Writers of Pro Football Prospectus 2008

Most Recent FO Features

GurleyTod16.jpg

» OFI: SEC Surprises

In an opening week where even the elite teams in college football looked mortal, the SEC had two big surprises in Texas A&M and Georgia defeating their South Carolinian opponents by big scores.

04 Jun 2014

Four Downs: NFC West

By Vince Verhei

Arizona Cardinals

Biggest holes: Right guard and right tackle

When it came to addressing obvious weaknesses, few teams did a better job this offseason than the Cardinals. In free agency, they added potential starters in cornerback Antonio Cromartie, left tackle Jared Veldheer, and tight end John Carlson. In the draft, they spent a first-rounder on safety Deone Bucannon, who should be a starter from day one. And then in the second, they found tight end Troy Niklas, an old school physical blocker/short-route type. They even found a quarterback of the future in Logan Thomas. As a bonus, they get healthier in 2014: Jonathan Cooper, last year's first-round pick who missed his entire rookie season after a broken leg, is expected to return to the lineup. The Cardinals won ten games last year and were the only team to beat the Seahawks in Seattle, and on paper they're even better now.

The offensive line, though, still needs some work, specifically on the right side. Veldheer and Cooper should be big upgrades at left tackle and left guard, and center Lyle Sendlein has been a desert mainstay for half a decade now. The incumbents at right guard and tackle, though, are Paul Fanaika and Bradley Sowell, two players who had never started an NFL game before last season. There were 165 offensive linemen with at least 500 snaps in the NFL last year. Sowell was second-worst among those players in rate of blown blocks per snap, according to the FO game charting project. Fanaika was in the bottom 20 percent. Last year's starter at right tackle, NFLPA president Eric Winston, remains available. It wouldn't be a surprise if he donned a Cardinals helmet again.

Notable Undrafted Free Agents

The Cardinals have 14 free agents on their roster. Guard Anthony Steen (Alabama) was a three-year starter for the Crimson Tide and an all-SEC player with a second- or third-round projection, but then he underwent surgery to repair a torn labrum in December. Offensive tackle Kelvin Palmer (Baylor) was an honorable mention all-Big 12 player as a senior. Running back Zach Bauman (Northern Arizona) had four 1,000-yard seasons in college, earning all-Big Sky honors every season. Fellow RB Tim Cornett (UNLV) went over 1,200 yards twice, the second leading rusher in Mountain West conference history. Inside linebacker Glenn Carson (Penn State) was an honorable mention all-Big Ten player. Linebacker Jonathan Brown (Illinois) was second-team all-Big Ten and was second in the conference with 119 tackles.

St. Louis Rams

Biggest hole: Quarterback

The Rams have perhaps the league's deepest defensive line, an impressive set of linebackers, and a lot of young talent in the secondary. They have youth and potential in the skill positions, and they added Auburn offensive tackle Greg Robinson with the second pick in the draft boost their offensive line. Now they need their quarterback to finally live up to his draft status.

Four years after the Rams took Sam Bradford with the first overall pick in the 2010 draft, he has yet to have what you could fairly call a good season. To be fair, by most measures, he was enjoying his best season in 2013 when he tore his ACL (although his QBR was actually a little higher in 2012). Still, Bradford has never finished higher than 20th in QBR, while other young quarterbacks like Robert Griffin, Nick Foles, Colin Kaepernick, Andrew Luck, Cam Newton, and Russell Wilson have been setting records and leading their clubs to the playoffs.

True, Bradford has not been playing in ideal conditions. His receivers, though talented, are inexperienced. His offensive line has struggled with injuries. And Brian Schottenheimer's offense has been as frustrating to watch in St. Louis as it was in New York. Still, Bradford is the man on the field taking snaps and making passes, and the player most responsible for what happens with the team's offense. And given the talent around him, he's out of excuses. If he can't figure it out in 2014, it's doubtful that he ever will.

Notable Undrafted Free Agents

Fifteen free agents will enter camp with St. Louis. Tight end Alex Bayer (Bowing Green) was a two-time all-MAC selection. Jarrid Bryant (South Dakota) played wide receiver and defensive back for four years (including a redshirt season) at Arizona State, graduated, then finished his career with the Coyotes as a graduate student. Running back Trey Watts (Tulsa) led Conference-USA in rushing and yards from scrimmage last season, and also scored twice on kickoff returns and once on a punt return in his collegiate career. Kadeem Jones (Western Kentucky) is the only fullback on the Rams' roster right now. He was a dangerous red zone threat in school, scoring 10 touchdowns on 52 career rushes and adding 15 touchdowns on 82 catches. Defensive tackle Deantre Harlan (Bacone College) is the first player from his school to sign an NFL contract. Defensive tackle Ethan Westbrooks (West Texas A&M) had 19.5 sacks last season and was named Division II Defensive Player of the Year. If things don't work out for him on the gridiron, he could always try things between the ropes; a number of West Texas A&M alumni later became successful pro wrestlers, including Dory Funk, Jr., Terry Funk, Stan Hansen, Dusty Rhodes, Ted DiBiase, Bruiser Brody, and Tito Santana. Cornerback Marcus Roberson (Florida) entered the season as a highly-ranked prospect, but a knee injury limited him to seven games. Linebacker Aaron Hill (Minnesota) was an honorable mention all-Big Ten selection. Linebacker Tavarius Wilson (North Alabama) was named Gulf South Conference Defensive Player of the Year.

San Francisco 49ers

Biggest hole: Cornerback

Last year's starters, Carlos Rogers and Tarell Brown, have moved together across the bay to Oakland. In their place, the 49ers plan to start Tramaine Brock and Chris Culliver. Brock, the team's nickelback last year, was the target on more than a quarter of the passes aimed at San Francisco cornerbacks, one of the 11 highest rates among corners. In other words, opposing quarterbacks picked on him, over and over again, whenever he was on the field. Also, in 600-plus snaps last year, he never once made a tackle on a running play. Culliver, meanwhile, played OK as the team's nickelback in 2012. He then missed all of 2013 with a torn ACL suffered in training camp. His life since then has been a string of arrests, lawsuits, and offensive remarks. None of that has anything to do with his ability to play football, but it does mean he's a headache, and headaches tend to run out of second chances quickly.

The 49ers added Chris Cook in free agency, but the veteran has struggled to stay healthy, never playing more than 12 games in a season for Minnesota. Last year, he was one of eight corners in the NFL to give up more than 10 yards per target. It's hard to see him developing into a star at this point. There are three other veteran options on the roster: Eric Wright, Perrish Cox, and Darryl Morris. That trio combined for just 203 snaps last year.

Notable Undrafted Free Agents

The 49ers drafted 12 players, which only left room for seven free agents. Center Dillon Farrell (New Mexico) was on the Rimington Trophy watch list. Tackle Fou Fonoti (Michigan State) was an honorable mention all-Big Ten selection. Linebacker Shayne Skov (Stanford) was a second-team All-American and the Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year. However, in 2011, he suffered a torn ACL and MCL and fractured his tibia, and he also had a DUI arrest in 2012. He'll be 24 when the season starts. Pass rusher Morgan Breslin (USC) had 13 sacks as a junior after transferring from a junior college, but hip injuries ruined his senior season and limited him to 4.5 sacks. Free safety L.J. McCray (Catawba) was a three-time first-team all-South Atlantic Conference selection.

Seattle Seahawks

Biggest hole: Offensive line

Ironically, it's the defending Super Bowl champions who have the most glaring weakness in the division. Marshawn Lynch broke so many tackles that he made the offensive linemen look better than they really were, but not even Russell Wilson was slippery enough to lift Seattle out of the bottom of FO's Adjusted Sack Rate rankings. In a division with the Cardinals, Rams, and 49ers, the Seahawks can't field a line as bad as last year's and expect to win another championship.

Remember those 165 offensive linemen with 500 snaps last season, mentioned in the Arizona section above? Five of the bottom 40 players in blown blocks per snap played for the Seahawks (including Breno Giacomini, now with the Jets). Seattle has a good center in Max Unger, a good left tackle who can't stay healthy in Russell Okung, and a bunch of question marks.

The current plan is to stick James Carpenter at left guard. Carpenter, a first-round pick in 2011, has bounced in and out of the lineup for years. Right guard J.R. Sweezy, a seventh-round pick in 2012, played defensive line in college and sometimes still seems to be adjusting to the position switch. Michael Bowie, the projected starter at right tackle, was a seventh-round rookie last year out of Northeastern (OK) State who had been kicked off Mike Gundy's Oklahoma State team. He was a healthy inactive for the Super Bowl. Second-round draft pick Justin Britt (Missouri) will challenge for a spot somewhere, but sixth-rounder Garrett Scott (Marshall) won't; the Seahawks waived Scott after a physical showed signs of a rare heart condition.

Notable Undrafted Free Agents

When the Seahawks open camp, they will take ten free agents with them. Guard Bronson Irwin (Oklahoma) was an honorable mention all-Big 12 selection. Tackle Garry Gilliam (Penn State) missed two years of college football with a torn ACL and subsequent infection. Quarterback Keith Price (Washington) set school records for passing touchdowns in a season and a career. Defensive tackle Andru Pulu (Eastern Washington) was a second-team all-Big Sky pick. Defensive end Jackson Jeffcoat (Texas) was an all-Big 12 first-teamer, a Walter Camp All-American, and one of the stars of FO's SackSEER pass rusher projection system. Inside linebacker Brock Coyle (Montana) was an all-Big Sky second-teamer. Safety Dion Bailey (USC) started his collegiate career as a linebacker and fits Seattle's preference for big defensive backs.

Portions of this article previously appeared on ESPN Insider.

Posted by: Vince Verhei on 04 Jun 2014

21 comments, Last at 08 Jun 2014, 2:02am by tuluse

Comments

1
by tuluse :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 3:42pm

"[Bradford's] receivers, though talented"

Are they talented? I haven't seen much from them that looks like talent.

2
by theslothook :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 4:26pm

We all know pass defense is important, but it's often poorly understood what the biggest contributing factors to it are. From the data I've seen, good pass defense is much more about coverage and less about pass rush specifically, but what makes up good coverage?

SF and ARI will give us some insights I hope. What do I mean? The 49ers are unproven at corner but very powerful at linebacker(assuming bowman comes back healthy), while the cardinals have a pretty good secondary but a complete mystery at linebacker. How those two pass defenses perform, in comparison to each other, but also in comparison to their own past performance(tricky I know, since there's healthy regression/progression forces at work) will be interesting.

3
by Perfundle :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 5:22pm

I don't think we need to wait. Just look at Seattle 2012 compared to Carolina 2013. Seattle had a roughly average pass rush, perhaps even below average considering their sack totals were inflated by one half against Green Bay, and probably also by their secondary in the form of coverage sacks. Their coverage of intermediate routes was rather horrible, especially from Trufant. They finished 3rd in DVOA pass defense.

Carolina had elite pass rushing from their front 7, but when teams managed to neutralize it they could be thrown on, especially against the better offenses. They also finished 3rd in DVOA pass defense.

I think it's basically a draw, and beyond that it depends on the matchups. Seattle is weak against accurate mobile QBs that can extend plays beyond the time the secondary can cover (whereas Carolina is better at containing these QBs in the pocket), and Carolina is weak against receiving corps that can get open quicker than the pass rush can get there (whereas Seattle is better at pressing these receivers).

4
by theslothook :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 6:45pm

No I meant, coverage related to secondaries versus coverage through linebackers. Personally, I'm not a general believer that pass rush contributes as much to pass defense as people think. I think most people view pass rush as 50 percent of what makes a good pass d. I actually think its far less than that, maybe even less than 20 percent.

The rest falls on coverage, but what is coverage? WE have three position groups, corners, safeties, and linebackers. Can you do well with just one of the three or do you need all three? what about just having 2. And which is more valuable than others? These are all the questions I'm interested in. Seattle in 2014, to me, doesn't help because I think they have all 3. Pff rated both their lbs as good in coverage and we all know how good their safeties and corners are. Hell, even their pass rush is good.

5
by Perfundle :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 7:59pm

I'm not talking about Seattle in 2014 either, but I guess you mean which form of coverage is more effective behind the same pass rush? But in that case, if SF and Arizona don't have the same quality of pass rush their coverage won't be comparable. And again, it depends on the offensive scheme faced. Against Erhardt-Perkins offenses linebackers would be more important, whereas Air Coryell offenses stress the secondary more.

6
by theslothook :: Wed, 06/04/2014 - 8:07pm

Of course we can run a controlled experiment and yes the two pass rush fronts will be different. That said, it will still be a nice to see what the results are. I also agree that different schemes are defended better than others. That said, as Matt bowen indicated, most teams run the same kinds of route combinations, just varied by formations. In the end, when we do an aggregate of the two performances, I'll be curious to see how the results come out.

I suspect that pass coverage starts with the corners so I expect Arizona to field a stronger pass defense.

19
by Adrian--- :: Sat, 06/07/2014 - 2:06am

I think it starts with the corners because you can't consistently pressure the passer on three step drop patterns, it is up to the coverage to stop those. The longer the ball is in the pocket, the more important the pass rush becomes. Even the best corners will struggle to prevent a completion if the rush never gets there.

20
by theslothook :: Sat, 06/07/2014 - 3:52am

That all sounds good in theory, but I've run regressions controlling for that. In the end, coverage still plays a role no matter if its 3 sec or 4 sec. Fundamentally, even if we eliminate screens, pass pressure accounts for only 30 percent of the plays at most, and even these are highly skewed since pressure itself is correlated with qb play. It's hard to admit, but the whole thing is hard to disentangle.

7
by Thok :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 8:32am

I understand why you list the Niners biggest hole as cornerback (there isn't anything else that is a comparable issue), but it sure would be nice to have somebody cromulent at backup QB as an insurance policy in case Kaepernick misses a small number of games.

8
by Vince Verhei :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 12:29pm

Hey now. They traded a sixth for Blaine Gabbert. Problem solved.

12
by Thok :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 6:19pm

I think it's clear I don't consider Gabbert to meet the low line of cromulent.

15
by Karl Cuba :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 7:22pm

You don't think he embiggens the role of backup qb?

16
by Thok :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 10:23pm

I find it more likely he's a ruthless pirate who tried to assassinate George Washington.

18
by Rivers McCown :: Fri, 06/06/2014 - 12:51pm

Silver tongues for this entire thread.

9
by Karl Cuba :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 12:58pm

What's quite interesting about this article is that while Vince has described Brock as a liability, PFF nominated him as a secret superstar who ranked about 9th out of their qualifying cornerbacks with a good success rate.

Is a corner back being targeted on more than a quarter of passes aimed at a corner that high a rate? He was the third CB for most of the season and a starter for the last month. So wouldn't you expect him to be targeted on about a third of attempts against 49er cornerbacks?

I view Brock as a guy who makes some plays and gives a few up but he's still a decent young player, though the run tackle thing is bizarre over 600 snaps, even Asante Samuels would manage at least a couple in that span. I think Culliver, Brock and Ward are a good, young set of cornerbacks if we get a full year out of them.

However, it's probably worth pointing out that a couple of years ago PFF's secret superstar for the Vikings was current 49er corner Chris Cook and we know how that worked out for them.

10
by Vince Verhei :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 1:17pm

1) Generally speaking, nickelbacks will usually get a higher share of their team's targets. Still, Brock's target percentage was 12th-highest in the league, so even compared to other nickels he was picked on a lot.

2) His Success Rate and Yards/Target ranks were in the 20s and 30s, so by those metrics he was good, but nothing special.

3) Finding a "biggest need" on that roster was very, very hard. I am open to suggestions on a position that may have been a better choice.

11
by Karl Cuba :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 1:22pm

3) Errrrr... Offensive coordinator? Team legal representative?.... Gabbert?

13
by Perfundle :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 7:00pm

The 49ers need another Gabbert?

14
by Karl Cuba :: Thu, 06/05/2014 - 7:21pm

Nooooooo, more that the possibility of having to rely on Gabbert is the problem. (Though to be serious, decent backup qbs are rather few and far between)

17
by Sakic :: Fri, 06/06/2014 - 9:33am

The 2013 Packers whole-heartedly agree with that statement.

21
by tuluse :: Sun, 06/08/2014 - 2:02am

The 49ers can probably handle playing with the backup QB better than most. Just run 40 times and play defense.

Still, you'd almost rather see an undrafted free agent than Blaine Gabbert.