Or, go one step better and never corollate a team's record with a QB's worth? Seriously, if one argues that records and championships define a QB's value, then is that person really going to argue that Brady has gotten worse as a QB over the second half of his career? (using the dumb logic that Brady won 3 SB's in his first half decade, and hasn't won any SB's in the second half decade, therefore he must be worse than he used to be)
I agree to an even higher degree -- win-loss record is only a small part of a QB's value, often predicated on the abilities of the other, say 52 guys on a team.
Comments
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
mike, I thought you were contractually bound to pick the Giants every week. What gives?
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
He's laying the three strokes and still taking the Giants.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
The only Giant I'd take is the new "How to Get Hot Girls" girl. Nice!
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
Does this go in the Sunday newspaper? No analysis of Saturdays games?
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
They went up yesterday.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
If Dimitri Patterson is adequate, then he's an upgrade from Ellis Hobbs, right?
And my one concern for Baltimore is Joe Flacco's 1 TD/6 INT playoff record.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
Can we make it illegal to talk about a QB's playoff record until he's played, say, a dozen playoff games?
Thanks.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
Or, go one step better and never corollate a team's record with a QB's worth? Seriously, if one argues that records and championships define a QB's value, then is that person really going to argue that Brady has gotten worse as a QB over the second half of his career? (using the dumb logic that Brady won 3 SB's in his first half decade, and hasn't won any SB's in the second half decade, therefore he must be worse than he used to be)
I agree to an even higher degree -- win-loss record is only a small part of a QB's value, often predicated on the abilities of the other, say 52 guys on a team.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
To be fair Athelas was talking about Flacco's TD/INT record, not his win%.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
"DeSean Jackson often returns punts for the Eagles in high-pressure situations. But then, you knew that."
Wow. What an awesome line to for the New York Times. I wonder if the editors even caught it.
Re: NY Times: Sunday Wild Card Matchups
[T]he Flowers-Carr combo will be the Chiefs’ most important players when Flacco cocks his shoulder and launches.
What about when Flacco shoulders his...
Never mind.
Post new comment