Writers of Pro Football Prospectus 2008

Most Recent FO Features

lionspackers.jpg

» Week 17 Game Previews

The FO crew previews three games in the final week of the season with critical playoff implications: Bengals-Steelers, Lions-Packers, and Panthers-Falcons.

02 Apr 2009

Walkthrough: Seamers

by Mike Tanier

Walkthrough completed the quiz "Which NFL quarterback are you?" with the result Bruce Gradkowski. Take the Quiz!

Click.

Allow Access? Allowing "Which NFL quarterback are you?" access will let us pull information from your profile, pictures, videos, hard drive, wedding album, tax return, and all desk drawers within six feet of your computer. Remember that elbow fetish site you visited eight months ago out of idle curiosity? Take this quiz, and all of America will know that you like a really big wenis.

Click.

Question 1: How much jewelry do you usually wear?

a) Three rings.
b) One ring.
c) One old ring from about 13 years ago.
d) No rings, not even ring tones.
e) Handcuffs.

Question 2: Which of the following do you enjoy doing the most?

a) Nailing supermodels.
b) Filming commercials.
c) Pondering retirement.
d) Skipping offseason workouts.
e) Electrocuting animals.

Question 3: Your worst enemy in the world would call you...

a) A guy who lost his competitive edge when he got married.
b) An overrated choke artist.
c) You have transcended the need for mortal enemies.
d) "My quarterback."
e) "Woof."

Question 4: You usually confront your problems by...

a) Throwing a screen to Wes Welker.
b) Creating an elaborate last-second plan to circumvent the problem.
c) Retiring.
d) Ignoring phone calls.
e) Running around in circles.

Question 5: Where do you see yourself in five years?

a) Foxboro.
b) Indianapolis.
c) Valhalla.
d) Detroit, Tampa ... anywhere but Denver.
e) Reality television.

Now, invite five other people to take the quiz! Comb your friend list and select five people to whom you can admit -- without feeling creepy or socially backward -- that you sit around taking random online quizzes. Then make them uncomfortable by inviting them to do the same, even though your real-world relationship with these so-called friends hasn't progressed beyond the "how you doin'?" stage.

You'll have to score your own quizzes and post your own results, folks. But if you answered "d" a lot, you may want to call a realtor.

Seams Simple

What do Jason Witten, Billy Miller, and Tony Scheffler have in common? Besides the fact that they are tight ends, smart guy?

The answer: They were among the best tight ends in the league at running the seamer last year.

The seamer (or seam route) is a deep pass pattern up the middle of the field, usually run by the tight end or a slot receiver. The receiver's goal is to attack the lane between two zone defenders. Even if the receiver doesn't get open, he creates space over the middle of the field by forcing the deep safeties to cover him.

You'll often read that a tight end possesses the "speed to stretch the seam," but there's no real way to measure how good a tight end is at running this particular route. That doesn't mean we cannot try. At Football Outsiders, we're awash in play-by-play data, as well as the results of our Game Charting projects. We don't specifically label plays as "seamers," but the official play-by-play categorizes each pass by location: short left, right, or middle; deep left, right or middle. It's a simple matter to sift through the data to find every pass thrown to a tight end in the deep middle of the field. Not all of these passes are seamers, and not every seam route will get labeled as a "deep middle" pass, but the data will give us a sense of how well the tight end works that area of the field.

Here are the numbers for all of the tight ends who were thrown five or more passes in the deep middle of the field in 2008:


Top Tight Ends on Deep Middle Routes, 2008
Player Team Att Comp Yards Y/A
Jason Witten DAL 10 7 193 19.3
Billy Miller NO 10 8 200 19.3
Tony Scheffler DEN 8 7 213 26.6
Dallas Clark IND 7 5 133 19.0
Vernon Davis SF 7 3 75 10.7
Mercedes Lewis JAC 7 5 121 17.3
Zach Miller OAK 7 5 160 22.9
Visanthe Shiancoe MIN 7 4 95 13.6
Chris Cooley WAS 6 5 128 21.3
Robert Royal BUF 5 5 118 23.6
L.J. Smith PHI 5 1 20 4.0

These are tiny data samples, so we shouldn't draw any major conclusions. The data can best be used to corroborate some opinions (Jason Witten is good) and make minor adjustments to other opinions (maybe Robert Royal is good at something).

Some surprising names were left off the list. Antonio Gates, for example, was just 1-of-3 in the deep middle of the field, for 25 yards. Kellen Winslow was 3-of-4 for 64 yards. Greg Olson was 2-of-2 for 40 yards. Tony Gonzalez was just 1-of-2. I checked the "deep right" and "deep left" data, and none of these guys were targeted deep very often last year. There are a variety of reasons: Winslow had quarterback issues, Gonzo is getting old, Gates played on a team with several deep-threat receivers. Again, we must be wary of the data sample: Only three or four passes separate these tight ends from the middle of the list. Players like Gates and Winslow would rank near the top of the chart if we look at two- or three-year windows: Winslow, for example, was 9-of-15 for 207 yards in the deep middle in 2007. Long-term analysis is a project for later in the spring, perhaps in a publication.

The data does add a little color to our knowledge of each team's offensive schemes. We're all familiar with Clark's and Witten's games, but it's easy to overlook how often the Saints throw over the middle to their tight ends. Miller caught eight seamers, and Jeremy Shockey was 3-of-4 over the middle for 72 yards. The Broncos loved to throw seamers last year as well. Both teams ran wide-open offenses with lots of empty backfield sets; with wide receivers running tunnel screens and working the short routes, it's easy to see how a good tight end would be able to slip into a coverage gap. And of course, both teams threw a million passes, so we would expect high totals in every passing category.

The presence of players like Davis, Lewis, Miller, and Shiancoe near the top of the list isn't surprising when you realize that these tight ends were often the best receivers on the field for their teams. Again, we can't draw massive conclusions from seven passes. Instead, we'll use the list as mild support for non-controversial conclusions: Miller is a pretty darn good player on a bad team, Davis is a talented disappointment, the Jaguars really need better receivers.

One last factoid before we move on: the average pass to a tight end over the deep middle travels about 18 to 22 yards in the air. That's confirmed by the 2007 Game Charting data. It's rare to see a pass thrown 30 yards to a tight end, and almost all 30-plus-yard receptions by tight ends are catch-and-run situations. That makes sense: tight ends like Gates, Witten, and Clark are fast enough to threaten a safety and force him to back up, but they aren't fast enough to beat a safety in a footrace to the deep post.

Why Tight Ends Go Deep

Figure 1: Strong TE Seam

The data above showed that even the best tight ends are only thrown about a dozen deep passes over the middle. So why is seam-splitting speed so darn important?

The answer lies in the split-second timing of pass route combinations. The tight end may not be the primary target when he runs the seam, but must be able to pull the deep safeties out of position. The threat of a pass up the deep seam is as important as the actual reception.

Figure 1 shows a route combination designed to beat a Cover-2 defense. The wide receiver, running an in-route at about 12 yards, is the primary target. The running back leaks into the flat to occupy the cornerback. The tight end runs a deep route directly at the safety. As drawn, this isn't technically a seam route, but it's a similar route with the same goal. In this example, the tight end is a speedster in the Gates/Witten class.

With a fast tight end running up the middle, the deep safety on the left must start to backpedal. The left linebacker, who's responsible for covering the tight end in the underneath zone, trades him off once he races through. Neither the safety nor the linebacker is in position to defend the in-route. Those three steps of backpedal by the safety make a huge difference in a play that takes about 2.5 seconds to unfold.

Figure 2: Weak TE Seam

In Figure 2, the tight end is much slower on his route. Here, the safety isn't forced to backpedal immediately, and the linebacker can take longer drifting back in underneath coverage. Both defenders are in much better position to make a play on the in-route. If the offensive coordinator doesn't feel that his tight end is fast enough to threaten that safety, he may have to scrap this play; without the backpedal, the safety could easily jump this route for an interception.

So seam-splitting speed is important, even if the tight end doesn't get the ball very much. That's why guys like L.J. Smith and Jerramy Stevens keep getting jobs: They may drop passes, fumble, and make mistakes, but coordinators want their downfield speed to open up the rest of the offense.

Kids With Blogs

Would you like a not-so-inside look at what makes some of this year's prospects tick? If so, check out Imatopprospect.com.

The concept is simple. Six highly-touted draftees -- K-State quarterback Josh Freeman, USC linebacker Brian Cushing, Connecticut cornerback Darius Butler, Maryland receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey, Ohio State linebacker James Laurinaitis, and Penn State defensive end Aaron Maybin -- join forces to blog about their pre-draft experiences in one convenient location. The sits is powered by "Ning," the latest social networking Facebook/Twitter wannabe, and is no doubt the brainchild of the players' agents.

As you might expect, this is hardly an unfiltered, uncensored look at the players' lives. Most of the blog entries are safe, tame, and bland; there's little doubt that an agent or handler checked each one before going live. The players work hard to be upbeat and to self-promote without sounding cocky. Each recounts the highlights of his offseason with peppy-but-measured enthusiasm.

"I guess it's safe to say that I absolutely crushed my Pro Day!" wrote Maybin on March 20. "I ran A 4.5 forty, I had a 10'10" broad jump, I had a 40.5" vertical, and I believe I excelled in my drills and interviews." Heyward-Bey was also upbeat. "Pro Day went smooth ... I went 14 for 15 on catches so I'd say that's a pretty solid day on the field." Freeman expressed eerily similar sentiments. "Pro Day was yesterday and I killed it! In a good way. Or so I hear." It would be interesting to see one of these kids explain away a 5.88 forty time or a shouting match with a scout, but don't hold your breath. For the record, the players' optimism was more or less matched by the independent opinions on various scouting sites.

There's a little more to the blogs than log rolling and smoke blowing. Freeman tracks his team visits and interviews: a workout with the Rams, dinner with the Jets coaches, a talk with Mike Shula in Jacksonville, and so on. Freeman's comings and goings can be tracked in local newspapers, and Freeman doesn't discuss many particulars of the meetings, but it's helpful to have all of his travels outlined in one place. USC linebacker Brian Cushing talks about his music ("Lil Wayne, 50 Cent, Jay-Z") and his diet ("6:30: a turkey souvlaki Greek sandwich wrap with celery. 8:30: salmon with a baked potato, with a little butter and broccoli"). Heyward-Bay admits that a prospect's life isn't all workouts and souvlaki. "My new found interest is Guitar Hero. I brought it 3 days ago and I'm already hooked. I've destroyed the medium and hard level. Now I have to tackle expert. Any takers?"

Cushing's diet and Heyward-Bay's guitar heroism may find themselves woven into my draft commentary. That's the danger these kids face: Anything they say can and will be used against them by hungry journalists. The little details of the blog help to humanize these prospects, which is a wonderful thing: Without the butter-broccoli potato, Cushing is just another height-weight-40 time with a few hours of game video and a mound of scouting jargon. But even benign details could come back to haunt a prospect, which is why these personal blogs are so oddly impersonal. If one of these kids were to do something rash, like post a photo of a girlfriend or make too-boastful a statement about his talents, the hyenas would swarm.

Sites like Imatopprospect.com will become far more common in the years to come. Prospects are forced to spout thousands of self-evident soundbytes before and after the draft. Instead of forcing them to say "I just want to get ready to help whatever team drafts me" a thousand times, they can type it once, add a few details about their favorite video games or sandwiches, then get back to lifting and running. Fans can keep track of their favorite players, writers can grab the tidbits or info they need, and agents can breathe easier knowing that they've streamlined the flow of quasi-information.

Plus, you do get those moments that remind you just how stressful the draft experience is for these 20-something kids. "Doing these personal team workouts and sitting around the house is all I do now. My friends are on spring break in warm weather states and I'm sitting in the house on call," wrote Heyward-Bey. "The only time I have to talk about how steep and rugged it is climbing up the mountain is when I reach the top," wrote Maybin.

These are young men in the midst of a grueling, sometimes dehumanizing process. We shouldn't begrudge them a little Guitar Hero.

Diagrams of the Past

I still haven't exhausted my supply of unused play diagrams from last year. In honor of Jay Cutler's imminent departure from Denver, this week's diagram features one of his biggest 2008 highlights: a 36-yard touchdown pass to Brandon Stokley against the Jets.

Figure 3: Broncos Stack Cross

The Jets are clearly showing blitz on this third-and-2 pass, and they run a stunt with a safety and linebacker on the offensive left. Their likely goal in a short yardage situation is to blow up any tomfoolery on that side, like a sweep or draw by Peyton Hillis (22) or a tunnel screen to Brandon Marshall (19). In fact, the Broncos appear to be setting up some kind of quick pass: Marshall motions toward the formation presnap, then runs underneath Stokley, who stems toward the cornerback as if he is preparing to block or run interference.

This play is successful because Marshall and Stokley sell their routes, and because the Broncos keep seven blockers in for protection. Hillis and the tight end create a safe rolling pocket, and Cutler can slide to his right to find a throwing lane. Marshall's feint worked perfectly: The safety covering Stokley moved forward to cover or tackle Marshall on the short route. When Marshall crossed back under Stokley, it created momentary confusion, and the safety was in no position to get deep. Good design, good read and throw by Cutler, good execution, touchdown.

Cutler will be gone by September, but plays like this will still be a part of the Broncos attack. Josh McDaniels was never shy about drawing up screens and fake screens in New England, and he'll have the raw materials to work with in Marshall, Eddie Royal, Tony Scheffler, and other weapons. If anything, the Broncos offense may grow even more spread-oriented than it was in the last days of Mike Shanahan.

All McDaniels needs is a quarterback who can run the system. He appeared to have one in Cutler. Cutler rode the hype roller coaster last year: He was a magazine cover boy in October, but the detractors lined up around the block when the Broncos missed the playoffs. Cutler had the worst 4,500-yard, 25-touchdown season in history, which is like being the ugliest centerfold or the dumbest nuclear engineer. DVOA and DYAR certainly thought he did pretty well. Cutler has his faults, but McDaniels' eagerness to alienate him appears to be inexperience/hubris/foolhardiness at this point. Young quarterbacks who can throw for 4,500 yards don't grow on trees, and they aren't sitting around in the middle of the draft board, either.

News and Notes

What will you be doing for the draft this year? Watching every pick with breathless anticipation? Following online or on the portable device of your choice? Actually enjoying the spring weather, knowing that all of the information you need will be available by Sunday evening?

If you answered A and B, then be sure to hang out on the Internet with me. I'll be in the Big Apple, live-blogging the big event for The New York Times. That's right: Walkthrough Takes Manhattan! I'll be following the picks, trades, and news, mixing scouting, jokes, and Football Outsiders wisdom all through the first two rounds.

I'm not the only FO writer blogging the big event. We'll be making a few more announcements over the next two weeks, but I'm only exaggerating a little when I say that FO will take over the Internet that weekend. There's no reason to be bored between picks; we'll keep you surfing, reading, and chatting all weekend long.

In other news, this is a great time to join Walkthrough Readers on Facebook. I'll be posting a few new topics on the message board. First, I want to know about your draft-day habits. How many of you watch the whole draft? Just the first round? Do you fold laundry and pay bills while watching the late rounds? Do you have a party? Drink? Play drinking games? Do you think watching the draft is ridiculous? Talk to other readers, and I may use some of the discussions in a future Walkthrough.

Second, I am looking for gamers, and I don't mean guys who play a little Madden. I am looking for Strat-o-Matic players, Statis Pro Players, and so on: guys who still harbor a love for tabletop or text-based football games. June is coming, and there isn't much real football to talk about during the dog days, so I'm looking for some old-school dice rollers and card flippers to share their experiences. Grab an old APBA card, roll a 66, wonder why linemen have a "kicker" rating, and get in the game!

Posted by: Mike Tanier on 02 Apr 2009

33 comments, Last at 14 Apr 2009, 4:04pm by German Physicist

Comments

1
by Temo :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 10:48am

Of course, then you give a guy like Martellus Bennett a Blog and you get some good stuff out of it.

Link: http://dmn.beloblog.com/cowboysinsiderblog/archives/2009/04/sooo-this-is...

"Then again, I'm a Bobby Carpenter believer." -- Barnwell

19
by Wait, what? (not verified) :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 1:20pm

Hah, that's awesome- thanks for the link. Marty B is the only member of the Cowboys organization I enjoy hearing from (unless I'm indulging in some schadenfreude after they lose). The amusement derived from seeing the comments of that weird subset of fans who think football players should only ever talk about football (lest they be termed "unprofessional") is a bonus.

23
by CathyW :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 10:13pm

That was really, really funny. And I'm a girl!

Thanks for sharing.

(Formerly known as PhillyCWC)

2
by Chris from CT (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 11:29am

Ahh, APBA football. My Dad still plays that game with a buddy of his - they do drafts, full seasons, etc. They still get new cards every year, but not sure if its from the original company.

3
by Theo :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 12:10pm

All I play is Blitz the League and the last card game I've played was poker.

4
by Aaron N (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 12:12pm

Mike - Will you be at Radio City? I go to the draft every year and was there last year blogging for my Packer site, Cheesehead TV. Would love to say hello...

5
by Danish Denver-Fan :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 12:32pm

Minor nit: Marshall is #15, and Royal is #19.

I watched all Bronco games last year except the Jacksonville game, and Sheffler was frequently running deeper routes than Marshall. Until he got injured, that is.

6
by Blotzphoto :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 12:48pm

Strat-o matic Football was my introduction to serious "Football Analysis". Also my introduction to the pain of draft day. I mean serious pain. I picked up a team in midseason 1988. It was horrible because it was based on the Vikings of the late 80's. IE, no Running backs. Much like Fantasy Football, Strat-o-matic revolves around RB play. So going into the 1989 draft with the first pick, there was no secret who I was gonna take, Elbert L. "Ickey" Woods. Now I would be pairing two hometown heroes in Ickey and Boomer Esiasons MVP season. I looked like a dynasty waiting to happen. Then in August Ickey Woods shuffled his knee off. And I still picked him, because as the guys at BP say, flags fly forever. I made it our Superbowl only to lose to a Buffalo team who ran back two kicks and a reverse for TD's.

7
by AnonymousToo! (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 1:05pm

Besides the Royal/Marshall number swap, your diagram of the Cutler play keeps referring to the offensive left and rolling left, but everything shown is on the offensive right. You also call Hillis by the new name "Hiller" at one point. Perhaps walkthrough could use a readthrough?

8
by Chris (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 1:43pm

Look at the 4 quarterbacks of those top deep pass catching TE's. Romo, Brees, Cutler, and P.Manning....

Why do teams throw to TE's over the deep middle? Because most teams play cover 2, and in the cover 2 the middle of the field is one of the main places you want to attack ( besides the deep outsides).

Tanier, can you keep giving the players nicknames? It's so funny and amusing ant it makes reading your stuff enjoyable. You should quit your day job and just be a comedian.

9
by Chris (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 1:45pm

Look at the 4 quarterbacks of those top deep pass catching TE's. Romo, Brees, Cutler, and P.Manning....

Why do teams throw to TE's over the deep middle? Because most teams play cover 2, and in the cover 2 the middle of the field is one of the main places you want to attack ( besides the deep outsides).

Tanier, can you keep giving the players nicknames? It's so funny and amusing and it makes reading your stuff enjoyable. You should quit your day job and just be a comedian. Make more of your articles jokes, and less football information because that is why we come to this site.

10
by Vincent Verhei :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 1:52pm

"Hiller" is now "Hillis," and the Broncos are moving to the right. I left the number swap in because I'm not sure whether the numbers are swapped, or the names.

14
by AnonymousToo! (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 4:55pm

But the stunt is still said to be on the offensive left, when really it's on the right.

Small detail, of course, but then again that's kind of what FO is about. If one is going to bother diagramming and dissecting plays, might as well correctly describe what happens. This isn't TMQ, after all.

From context, it seems clear that Marshall is supposed to be on the right, so it's the numbers and not the names that should be swapped.

16
by Danish Denver-Fan :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 5:15am

What context? The tunnel screen? I guess a screen can be to both a speedster like Royal and a mountain like Marshall. From the highlights on NFL.com it's very hard to tell. The guy running the curl(y)route on the left looks to be #19, but his height and long strides suggest it's Marshall...

11
by redonkulous (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 2:37pm

Rats. I was hoping Winslow would be a Cleveland Seamer.

13
by Tundrapaddy (not verified) :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 4:52pm

Oy vey.

12
by mrh :: Thu, 04/02/2009 - 4:43pm

Chiefs' lore: September 29, 2002 Mia @ KC. Dolphins played a cover-2 defense all-day, and gave Tony G a free release all afternoon. Result: 7/140 3 TDs. This is based on what the radio announcers were saying as I didn't see the game live, so take it for what it's worth. But I'll bet if you listen to the Chiefs' broadcasts in 2009 it'll come up at some point that Tony hasn't seen a free release or conventional cover-2 scheme since that day. Which is probably an exaggeration but points out that there is a difference between being able to run a "seamer" effectively and being allowed to because the defense opts to shut down other threats. Oh and that Trent Green and the Chiefs line circa 2002 was a different animal than Tyler Thigpen and the line last year, which probably dictated a lot of Tony's patterns.

Good stuff.

15
by tuluse :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 1:15am

Cutler had the worst 4,500-yard, 25-touchdown season in history, which is like being the ugliest centerfold or the dumbest nuclear engineer

Isn't Homer Simpson a nuclear engineer? (or is it nuculear?)

17
by jebmak :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 12:37pm

Nuculer, it's pronounced nuculer.

29
by John Walt :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 3:37pm

I hope that's sarcasm. It's pronounced new-clear

30
by tuluse :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 4:43pm

You don't watch a lot of the Simpsons do you?

18
by Wait, what? (not verified) :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 1:06pm

My answers: D C B E E

Which makes me... Donovan McNabb! Sigh.

22
by EaglesFan (not verified) :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 6:08pm

HaHa. Were you hoping to see a McNabb for Cutler trade too???

(big shout out to the Cleveland Seamer comment!)

20
by TomC :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 3:27pm

God I love the tight end down the seam. (Yes, that sounds bad, but I don't care.) When the Bears drafted Olsen, I thought: "Finally, here we go." But, as Mike points out, they only tried it twice all last season. The only reason I can imagine for not running it more often is lack of faith in the pass protection ('cause you can't max-protect when you're sending your TE deep). I really hope that with an improved OL and a QB that can extend plays with his feet, that we'll see the seamer as a fundamental part of the Bears' offense this year. You hearin' me, Ron?

21
by tuluse :: Fri, 04/03/2009 - 4:34pm

they only tried it twice all last season.

Not quite, all this shows is that Orton only threw it him on that route twice.

24
by TomC :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 12:34am

Fair enough. But I want it to be a bread-and-butter play in the Cutler era.

27
by tuluse :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 3:24pm

Well the most common of any team was 10 attempts. As Tainer points out, this route is more about freeing up other receivers than actually throwing the seam route.

32
by Jimmy :: Mon, 04/06/2009 - 6:55am

The Cutler era thingy needs changing to before Cutler and after Cutler. BC and AC for easy reference. Only mildly blasphemous but then again I am not religious.

25
by Felton (not verified) :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 1:17pm

Interesting also is that few of the top TEs in "deep middle attempts" played in this season's playoffs. I'd like to see Shockey healthy, but I was never a fan of the Shockey trade to the Saints - too high a price and not enough return is no way to go through life. Reminds me of the great Saints signing of Dave Parks in 1968. Billy Miller's alright with me.

26
by JQ (not verified) :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 3:18pm

The description on the home page doesn't really make sense. It basically says "which tight end has caught the most deep over the middle passes the answer might surprise you" and then shows Witten. With the answer being Witten and him being the answer in no way is surprising when you read the article

28
by tuluse :: Sat, 04/04/2009 - 3:27pm

Billy Miller caught the most.

31
by Anonymous1 (not verified) :: Sun, 04/05/2009 - 8:31pm

I love a hot route to my tight end, especially when we're not using max protection.

33
by German Physicist (not verified) :: Tue, 04/14/2009 - 4:04pm

You're both wrong. It's pronounced either of two ways:

Main Entry:
nu·cle·ar
Pronunciation:
\ˈnü-klē-ər,
ˈnyü-, ÷-kyə-lər\

And it's certainly NOT pronounced New-Clear like John Walt said. Epic Fail.