, and rookies haven’t had a chance to study the playbooks or meet with position coaches. And because free agency was pushed back until after the lockout, many teams don’t know what their rosters will look like even as they begin training camp. So without further ado, let’s look at the four teams of the AFC East to see which positions they should be considering strengthening:

Buffalo Bills: Right Tackle

There was simply no way the Bills were going to be able to adequately address all their holes in the space of a single offseason, and to their credit, they haven’t thrown lots of money around trying to. Ryan Fitzpatrick isn’t a long-term solution at quarterback -- he may not even be a short-term solution -- but there were no surefire prospects worth burning a top five draft pick on, and the free agent pickings were slim, particularly if you didn’t want to give away the farm for Kevin Kolb. Instead of getting cute at the top of the draft, the Bills took Marcell Dareus, a massive, scheme-versatile defensive tackle who should immediately upgrade a defensive line that was 32nd in Adjusted Line Yards. Dareus is no Nick Fairley, but he does bring some pass rush, and his ability to tie up blockers will allow linebackers and defensive backs to come free on blitzes. Paul Posluszny briefly left a hole when he signed with Jacksonville, but free agent Nick Barnett quickly filled it.

The right tackle spot, however, is not a hole but a canyon, and it doesn’t look like Buffalo has done enough to address it. The Bills were 30th in Adjusted Line Yards at runs off right tackle, but that doesn’t begin to tell the tale. Buffalo ended up playing four different players at right tackle, beginning with Cornell Green, then Cordaro Howard, Mansfield Wrotto, and finally Erik Pears. Things got so bad that Chan Gailey started rotating players from series to series in the vain hope that someone would do some blocking. Green is gone and Howard has moved inside, but that hasn’t made the situation much clearer. As camp opens, there is a battle between Wrotto, Pears, Ed Wang, and rookie Chris Hairston, a fourth-round pick out of Clemson. It would have been nice to land a top performer like Tyson Clabo in free agency, but even spending modest money for a second go-round with Langston Walker might be preferable to handing the job to any of the four current contestants.

Miami Dolphins: Quarterback

If you were to simply look at the statistics, quarterback would not necessarily be the biggest hole on the Dolphins. Chris Clemons struggled badly getting to the sidelines to provide help over the top, and offenses frequently targeted him in isolation in the deep middle of the field. The interior line could use some more help even after inserting Mike Pouncey into the starting lineup. And of course, the special teams were consistently horrific from beginning to end. In contrast, Chad Henne’s 621 DYAR (Defense-adjusted Yards Above Replacement) were 17th in the league, which is to say just a bit below average. Henne’s season was crippled by the 19 interceptions he threw, but a closer look suggests that he was the victim of some terrible luck. Almost every mistake throw Henne made ended up on the stat sheet, as Henne only threw one dropped interception all year. With even average luck, Henne’s interceptions will decrease next year, and he could return to being a middle-of-the-pack quarterback with some potential for growth.

Of course, there are lots of things that statistics don’t cover, and it’s those things that turned Henne’s season from disappointing to catastrophic. Brandon Marshall publicly allied with backup Tyler Thigpen, and took his grievances with Henne to the airwaves, complaining about Henne’s refusal to throw him the ball with sufficient frequency. Henne was benched during the season, reclaimed his starting job only because of injuries, and then was injured himself. In the offseason, owner Stephen Ross was adamant that the Dophins bring in competition, and the team tried to do just that, fumbling around with Denver over Kyle Orton before deciding that Orton’s contract demands were too high. Instead, they signed Matt Moore, he of the -270 DYAR and -37.5% DVOA, who lost his job last year to Jimmy Clausen of all people. Now the Dolphins will have a quarterback controversy on their hands in training camp, and there will be pressure to give Moore a legitimate shot at the starting gig, which means fewer reps for Henne as offensive coordinator Brian Daboll installs a new offense.

This can go one of two ways and still work out. If Henne comes out of the gates fast and grabs a stranglehold on the starting job, Miami can go back to developing their young and talented quarterback with no harm done. Alternately, Miami can pony up for Orton, who is the only guy out there who represents a legitimate upgrade over Henne. Right now, though, it looks like neither of those things are happening.

New England Patriots: Defensive End/Outside Linebacker

The hot story out of Providence is that Bill Belichick seems to be abandoning his traditional 3-4 defense in favor of a 4-3, and that the Patriots have primarily been working with 4-3 Under and Over fronts in the first days of training camp. The release of Ty Warren and the trade for Albert Haynesworth could be viewed as additional evidence of a shift, as Warren is a prototypical five-technique while Haynesworth has done his best work in a 4-3 set. The whole thing is something of a Macguffin -- the Patriots have run a wide variety of fronts for some time now, and the gap principles will remain the same. The real issue is finding someone who can rush off the edge, whether standing up or from a three-point stance. New England’s DVOA against the pass on third downs in 2010 was an abysmal 24.0%, and right now the starting defensive ends would be Jermaine Cunningham and Eric Moore, who combined for a grand total of three sacks last season.

Cunningham was a down lineman at Florida, so there is reason to believe he’ll develop faster if he returns to playing with his hand on the ground. Moore has been a non-entity for most of his career, though a stint in the UFL seems to have invigorated him; he registered 14 tackles, two sacks and two forced fumbles in just four games after returning to the NFL last year. If the Patriots want to add competition, they could look to Andre Carter, who flopped as a 3-4 outside linebacker but is a credible 4-3 end, or Matt Roth, who fits the mold of a traditional Belichick edge rusher and who has plentiful experience in the system, having played for both Nick Saban and Eric Mangini. If the Patriots really wanted to make some noise, they could jump into the trade market for Osi Umenyiora. Umenyiora is looking for a big contract, and he would have no position when the Patriots wanted to use three down linemen, but he would certainly look good lined up alongside Haynesworth or Vince Wilfork.

New York Jets: Wide Receiver

Aside from his foray into the Nnamdi Asomugha sweepstakes, general manager Mike Tannenbaum has largely been content to re-sign his players or to extend the contracts of younger stars. The big name was obviously Santonio Holmes, but Tannenbaum also locked up Antonio Cromartie and Eric Smith, extended David Harris for another four years, and returned Donald Strickland, who had played for the team in 2009, to replace the departed Drew Coleman. While maintaining continuity isn’t always a good thing--Carolina’s decision to spend vast sums to return the young core of their 2-14 team comes immediately to mind--the Jets fielded one of the most talented teams in the league, and the talent was fairly evenly distributed on both offense and defense. If the Jets are going to take a step forward, they don’t necessarily need to sign a bunch of free agents. What they do need is for Mark Sanchez to take another step forward in his development, and preferably a big step. So how best to ensure that your young quarterback has all the weapons he needs? How about signing a 34-year-old receiver who has been in jail for the last two years?

In fairness, the Jets were going to have a very hard time re-signing both Holmes and Braylon Edwards, and there is no question that they made the right decision by prioritizing Holmes. And Burress at first blush provides a good approximation of Edwards’ skill set, so it stands to reason that he could step into the offense fairly seamlessly. The problems are twofold. The first is that there simply is no history to suggest that Burress is going to be able to recapture his 2008 form after his extended time away from the game. Michael Vick was sluggish in his return to the NFL, and the rust didn’t come off until the following season. And the second problem is that the 2008 version of Plaxico Burress was already showing signs of slowing down, averaging only 13 yards per reception, his lowest total since his rookie season, and ranking 37th in both DYAR and DVOA. If Burress struggles as the number two receiver, it will allow defenses to consistently roll coverage towards Holmes, thus making Sanchez’s life difficult.

(This article previously appeared at ESPN Insider.)

Posted by: Sean McCormick on 04 Aug 2011

17 comments, Last at 08 Aug 2011, 3:04pm by chemical burn

Comments

1
by tuluse :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 12:48pm

Hurray! Four downs are back!

2
by tuluse :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 1:04pm

I don't think that is the right usage of MacGuffin, maybe you meant red herring?

7
by Brooklynfinfan (not verified) :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 9:01pm

That's right. A MacGuffin is a plot device that sets a narrative in motion without necessarily being integral to it (the mysterious glowing briefcase in Pulp Fiction is a classic example). I suppose you could be trying to say that some interesting storylines will come out of a Pats defensive alignment switch...but I think red herring was the idiom you were looking for.

This is silly nitpicking, of course. The return of Four Downs is a welcome sight no matter what analogies or expressions you want to use. Best site in the business.

8
by tuluse :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 9:57pm

I reserve the right to nickpick as sillily as I like.

9
by Brooklynfinfan (not verified) :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 10:29pm

oh, sorry! I wrote that poorly. I meant my own correction was silly nitpicking. I was agreeing with you about the misuse of Macguffin, but also trying to acknowledge that by doing so I was getting way off of any topic even remotely related to actual football and...yeah, I'm making it worse right now. Totally not about football anymore. My apologies if I touched a nerve.

10
by Intropy :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 11:27pm

I prefer to carry a big stick and speak softly for I tread on your horse's dreams.

15
by Sean McCormick :: Sun, 08/07/2011 - 9:28pm

Right you are.

3
by Harrison Bergeron (not verified) :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 1:15pm

Henne is going to have a nice career once the Dolphins release him and he catches on with a good/patient team.

4
by Sergio :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 2:39pm

This.

When did it become canon for a QB to step right in and take over the position?

-- Go Phins!

5
by Anonymous1 (not verified) :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 3:35pm

Actually, the Patriots switch isn't "something of a Macguffin", it is a genuine philosophic change. They haven't even practiced the 3-4 yet and have been using a lot of 1-gap principles.

As further evidence of the change, NE signed former Bears DE Mark Anderson today. I don't get all the enthusiasm about Roth and it seems that Pats aren't interested in him either.

6
by justanothersteve :: Fri, 08/05/2011 - 3:57pm

Today Miami signed Kevin O'Connell, having learned from Arizona that you can never have too many mediocre QBs.

11
by The Ninjalectual :: Sat, 08/06/2011 - 12:19am

What, no list of player departures/arrivals?

12
by Humpty Dumpty (not verified) :: Sun, 08/07/2011 - 5:07am

The Jets paid more money for Burress than the 49ers paid for Edwards (who has a non guaranteed 1M base contract). Looks like NY got a bit too cute, because I know who I'd rather have.

16
by Led :: Mon, 08/08/2011 - 11:49am

I'm pretty sure the Jets would've paid Edwards the Burress money if Edwards would have accepted it at the time. Word is that Edwards wanted a deal similar to what the Jets paid Holmes and certainly would have insisted on a multi-year deal. Turns out Edwards overestimated his market value and then had another off the field altercation that further depressed his value, leaving him with no other option than a crappy deal with San Fran. That doesn't mean he would've accepted the same deal with NY a week earlier.

17
by chemical burn :: Mon, 08/08/2011 - 3:04pm

Yeah, Edwards is getting suspended a big freaking chunk of time this year. It's not clear how hard Goodell is going to come down on him, but the kitchen fight is so egregious and ugly (and he proved his involvement by tweeting about starting it just before it happened), I think most people will be rooting for "pretty damn hard."

13
by Humpty Dumpty (not verified) :: Sun, 08/07/2011 - 5:07am

The Jets paid more money for Burress than the 49ers paid for Edwards (who has a non guaranteed 1M base contract). Looks like NY got a bit too cute, because I know who I'd rather have.

14
by johonny (not verified) :: Sun, 08/07/2011 - 1:04pm

Seem to me last year most of Henne's worst games came after he suffered a knee injury that limited his mobility and his offensive line suffered multiple injuries. The two seemed to go hand in hand in making it hard for anyone to QB the Dolphins. The Dolphins two running backs also seemed less productive behind that line. All of which makes you wonder why Miami has spent so much effort to toy with its backs and quarterback and seems scrambling to fix its oline. Right now every line position except LG seems to have a question mark. Is Miami really up to adding a rookie running back and TE/FB to the mix in protecting Henne? Seems like only if all pro LT is ready to start the season, they figure out who wins RT job, they sign their center, they figure out who is their RG... wasn't their coach suppose to be a Oline guy?