Just in case Sunday night did not make it clear, defense rules the NFL in 2016. The best teams in overall DVOA all combine top-five defenses with below-average offenses. The Eagles now lead the league in both defense and special teams and are back to No. 1 overall.
01 Nov 2010
by Robert Weintraub
This will be something of a departure for OFI. I want to discuss the tragic death of Notre Dame student and videographer Declan Sullivan. Surely you heard about the incident. Sullivan was taping the Irish practice from a scissor lift, a temporary and often rickety structure. The practice was taking place in cyclonic conditions, and an enormous gust toppled the lift, killing Sullivan.
I have some experience with scissor lifts, and with asking colleagues to shoot from them. My day job is as a television producer, and I often have employed the use of the lifts to shoot sports and other functions. Just this weekend, while producing a documentary on the fabled "Marching 100," Florida A&M's spectacular band, we used a scissor lift for a brief time to capture the precise formations the band traces.
Therefore, I can say with full confidence that the death of Declan Sullivan was not only preventable, but should have been prevented, and that Notre Dame athletic director Jack Swarbrick and coach Brian Kelly should pay for the tragedy with their jobs.
Every professional cameraman has horror stories about shooting from scissor lifts. My guys this week all nodded grimly and knowingly when the news broke. No one was surprised. Many of them refuse to go up on a scissor lift in anything but perfect, windless conditions, such as those we had Saturday in Florida. And these aren't 'fraidy cats -- they have shot out the door of helicopters during boat races and jumped the wall in NASCAR pits and gotten in the way of angry bulls on rodeo shoots. Yet the idea that Sullivan would mount the scissor lift in conditions far from ideal shocked them.
Of course, a professional cameraman with 20 years of experience can refuse such an assignment. A student in thrall to Notre Dame football, and utterly at the mercy of the coach, cannot. That's why Kelly and Swarbrick are ultimately culpable for the death. I don't believe either was fully aware of the risks, nor were they callously disregarding Sullivan's safety. But as producer, I am responsible for everything that happens on my project. If I sent a cameraman to his doom in such a fashion, I wouldn't be able to look at myself, much less sweep it under the rug or chalk it up to fate. Kelly, and to a lesser extent Swarbrick, are responsible for all that happens on the practice field. Sullivan's death is on their hands.
And spare me the line about how "it was calm before the big gust that toppled the lift." I was in Florida and knew all about the windstorms raging through the Midwest. Again, scissor lifts have been known to topple in average breezes. There can be no doubt that sending anyone up under those conditions was an egregious mistake.
So it was with some satisfaction that I watched the Irish lose to the smallest school in the FBS, Tulsa. It wasn't just my knee jerk reaction to Notre Dame (root for the other team) at play. I didn't want Kelly to claim Sullivan's death gave his side a boost afterward, which would have been tawdry and small. As it happened, starting quarterback Dayne Crist was knocked out of the game and the season with a knee injury, and his replacement, Tommy Rees, made an error in judgment (a recurring theme in South Bend this week). Down 28-27 to the Golden Hurricane, Rees had the Irish in easy field-goal range. But with 36 seconds to play, Kelly called a pass. Rees mystifyingly threw off balance to the end zone. John Flanders had air-tight coverage on Michael Floyd, and intercepted, sealing the win for Tulsa. It was the singular result Rees had to avoid in that situation.
Kelly shoulders the blame for that call, just as he shoulders the blame for the tragedy during his practice.
Unfortunately, Declan Sullivan doesn't get a next week.
1. Boise State
8. Ohio State
16. Michigan State
17. Virginia Tech
19. Oklahoma State
20. South Carolina
22. Central Florida
23. Florida State
24. Mississippi State
1. Sio Moore, linebacker, UConn. He had 17 tackles, three tackles for loss, two forced fumbles, two fumble recoveries in the Huskies' historic win over West Virginia. His given name is Snorsio, in case you're curious.
2. Demond Washington, corner, Auburn. His 95-yard kickoff return touchdown not only cemented the win for the Tigers, but at the same time broke the school record for return yardage in a season. Washington also had a pivotal interception deep in his own territory.
3. Jabaal Sheard, defensive end, Pitt. He had two sacks and a pair of forced fumbles in the Panthers 20-3 whipping of Louisville.
4. Chase Minnifield, defensive back, Virginia. The whole Cavs defense played strong, but Minnifield's pair of pick -- including one on the play that Jacory Harris was knocked from the contest -- set the tone.
5. Jordan Holmes, center, Oregon. Another huge offensive performance by the Ducks, and another steady game by the line and its anchor. They never falter during Oregon's up-tempo attack, and they create huge holes for LaMichael James & Co.
15 comments, Last at 02 Nov 2010, 12:44pm by MaineMan