Audibles at the Line

Unfiltered in-game observations by Football Outsiders staff

Audibles at the Line: Week 17

compiled by Andrew Potter

Each Sunday, the FO staff sends around emails about the games that each of us are watching. We share information about the games that the rest of the group might not be watching, ask questions, and keep everyone else informed about which games they might want to tune into (if they can).

On Monday, we compile a digest of those emails and produce this feature. By its nature, it can be disjointed and dissimilar to the other articles on the site.

While these e-mails are generally written with Audibles in mind, they do not represent a standard review of all the games each week. That means we aren't going to cover every game, or every important play. We watch the games that we, as fans, are interested in watching, so your favorite team's game might not be covered to your fullest desires or even at all. (If you are a Steelers or Patriots fan, you are probably in luck; if you are a Bills fan, not so much.) We have no intention of adding new authors solely to cover every game on a given Sunday, nor will we watch a different game from the ones that we're personally interested in watching just to ensure that Audibles covers every game.

Cleveland Browns 24 at Pittsburgh Steelers (AAA) 28

Bryan Knowles: Week 17 did not break very well for the NFL -- the playoff races that still do matter are so intertwined that there's no Sunday night game, and they couldn't even evenly distribute the two wild-card races throughout the day because they (rightly) didn't want to make Seattle-Arizona a 10 a.m. local time game with a playoff spot on the line. That's unfortunate.

It also means this might be the least meaningful early Week 17 window in modern NFL history. Exactly one thing can be clinched this morning: home-field advantage in the AFC. If the Jets can upset the Patriots and the Steelers knock off the Browns, Pittsburgh would leapfrog New England and have the chance to host the AFC title game at their place.

To show you how important that really is, look at Pittsburgh's inactive list. Ben Roethlisberger, Le'Veon Bell, Maurkice Pouncey, David DeCastro, Antonio Brown, Cameron Heyward and Coty Sensabaugh. That's a pretty good list of talent who won't even have jerseys on today! And how annoyed will they be if the Jets DO manage to give the Patriots a game -- remember, the Pats lost to Miami and the Jets knocked off Jacksonville, so it's not as crazy as it sounds -- but they end up losing to the Browns because all their stars are sitting on the bench? A weird white flag from Pittsburgh; is the need for two weeks' rest more important than potentially avoiding the Patriots in New England (not to mention getting Kansas City or Baltimore in the divisional round rather than Jacksonville)?

Dave Bernreuther: I'm sure pundits everywhere have already covered this, but I just don't understand why the Steelers couldn't have at least dressed those players and sent them out to start the game with their eye on the scoreboards, ready to pull them whenever a) New England had the game in hand and/or b) they had the game in hand. I mean, it's the Browns. Two or three good drives on offense ought to be enough to put them away and pull your starters.

Honestly, I'm sort of rooting for the doomsday scenario to happen to them now so that they're punished for it. And if they come out flat in the first half in two weeks, well, it won't be the first time we've seen that happen in the playoffs. They were sort of the beneficiaries of it 12 years ago, as I recall.

At least this gives Browns fans something to root for.

Bryan Knowles: The Rams sitting their starters makes a lot more sense -- the difference between No. 3 and No. 4 is much less important than 1 vs. 2, they could still get the No. 3 seed even if they lost if the NFC South breaks right, and a week of rest (and lack of injuries) is probably more significant than the difference between Saints or Panthers and Seahawks or Falcons.

But good lord, it's not like the Steelers have historic problems with the Patriots or a very solid home-field advantage on special teams or anything, right? Mmm. Mmm mmm mmm.

Carl Yedor: There is one other thing that can be clinched in the early slate: Minnesota hasn't officially clinched the 2 seed in the NFC, though it would take a very unlikely series of events for them to not get that first-round bye. If Carolina wins and Minnesota, New Orleans, and the Rams all lose, the Panthers would jump all the way to the 2 seed because of their head-to-head win against the Vikings a few weeks ago.

But yes, that's so unlikely that it might as well already be wrapped up.

Bryan Knowles: Even that, the Vikings can't actually lose in the early games; the NFL didn't feel it important enough to shift Minnesota's start time to match those other three and crowd the late schedule even more. If the NFL doesn't think it's important, I'll agree!

Scott Kacsmar: Well, I guess the Steelers have already thrown away the No. 1 seed once this year. I think what the Steelers are doing today is absolutely ridiculous. If the roles were reversed with New England, there's no way in hell Bill Belichick would blow off this game when there was still slim hope for the No. 1 seed. Start your studs for a half, get a lead, and then you can rest them. Oh yeah, they can also rest when you have a bye week already locked up. Do you really want to be like the 2005 Colts and 2011 Packers and come out rusty (as offensive-driven teams too) because you gave your studs an extra week off? Not to mention that first matchup could be with Jacksonville's defense. The Steelers have never lost a game in team history at home with a 14-point lead. That should be easily attainable in a half of work against this Cleveland team with your normal roster in there.

I also think dropping your rival to 0-16 is a nice goal to complete. I feared last year that Cleveland might avoid 0-16 by beating the Steelers' backups in Week 17, but the Browns added to Chargers' BINGO the week before, then blew an overtime lead in Pittsburgh anyway. But it was 14-0 early and Landry Jones could hand a team a game. What happens if Jones gets hurt and you have to put Josh Dobbs in the game today since Ben Roethlisberger is inactive? What if the Jets are actually keeping it interesting in New England too? It's just a wimpy move today. The No. 1 seed carries more importance than playing in fear of injury.

Bryan Knowles: One of the few players Pittsburgh IS playing today is Darrius Heyward-Bey, who takes an end-around and romps 29 yards for a score, placing Pittsburgh in the top seed slot for … about 3 minutes before the Patriots respond with a Dion Lewis touchdown. With all the talk about starters sitting and backups starting, it is, perhaps, good to remember that the Cleveland Browns are still the Cleveland Browns. There's a reason they're 0-15!

Dave Bernreuther: Just like we all predicted half an hour ago, the Landry Jones-led Steelers have taken care of business, jumping out ahead of the Browns... (eye roll emoji).

Landry Jones didn't have much to do except hand it off on the trickery that sprung Heyward-Bey for the 7-0 start, and DeShone Kizer is still DeShone Kizer, and he went straight backwards on his first drive, giving the Steelers the ball back at midfield. Jones returned the favor with a pick, but if you blinked you missed the next Browns drive. it gets even better, though. A JuJu Smith-Schuster catch short of the sticks at the 7 leads to an overly conservative field goal call ... at which point the Browns jumped offsides. This is why you're 0-15, guys. Four rushes fail to score, though, so amazingly, the offsides saved the Browns three points. Can someone check in on Scott and make sure he's safe? Because this game is already driving me nuts and I don't actually care.

Vince Verhei: So, some Cleveland notes in the first quarter:

  • They ran eight plays in the first quarter. Four of those plays lost yardage.
  • They took a delay of game on their first punt. Because they haven't had enough practice on getting the punt team on the field this year.
  • DeShone Kizer called timeout with two seconds left in the quarter. So there would not have been a delay of game penalty anyway. But even if there had been, the Browns were at their own 1. Put it all together and Kizer called timeout to avoid a non-existent half-yard penalty.
  • The defense had a neutral zone infraction penalty that turned a Pittsburgh field goal attempt into a Pittsburgh first down.

That last one actually worked out in the Browns' favor, because it led to a goal-line stuff on fourth down. But the fact remains that Cleveland's starters are getting walloped by Pittsburgh's backups. Landry Jones just hit JuJu Smith-Schuster for a 20-yard touchdown to put the Steelers up 14-0 early in the second quarter.

Signs of life from Cleveland's passing game in the second quarter. First, Josh Gordon runs a post-corner for a 54-yard gain inside the 5 to set up a Duke Johnson touchdown run. Then, Rashard Higgins runs a skinny post out of the slot, breaks a tackle, and splits the safeties playing Cover-2 for what's officially a 56-yard catch-and-run touchdown, with most of those yards coming after the catch. Kizer's halftime statline is funny -- He's averaging 26 yards per completion and 10 yards per throw, but he has only completed 5-of-12 passes and has also taken four sacks. He's also the team's leading rusher with 18 yards on two carries. The Browns have 110 yards on those two big catches and 27 yards on their other 23 plays. It's very obvious that Kizer should have stayed in school and had no business playing in the NFL this year, but I still see more potential here than in the Paxton Lynches or Blaine Gabberts or Matt Cassels who have also played this year.

Meanwhile, the Steelers are averaging almost 9 yards per pass play and more than 6 yards per run and still lead 21-14 at half.

Touchdown Browns! Cleveland looks like an honest-to-god pro football team on their first drive of the second half, going 68 yards in seven plays and only once getting to third down. Biggest play was David Njoku catching a short curl, breaking a tackle, and running into the red zone for 34 yards. Kizer then hit Higgins on an out route for a 5-yard touchdown, and we're tied at 21. There's a win to be had here, fellas!

Bryan Knowles: And that Browns tie game lasts about 10 seconds, as JuJu Smith-Schuster breaks five tackles on his way to a kick return touchdown. Oh, Browns.

Vince Verhei: You can't stop DeShone Kizer, you can only hope to contain him. He runs for a first down on third-and-15, then converts a third-and-17 with a dig route to Corey Coleman. The drive stalls there, but Zane Gonzalez hits a 51-yarder (in Pittsburgh!) to make it 28-24. This is just the third time all year the Browns have scored 24 points; their season high was 28 at Indianapolis in Week 3.

Wait. I was wrong. You CAN stop DeShone Kizer. He had gotten away with at least two dropped interceptions earlier in the game, but the Steelers made him pay on their third chance. Sean Davis cuts in front of Njoku for a diving grab to give Pittsburgh a first down in Cleveland territory. Their offense has been shut out this half, but a touchdown here ends the game.

Cleveland's year started with a close loss to Pittsburgh that was decided in part by a Steelers touchdown on special teams, and it's looking like it could end the same way.

Bryan Knowles: OOOOH, Browns. fourth-and-2, 0-for-season on the line, Kizer makes a great play in a collapsing pocket to find space, finds Corey Coleman wide open for the first down and more ... and the ball flies right through his hands. Oh, Browns. Oh, oh Browns.

Two timeouts left, but...

Vince Verhei: And the Browns go to 0-16 in the most Cleveland way possible. They have a fourth-and-2 in Pittsburgh territory. Kizer drops back, steps up, but hesitates, and the rush gets to him. But somehow he slips out and finds Coleman for what should have been a first down in the red zone ... but Coleman drops the pass. No excuse on that one, that came in right in his face and he still took his eye off it. Unreal.

Just putting the Browns season to bed: yes, they went 0-16, but Sashi Brown leaves them in better shape than when he took over. That's a very good defensive front, and they have 12 picks in seven rounds in next year's draft -- including, officially, the first and fourth overall selections. Jimmy Haslam has repeated that Hue Jackson won't be fired, which I don't get, but they at least have a foundation to build around for the first time in maybe forever.

Andrew Potter: "There'll be actual real live players / It'll be totally strange / But wow! Am I so ready for this change ... Don't know if I'm elated or gassy / But I'm somewhere in that zone!"

Rivers McCown: Owner Jimmy Haslam said he retained Hue Jackson because he thinks he "hasn't lost his magic." Uh, sure. Preparing to use Ricardo Louis and Rashard Higgins extensively is a form of Vancian Magic, I suppose.

Chicago Bears 10 at Minnesota Vikings 23

Bryan Knowles: With so little going on in the early games, the Vikings-Bears game might be the closest we have to a marquee matchup. That makes me sad, but hey, at least I get a full dose of Mitchell Trubisky before forgetting he exists for six months. I remember back when Dalvin Cook went down, we all went "oh no, here comes the bad luck for the Vikings yet again," but Latavius Murray's had a fairly solid season in reserve -- better than Jerick McKinnon, at any rate. You might guess that Ezekiel Elliott and LeGarrette Blount have the most rushing touchdowns since 2016; Murray being in third place, with 19 thanks to his early touchdown today, is somewhat more surprising.

Yeah, don't stay up too late worrying about the Vikings' bye week chances. They're up 14-0 after Murray's second touchdown of the day. The Bears have zero rushing yards and just one first down in the first quarter. Trubisky's 5-for-6 … for 38 yards. Zzzzzz. To RedZone it is; there's just nothing going on in this terrible window…

… except for some trickeration! Vikings are forced to punt deep in their own territory, and the Bears do one of my favorite special teams plays. Everyone on their punt return unit starts fading to the left sideline, as if the punt is spiraling away in that direction. Minnesota follows, of course -- but the ball has actually been going to the other side of the field, where Bryce Callahan fields it and has a wide open lane to the end zone. That might have been the most clever play of the entire Bears season, which is saying something in and of itself.

You know, when the Bears hired John Fox before the 2015 season, it felt like a really, really solid move. He was bringing with him Vic Fangio and Adam Gase, top coordinators and potential head coach candidates at the time. Yeah, Fox wasn't particularly good at getting his teams over the top in the playoffs, but he helped turn both the Panthers and Broncos into playoff contenders. I really thought that would happen again in Chicago -- that we'd see a return to respectability, at least. Instead, well ... they had a -13.8% DVOA the year before Fox was hired, and they're sitting at -15.3% coming into today. Fans here in Chicago were so excited -- and it just ended up being bupkis. Now, they're stuck looking for an offensive-minded coach who feels like he can develop Trubisky, possibly to the point where he can throw to both sides of the field. Plus, they'd love to get someone who Fangio is fine working with, which makes the search that much more difficult. Been a long four years in the wilderness for the Bears.


Aaron Schatz: Wow. Vikings essentially with THREE goal-line stands today in the fourth quarter.

At the start of the fourth quarter, the Bears made it down to first-and-goal at the 6. Four straight incomplete passes.

Then with four minutes left, the Bears got to the 12. They made it to third-and-2 from the 4, incomplete pass to Dontrelle Inman. So the Vikings need to stop them on fourth down for the goal-line stand. Instead, Danielle Hunter gets himself a neutral zone infraction. That gives the Bears four more shots from the 2, which is why it's "essentially" and not "definitely" three goal-line stands.

So from the 2, we go:

  • Jordan Howard, run for no gain.
  • Pass to fullback Michael Burton, no gain.
  • Incomplete slant to Tarik Cohen, lined up at slot receiver.
  • Pass to Cohen coming out of the backfield, tackled at the 1.

New York Jets 6 at New England Patriots 26

Aaron Schatz: On the first play that they used James Harrison, the Patriots dropped him into coverage. The Jets then had big gains on three straight plays, but all to the other side of the field, away from Harrison, so not his fault. Then the Jets offense remembered they were in fact the Jets, went backwards on two plays, and Bryce Petty couldn't connect on a swing pass on third-and-19. How do you not throw that pass accurately? Field goal, now 7-3 Patriots, end first quarter.

The Patriots offense has completely slowed to a crawl after the initial easy touchdown drive. Now on their fourth drive since, they just got a first down from defensive holding and I think that's just the second first down on these four drives. Brady's just missed guys deep a couple of times; other times, he's gone down quickly with a strong pass rush from the Jets. The Jets look like they are playing a lot of man coverage with a double bracketing Gronk, and that's led to zero targets for Gronk in the first 25 minutes of the game.

And since I typed that, the Patriots have a couple more first downs, including a long one just now with DPI by rookie safety Marcus Maye on Brandin Cooks. Pats will be in the red zone again with a 7-3 lead.

Addendum: Pats make it a 14-3 lead on a 5-yard touchdown pass to Cooks when two Jets defenders run into each other leaving him wide open.

Dave Bernreuther: Not only did they leave Cooks wide open, they left Danny Amendola open as well. Brady could easily have gone to him as well.

One drive and a Petty sack later and we can consider Tomlin off the hook. The Patriots aren't blowing an 11-point lead at home to Bryce Petty.

Aaron Schatz: Pats now up to a 21-3 lead after a little swing pass touchdown to Dion Lewis. Earlier in the drive, the Patriots ran a reverse with Brady flipping it to Philip Dorsett, who flipped it to Cooks going the other way. How many times does an announcer call an end-around a reverse by mistake? This time, Jim Nantz actually had a chance to call a revers e... and he called it an end-around! You missed your chance, buddy!

If the Pats blow a 21-3 lead at home to Bryce Petty with home-field advantage on the line, that might pass the Bills' 2004 loss to the Pittsburgh backups as the worst regular-season loss in FO history. So I'm feeling pretty good about my decision to stay home from Gillette in order to pay maximum attention to the 4:30 games.

Vince Verhei: Imagine how bad Christian Hackenberg must be if the Jets won't even put him in the game today.

Houston Texans 13 at Indianapolis Colts 22

Rivers McCown: All the hangover of New Year's Day without the waiting for 24 hours. Alfred Blue! A dead Colts team that will fire its coach! Some other guys! It's 10-7 Texans in the second.

Tom Gower: 13-7 at the half. Week 17 Colts is Week 17 Colts defense (Corey Grant of the Jaguars had 100 yards rushing against them last year). T.J. Yates looks vaguely NFL quarterback-ish, even with DeAndre Hopkins inactive and Will Fuller declared out early with a knee injury so serious it doesn't prevent him from standing on the sidelines. My favorite part of the first half was when I flipped over to Eagles-Cowboys briefly and saw Nate Sudfeld trip over his own feet trying to scramble. I should try harder to find a different game to watch. The chapters in Football Outsiders Almanac 2018 about these teams will almost certainly end up a lot on the quarterbacks not playing today.

Dave Bernreuther: Tom, that's Week 1-16 Colts defense too, though.

I really thought they'd bring a better effort as a sendoff for Chuck. For all his failings in recent years, he's a good dude and the players love him. But at least they're doing the 2018 Colts a favor and not screwing up the draft order. With the Giants playing well right now, things could be shaping up well for them.

At the time of the touchdown to Jack Doyle, Jacoby Brissett was somehow 8-of-9 with only one sack. He's back to himself now. And they have a total of 56 passing yards and 73 total after a half, which is no way to get out to a blow-able halftime lead.

People have loved to talk about the Colts defense as the reason for all the blown halftime leads, but I'll actually take the contrarian approach of blaming the offense. With the exception of the 49ers game, the reason the Colts blow leads is because by halftime, the other team has figured out Brissett and what they're doing, and the Colts offense is dead in the water. Nobody likes Chudzinski, but he's at least doing pretty well in the start of games to craft a game plan that lets Brissett do pretty well. He's just not that good yet, though, so it can only last so long.

I never say anything nice about these Colts, so let me just take a second to praise Frank Gore, who is running hard and still looks young. He's, what, fifth all-time in rushing? He's NEVER hurt. And he's at the point where he can go year to year on contracts ... is there any reason not to re-sign him next year, even if his role diminishes?

Also, kudos to Chuck for the surprise onside kick that the 2-14 2011 Colts were mysteriously too afraid to try last time the team sucked and was playing out the string. They didn't recover, but I liked the message. (Or I would, anyway, were I not hoping they'd lose the game and have the leverage of the No. 2 pick.)

I jinxed Frank Gore AND the Colts' chances to lose. Brilliant. And Chuck Pagano gets to go out with a win after all. Good for him.

Rivers McCown: Rick Smith stepped down after the game to spend time with his wife, who has breast cancer. Smith has fairly taken a lot of criticism over the years -- the bottoms of his rosters were horrific and he avoided responsibility for it for many years -- but he's also the guy who found DeAndre Hopkins and Deshaun Watson after the first 10 picks. I think it's probably best for both sides if he moves on.

Dallas Cowboys 6 at Philadelphia Eagles 0

Rivers McCown: That NFC fourth seed looks a little more tempting for the Rams every time Nick Foles drops back.

Bryan Knowles: This game is scoreless at halftime. That hasn't happened since 2011, when the stoppable force of the Tim Tebow Broncos met the movable object of the Caleb Hanie Bears. My kingdom for some points! The highlight of this game is the Eagles' punter forgetting to take his sweatpants off before stepping onto the field.

We're still scoreless after three quarters. Last time that happened was 2007, with the Matt Moore Carolina Panthers taking on the ... Matt Hasselbeck Seahawks. OK, good teams sometimes have off days, too.

Just saying -- the most common tie score in NFL history is 0-0, though it hasn't happened since 1943. After the Browns fighting for 1-15, that might be the most interesting thing to watch for the rest of these early games.

Carolina Panthers 10 at Atlanta Falcons 22

Derrik Klassen: Steve Sarkisian threw to his backs a lot on Atlanta's first drive of the game, ultimately resulting in Devonta Freeman taking a quick dump-off pass to the house. Aside from Julio Jones, the two running backs are Atlanta's best weapons. Hopefully Sark sticks to it and continues to feed his playmakers.

Aaron Schatz: I don't know where else to mention it so let me just say that I watched ESPN Countdown for the first time all year today and Charles Woodson could not stop referring to the Atlanta running back as "Tevin Campbell."

Panthers are 12th in DVOA against running backs as receivers, and held Atlanta's backs to just 37 receiving yards in first meeting. Falcons don't care, getting big chunks with passes to Freeman and Coleman today.

Bryan Knowles: Carolina's really struggling getting anything going to the wideouts. Cam Newton's 0-for-5 to start the game; Atlanta's all over them at every turn. Pressure's helping, especially pressure that doesn't let Newton gallop through miles of open space. Really impressed with Atlanta's defensive performance so far.

Vince Verhei: Cam Newton is 0-for-his-first-9 passes. Awesome. Swell.

Aaron Schatz: With 7:04 left in the second quarter, Newton finally completed his first pass for positive yardage. The Falcons defense has been ferocious today, with defensive linemen winning at the line of scrimmage and defensive backs jumping routes. It looks like they spent a LOT of time watching film this week.

Scott Kacsmar: This is Devonta Freeman's 64th game (including playoffs). He has seven catches in the first half. He's had six games in his career with at least seven catches coming into today. The 64 receiving yards are already his fifth-most in a game. I saw some checkdowns, but maybe Atlanta saw something it likes. Been a lot of talk about the lack of receiving from the backs this year compared to last year under Kyle Shanahan.

Aaron Schatz: Right guard Amini Silatolu, filling in for Trai Turner, was nice enough to invite Super Bowl edition Grady Jarrett back for a special encore performance today.


Bryan Knowles: Carolina needed a big play, and they finally got one. After his first 10 pass attempts got -3 yards, Newton complete four passes of 10 yards or longer, including a huge conversion on third-and-23 after Super Bowl Grady Jarrett had an 11-yard sack on the previous play. It leads to a fairly easy touchdown to Devin Funchess on a slant, and we have a ball game here. Finally. Someone tell Seattle!

Some time management issues at the half here. Atlanta hit a long pass with time running out to put them into field goal range, but couldn't get up to spike the ball in time, says the refs. I actually think they beat the clock, but you can't review that with less than two seconds, apparently, so we have a 7-7 half. We'll see if that missed field goal opportunity factors in, though with the Seahawks floundering, the Falcons seem alright either way.

The Panthers are putting Matt Ryan under plenty of duress -- five hits and quite a few hurries -- but he's performing well under pressure. That's key, because the Falcons are getting zip in the running game; nine carries for 26 yards isn't exactly a key part of your offense. Julio Jones has just two catches, as the Falcons focus on feeding the ball to Freeman through the air over and over again. Hey, whatever works, I suppose.

Aaron Schatz: I don't know another team that matches linebackers on slot receivers as much as the Panthers. Falcons are in the red zone and Luke Kuechly is just isolated on Mohamed Sanu, no biggie.

Bryan Knowles: Terrible, terrible, TERRIBLE interception for the Panthers. I don't even think it was fully on Cam Newton; I think Devin Funchess broke off his route. At least, that's the only explanation that makes any sense, because otherwise, Newton just threw the ball right to Ricardo Allen.

Aaron Schatz: Christian McCaffrey has four carries for 13 yards. On the season he has 115 carries for 434 yards, and is barely over replacement level in the FO stats. I know he has been a valuable receiver, but the Panthers seem to have no ability to scheme runs that fit his talents, so it's like they barely even try. Even with Jonathan Stewart out in this game, Cameron Artis-Payne has more carries so far.

Bryan Knowles: Carolina punting down two scores with six minutes left is a pretty big white flag. Seahawks fans have every right to be annoyed with that, but hey, the Panthers don't need to go all out, I suppose. They're only down two scores because Atlanta gambled and attempted a 56- yard field goal -- had they missed, Carolina would have been in great field position and down just a score. That long field goal was probably the nail in Seattle's coffin.

Aaron Schatz: Cam Newton just sailed the ball to Greg Olsen, high and behind Olsen, and Olsen leapt up and it went off his fingers and into the hands of Keanu Neal on the tip drill. Newton has been sailing passes all day, especially when targeting Olsen. That might be ballgame with four minutes left and only one timeout for the Panthers.

Arizona Cardinals 26 at Seattle Seahawks 24

Vince Verhei: Watching the Seahawks and Panthers games side-by-side, needing both teams to win for Seattle to get into the playoffs. So of course Atlanta and Arizona both get opening-drive touchdowns just a few seconds apart. Arizona's came on a bevy of good runs and short completions, then was finished when Drew Stanton was able to outrun Michael Bennett in the backfield, and Jaron Brown had an eternity to run from one sideline to the other in the end zone for the 25-yard score.

Tyler Lockett then returns the ensuing kickoff for a touchdown to tie things up at 7-all.

Carl Yedor: About as good/bad of a start for Atlanta/Seattle as you can think of, with Atlanta and Arizona both scoring on their opening drives of the game.

But then before I can finish typing, Tyler Lockett returns the ensuing kickoff for a touchdown in Seattle. Tie ballgame there, still 7-0 in Carolina.

Andrew Potter: We're roughly ten minutes in, and the NFC playoff race has already crushed the entire early window for entertainment. Saints down 7-0 after the opening drive, return the ensuing kickoff for a touchdown. Seahawks down 7-0 after the opening drive, return the ensuing kickoff for a touchdown. Panthers down 7-0 after the opening drive ... go three-and-out. Ah well.

Vince Verhei: Cardinals lead 10-7 at the end of the first quarter, but they've got the ball in Seattle's red zone. Neither offense has done much since Arizona's opening drive, but the Cardinals have gotten good field position twice after the Lockett touchdown, once on a long kick return of their own, once on a terrible Jon Ryan punt that went out of bounds at the Seattle 40. That's a lot of peaks and valleys for Seattle special teams in 15 minutes.

Seahawks have only run six plays so far, on two three-and-outs. That includes a stuff for no gain on third-and-1 and a sack on third-and-long. They had one other running play, a 5-yard loss. Seattle's offensive line rearing its ugly head again.

Elijhaa Penny scores from 9 yards out to put Arizona up 17-7. They have already run 13 times for 68 yards. Coming into today they were 30th with 59 rushing first downs, 3.9 per game. They already have six first downs on the ground today, and the game isn't even 20 minutes old yet. Their offensive line is just crushing Seattle's front seven today, and that doesn't make sense.

Cardinals lead 20-7 at halftime. Credit to Twitter user Aaron England‏ (@aengland51) for the best description of the Seattle offense I've ever heard: It's like playing Tecmo Bowl, but the defense guesses the right play every single time. Their running backs have five carries for 2 yards in the half; their one successful carry was a 5-yard gain on first-and-10. Wilson has been oddly hesitant to run today, turning down open running lanes to throw to covered receivers or drop backwards into sacks instead. The most irritating of those was on a third-and-2 when Seattle ran five curls. Arizona rushed three and Wilson had lots of time to make a decision. Again, they only needed 2 yards. Instead of taking off, he hesitated before running, and the defense closed in for a 1-yard gain and a punt. Seattle's offensive production in the half: 18 plays, 24 yards, one first down.

But Seattle's offense has been miserable all year. It's far, far more disappointing for the defense to be losing the matchup against Drew Stanton, Kerwynn Williams and company. To be fair, Stanton has made several good plays under pressure. But the game plan is clear: force short passes to Larry Fitzgerald. Twelve targets and eight receptions in the first half, but for only 55 yards. A monster PPR day, I guess.

When the second half started, Fox put up a total yardage graphic that read "SEA - 24." Chris Myers read that as "minus-24." He was wrong, but nobody really blinked an eye, because it felt believable.

Seahawks get a touchdown on their opening drive of the second half. Doug Baldwin beating Budda Baker on a corner route for the 18-yard touchdown. Biggest play was a fourth-and-6 where Seattle turned down a 52-yard field goal try, and Wilson found Jimmy Graham all alone in the middle for a 20-yard gain. Now a 20-14 lead for Arizona.

Another short Ryan punt lets Arizona pick up one first down and get a 53-yard field goal from Phil Dawson. That's five scoring drives for Arizona today, three of them starting at their own 46 or better. Cardinals lead 23-14.

Carl Yedor: Seattle is currently 0-of-8 on third down today, which is a big reason why they have only scored seven offensive points. Wilson has been sacked three times, but it feels like that number should be higher (as usual). Seattle forces a three-and-out after a promising drive stalled out in Cardinals territory. We'll see if Wilson can turn it on for the fourth quarter, though it may not end up mattering with Atlanta up 16-7 at the moment.

Vince Verhei: Seattle gets their first third-down conversion on the first play of the fourth quarter ... when Wilson's pass is tipped at the line, but J.D. McKissic (with Tyrann Mathieu in coverage) tracks the ball down for the reception.

That leads to a third-and-1 where the Cardinals lose Luke Willson, who is on his knees and in position to catch the ball inside the 10 ... but he tries to get up before securing the catch, and he drops it to the turf. Blair Walsh then comes in to try a 49-yard field goal on fourth-and-1, and I am SCREAMING for Seattle to go for it. At least he hit the kick. I have no idea why you kick on fourth-and-1 when you went for it on fourth-and-6 earlier. Regardless, 23-17 lead now.

Two-play scoring drive for Seattle. Wilson keeps the ball on an option and runs for 31 yards, and then Doug Baldwin beats Patrick Peterson deep for a 29-yard touchdown. That puts Wilson ahead of Tom Brady for most passing touchdowns this season, and that's not counting his three rushing touchdowns. Seattle goes up 24-23, though things are looking bleak down south -- the Panthers just punted down two scores with less than six minutes to go.

Carl Yedor: Seahawks get to the Arizona 30-yard line and then squat on the football, setting up Blair Walsh for a 48-yard field goal. He misses, which is unsurprising, and Arizona wins 26-24. Seahawks finish 9-7 and will be watching the playoffs from home for the first time since 2011.

Vince Verhei: Seahawks lose when, appropriately, Blair Walsh misses a 48-yarder. I'm pretty sure they knew they were eliminated by that point -- why else would they run on third-and-9? So much for a magical home-field advantage -- four losses at home for Seattle this year, including the loss to Atlanta on Monday Night Football that really cost them a playoff berth. Will be the first time since drafting Wilson the Seahawks have failed to win a playoff game.

Going to be a big offseason for the Seahawks. They don't have to just pass the Rams in the division next year, they have to hold off the 49ers, and obviously Arizona's in shouting distance of being a playoff team too. Everyone knows about the tough decisions they'll have to make on defense, but the offense is also completely broken. It's the worst offensive line in the league and the worst group of running backs, and the receivers all tended to vanish once in a while too. And frankly, while Wilson was the engine that made everything go, I thought he wasn't at his best this year either. May have gotten jumpy from years of pressure, but he seemed to miss more deep balls and had more trouble finding guys this year than usual.

Regardless, the Seahawks are at the point in their roster where New England was in about 2005 or 2006. You can't have a franchise quarterback in the prime of his career and try to win as a defense-first team. You just can't get and maintain that much defensive talent year after year. The next Seattle playoff team will likely be very different than those of years past.

San Francisco 49ers 34 at Los Angeles Rams (AAA) 13

Bryan Knowles: San Francisco continues to struggle in the red zone. They're going to need to find someone who can separate in a relatively short space or have the size advantage to outjump people to take another step forward. That being said, the team with the longest winning streak in the NFL marches right down the field, thanks to a George Kittle 44-yard grab, and kicks a field goal. That, temporarily, knocks the Rams down to the fourth seed in the NFC (with the Saints passing them); the Rams have essentially decided to cede the third seed by resting nearly every important player on the roster.

Buffalo Bills 22 at Miami Dolphins 16

Bryan Knowles: The Bills need a small series of miracles to slip into the playoffs, but that all starts by beating the Dolphins. This will help if the Dolphins continue to opt not to cover Nick O'Leary, who had a good 5 yards of wide open space in the end zone for a touchdown. That, at least for the moment, moves them into the five seed. Remember, they have professional sports' longest active playoff drought; they'd be in much, much better position if it hadn't been for the Peterman Incident.

Wouldn't that just figure. The Bills, hanging on to playoff position at the moment, just watched their one true offensive star go down. LeSean McCoy was carted off the field with what has been described as an ankle injury of some sort. It would just be Buffalo's luck to make the playoffs for the first time since 1999, only to have their star miss the game.

It would also be unfortunate for all of us having to watch that game, but that's neither here nor there.

Dave Bernreuther: Kyle Williams on a fullback dive gives the Bills a commanding lead. Darqueze Dennard brings a Joe Flacco pass back to the house. Everything is coming up Buffalo! Well, except the fact that their best player got carted off the field...

I have never seen so many defensive and special teams touchdowns in such a small window of time. They're everywhere this afternoon, with a few near-misses as well. The prettiest, and one of the better shows of awareness I've seen, happened in Miami. While rumbling down the sideline, Preston Brown came to a full stop, waiting for his blockers to catch up and do their jobs, before continuing on his way to the end zone.

Coaches seem to be doing a better job convincing players to actually block downfield on plays like that these days.

And then, upon review of the fumble, Jeff Triplette announced that Brown was out of bounds when he recovered it, so it all comes back, and Brown ... did a stupid little dance and celebration on the sideline. AFTER it was announced that Miami was keeping the ball!

So I will take back what I just said about Brown's awareness, I guess. He kind of canceled that one out.

Vince Verhei: So Buffalo's in the playoffs. Does that change things for the Bills and their fans? Are they still going to go out of their way to sabotage and get rid of Tyrod Taylor for 2018?

New Orleans Saints 24 at Tampa Bay Buccaneers 31

Bryan Knowles: Saints are still fighting for the divisional title, and things did not go well on the opening drive; the Buccaneers marched right down the field and scored a touchdown. Ensuing kickoff, however, sees Alvin Kamara race back 106 yards, meaning they slipped out of the three seed for about six seconds of game time.

Wild, quick starts to all these important games. I've got eight screens going on a TV, two desktop computers and a laptop, and I'm having trouble keeping up with it all. Somebody, blow someone else out, please!

Saints special teams collapsing. They force a Buccaneers punt, but Tommylee Lewis fumbles on the 7-yard line, which is scooped up and returned in for a touchdown by Isaiah Johnson. That puts the NFC South back into play, and (at least for the moment) slides the Rams back into the three seed. Very interesting...

New Orleans bounces back from the punt return kerfluffle with a methodical 13-play drive. Zach Line catches a short out for the go-ahead touchdown, putting the Saints back in the No. 3 seed at the moment. It also gives them a cushion over the Panthers, who just kicked a field goal to make THAT a one-score game. Oh, and Seattle is coming back, with a field goal of their own making THAT a one-score game.

So, yeah. Just a wee bit of drama entering the fourth quarter, even with the Chargers and Bills with fairly unassailable leads, and the Rams packing it in before the game even started.

All-Rookie Team honorable mention Chris Godwin scores a touchdown at the last second, upsetting New Orleans. The Saints still win the NFC South, thanks to the Panthers' loss, but that means they fall to the No. 4 seed rather than the No. 3. NFC wild-card games are Falcons at Rams and Panthers at Saints.

Jacksonville Jaguars 10 at Tennessee Titans 15

Bryan Knowles: Jacksonville is starting everyone today, so a scoreless first quarter isn't a surprise. One way to attack Jacksonville's aggressive pass rush is with screens and the like -- and that's exactly what the Titans do, hitting Derrick Henry on a pass behind the line of scrimmage which turns into a 66-yard touchdown. That, at the moment, would put the Titans in as the No. 5 seed, bumping the Bills to the No. 6 seed and knocking the Ravens out of the playoffs entirely.

Rivers McCown: Derrick Henry was held up as the back that just needed a full-time chance by the fantasy football community. So far: nine carries, 11 yards. He did take a screen to the house, but still. When the Titans can't run, they don't have a good offense with this version of Mariota.

Tom Gower: Titans lead 12-3 at the half. Derrick Henry, who started the game miserable, had a long catch-and-run, 66 yards on a screen pass. The Titans also scored twice after the two-minute warning, three-and-kick drives after starting in Jaguars territory. The first came after a muffed punt, the second after a forced fumble on a short pass (good play by rookie corner Adoree Jackson). The Jaguars have the only drive-like substance in the game, when they got their field goal. Blake Bortles has been his usual 2017 mix of sometimes effective (he has converted a few third downs through the air, something he struggled to do in the first matchup until the randomly super-awesome-when-it-didn't-matter-at-all fourth quarter) and sometimes pretty bad (a handful of passes thrown behind receivers to prevent completions). Like most Titans-Jaguars games, I can't tell if the teams are 4-11 and 3-12 or 10-5 and 8-7. We'll see if the Jaguars quit after halftime, like they should. Thirty minutes to the first Tennessee postseason trip since 2008 if the score holds!

Oh, the first half of this game featured not one, not two, but three wacky challenges! Doug Marrone challenged the second Titans play of the game. It was whether a 5-yard pass completion on second-and-12 was caught. He did not win it. Mike Mularkey's first challenge was kind of marginal -- a very Bert Emanuel Rule play of a 15-yard pass on first-and-10. Ruled a catch on the field, there was not sufficient evidence to overturn the close call in replay. Mularkey then decided to use his second and final challenge of the game with 3:38 to go in the second quarter when the Jaguars had too many men on a punt on fourth-and-4 from midfield. No, it wasn't a Tennessee punt, such that too many men would continue the drive. Rather, the Jaguars were able to down the punt at the 5, and Mularkey thought he would probably end up with better field position after a sure winning challenge. The challenge was a fairly clear winner, at least, and the subsequent punt did go into the end zone, so at least he had that going for him. Hopefully there's nothing in the final 28 minutes of challengeable time that he wants to get New York to take a look at. (Or hopefully there is, so Amy Adams Strunk fires him as Ian Rapaport indicated could happen; this is such a weird rooting experience. It's almost like a good outcome for me is guaranteed, but at the same time I as a fan want both things to happen.)

Rivers McCown: The Titans should vote Jaydon Mickens a playoff share.

Tom Gower: Mickens had a punt muff after he signaled for a fair catch that gave Tennessee the ball at the 11, resulting in a field goal that made it 9-3. He muffed another punt early in the third quarter that had the Jaguars backed up to their own 5 after he did get it back at the 2.

Bryan Knowles: With a playoff spot on the line, the Titans just can't put the Jaguars away. A collision between Mariota and Henry puts the ball on the ground, and Yannick Ngakoue scoops it up and brings it back to the house. 15-10 Tennessee, and don't count this one done quite yet...

Marcus Mariota scrambles the Titans into the playoffs, despite ... well, despite everything Tennessee has done this year. It has been a rough year for him, but his first career playoff berth eases the sting somewhat.

Tom Gower: The Jaguars played starters throughout the game. I thought for sure we would and should see Chad Henne, at the latest after they didn't score to start the second half. But Bortles the whole way it was, and offense was hard to come by throughout the game. After the early field goal drive, they made it inside the Titans 45 just once. Dede Westbrook dropped a touchdown pass (bad game for him), and the drive ended up with a punt from the 46 after a third-down sack and a couple penalties.

Tennessee's offense was mostly awful. Their second-half score, like their two first-half field goals, came on a drive that started in Jacksonville territory. Overall, they started in plus territory four times (not counting the kneeldown at the end of the game) and ended up net +2 points, as their fourth possession in plus territory featured Derrick Henry running into Marcus Mariota in the backfield and the ball popping out to Yannick Ngakoue for the Jaguars' lone touchdown of the game.

Titans receivers combined for four catches for 25 yards on 10 targets, thanks in part to a couple bad drops by Eric Decker who at 3-18 led the group. Derrick Henry was 15-34 in the second half to finish 28-51. But Marcus Mariota, who ran more on designed runs than he probably has this year, had a couple key runs, including a third-and-5 conversion that put Jacksonville under extreme time pressure for a potential winning drive. Buffalo's later success rightly overshadows it, but one of the longest playoff droughts in the NFL is over. On to Kansas City.

Oakland Raiders 10 at Los Angeles Chargers 30

Aaron Schatz: Right before halftime, and Philip Rivers hits Keenan Allen in the back right corner of the end zone with an absolutely insane lob pass. Like, so insane that Rich Gannon literally said on the broadcast, "Rivers just throws this away." And the ball just fell right into Allen's hands one step away from being out of bounds. So much touch on that pass.

But of course, because they are the Chargers, the extra point was blocked. 20-10 Chargers.

Andrew Potter: I have this morbid urge to witness a soccer-style field goal penalty shootout between the Chargers and Buccaneers.

Cincinnati Bengals 31 at Baltimore Ravens 27

Charles McDonald: Ravens just had a huge kickoff return by Chris Moore to set them up inside the 10 with 8 seconds left in the second quarter. They rewarded him by throwing him a slant for a touchdown to cut Cincinnati's lead to 17-10 going into the half. The Bengals absolutely dominated the first half, but with the late score by Chris Moore (I love it when I accidentally rhyme), the Ravens are right back in it.

Bryan Knowles: I went into today thinking the Seahawks, Ravens, and Chargers would grab the three playoff spots up for grabs. As of halftime, that's a big 0-for-3. Oops.

Aaron Schatz: Chris Moore giveth, and Chris Moore taketh away.

Bryan Knowles: For the first time all day, the Ravens take the lead! Mike Wallace puts the ball into the end zone with about 8:30 left in the game, and that will, for now, bump the Bills out of the playoffs. Ravens to No. 5, Titans sliding to No. 6. Still not over!

Aaron Schatz: Holy mackerel. Andy Dalton. Just connected with Tyler Boyd in the seam on fourth-and-12, and Boyd didn't just get into field-goal range, he rumbled into the end zone to give the Bengals a 31-27 lead with less than a minute left. Credit to Dan Fouts, who completely called it ahead of time, saying to watch Boyd in the slot. He was wide open in a zone. And Andy Dalton will now drink for free in Buffalo for the rest of his life, if he ever feels like going to Buffalo for some reason other than a road game against the Bills.

Dave Bernreuther: Just when I was making the joke about Marvin Lewis being content to play for a long-and-nowhere-near-certain tying field goal, followed by the joke about having to rely on Andy Dalton of all people to mount a comeback against the Ravens' D ... just after he throws 2 yards to a covered guy on third-and-15 ... Andy Dalton turns into Peyton Manning. And throws a DART for a go-ahead touchdown.

I grew up near Buffalo. Wasn't a Bills fan, because even 8-year-old me was a contrarian jerk. But boy am I happy for those people right now.

Bryan Knowles: How, how HOW do you throw SHORT of the sticks on fourth-and-season?! How do you do that? How is that even allowed?

Vince Verhei: Hooray! I don't have to watch Joe Flacco in the playoffs! Best news of the day.

Aaron Schatz: So the Cleveland Browns are now on the clock with the longest playoff drought in the NFL (2002) and the Seattle Mariners, I think, get the title of longest playoff drought in the big four American pro sports (2001).


120 comments, Last at 04 Jan 2018, 6:12pm

2 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by D2K // Dec 31, 2017 - 11:59pm

Bills fan here still riding a high of pure elation. I don't know what else Taylor has to do to prove that he should be the quarterback of this team? Hopefully, the front office sees this now and doesn't listen to the media and fans whojust aren't happy with anything that isn't Jim Kelly.

Still an amazing ride this season. From the tank talk in the preseason after all the trades to the hot start (5-2), to the 3 game losing streak mid year where we didn't even look like an NFL team let alone a playoff team and the Petermam experience, to the 4-2 finish (4-0 against non-Patriot teams). To watching Bengals vs Ravens just knowing Dalton would screw it up, especially after the 3rd and 15 check down. A win in Miami and 4th and 12 touchdown from Cincinnati. Unreal.

Login or Register to post comments

3 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:04am

If the Bills don't feel that Tyrod Taylor can lead them to a SB, then they're perfectly justified in exploring other options during the off season. There's a wide range between Taylor's overall play and that of Jim "first ballot HoFer" Kelly's.

Login or Register to post comments

4 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by D2K // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:10am

I didn't say Taylor was Jim Kelly though but he is world's better than the alternatives including Kirk Cousins (gonna be cheaper as well) and any QB in this upcoming draft.

Login or Register to post comments

5 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:14am

No way is he "world's better" than Cousins and it's a complete unknown whether any of the QBs in this draft will be worse or better than him. If the Bills are in position for one that they feel projects to be better they should draft him.

Login or Register to post comments

8 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by D2K // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:24am

It is world's better when you consider that Taylors salary will be $9 million while Cousins will be $22-$25 million per year. Cousins isn't $16 million better.

The Bills are a 9-7 team with 5 picks in the first 3 rounds. If they use that draft capital to build around Taylor they could be a playoff team for multiple years in a row.

Login or Register to post comments

9 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:51am

Do you see the Bills going to a SB with Tyrod Taylor?

Login or Register to post comments

42 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by comfect // Jan 01, 2018 - 11:47am

Quarterbacks who have started a Super Bowl, starting in February 2007: Tom Brady, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson, Joe Flacco, Colin Kaepernick, Eli Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Rex Grossman.

I could easily see Taylor being (now or in the future) as good as some of the people on that list. Not all of them, but as a lot of people have said here, he's not problem #1--and what's also worth pointing out is that it's a lot harder to evaluate the rest of the offense (OL and WR especially) if they're playing with someone like Nathan Peterman than if they're playing with Tyrod Taylor. So even if you're convinced (as I'm not) that Taylor could never be a SB quarterback, driving him out of town is still coaching and GMing malpractice.

Login or Register to post comments

44 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Alternator // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:15pm

Sure? The Ravens twice won a Super Bowl with a QB no better than Tyrod, with the second coming against another QB around his level in Kaep, not to mention teams like the Broncos or Seahawks which were built around their defense.

If they want to draft a replacement to Taylor, that's fine - but the degree to which the Bills seem to want him gone (seriously, starting Peterman?) is insane. Decent starters do not grow on trees, and should not be casually discarded.

Login or Register to post comments

6 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:16am

Tyrod Taylor is probably the 45th worst player on the Bills roster. He won't be a hall of famer, but he's a perfectly viable NFL starting quarterback.

The handful of games I've watched of Buffalo have made it very clear that they have some of the worst WR in the NFL - the number of throws Taylor makes that should be caught, and aren't, is ridiculous.

This sort of thing is kind of the hallmark of bad franchises - they've got a roster full of bad players and they're trying to run a good one out of town because he's not elite.

Login or Register to post comments

7 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:23am

I'm not surprised that a NE fan is all for the Bills sticking with Taylor. Be honest, when you look at the schedule and see the Bills are next are you sitting there thinking "Oh shit. Tyrod Taylor."? Do you see the Bills winning the division with him?

Login or Register to post comments

12 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:44am

Tyrod Taylor isn't whats keeping the Bills from winning the division.

He's the 2nd best quarterback in the division.

Login or Register to post comments

13 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:47am

Sure he is, at least to some extent

Login or Register to post comments

21 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:41am

Only if you think 25+ teams in the NFL have a quarterback problem.

Tyrod Taylor is never going to carry a team to a superbowl - but finding a guy who can is exceedingly unlikely - one shows up in the NFL every 4 or 5 years. Chasing them is a waste of time.

So you have to build a team that's strong all around and hope you get lucky or have a good run. Continuing to try and find the next Tom Brady every 3 years is how you end up - well, the Buffalo Bills.

Login or Register to post comments

113 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by AwesomeDan // Jan 02, 2018 - 9:24pm

It's much closer to 1 QB per year who's worth building around than one every 4/5 years. Your job as a GM is to get one, not to hold onto mediocrity and hope for a miracle.

Tom Brady (2000)
Drew Brees (2001)
Michael Vick (2001)
Philip Rivers (2004)
Ben Roethlisberger (2004)
Tony Romo (2004)
Aaron Rodgers (2005)
Matt Ryan (2008)
Matthew Stafford (2009)
Cam Newton (2011)
Andrew Luck (2012)
Robert Griffin III (2012)
Russell Wilson (2012)
Jimmy Garroppolo (2014)
Jameis Winston (2015)
Carson Wentz (2016)
Deshaun Watson (2017)
Patrick Mahomes II (2017)

Login or Register to post comments

117 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by thewhitesnake8 // Jan 04, 2018 - 12:20pm

GREAT point here, but Pat Mahomes II ???? Let's pump the breaks there a little bit ...

Login or Register to post comments

45 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:20pm

He's only the 2nd best QB in the division because Tannehill is injured, and Jimmy G was traded. Even then it's not all that clear he's better than Jay Cutler.

So basically he's clearly better than whatever is happening on the Jets. Yee-hah!

Login or Register to post comments

61 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:48pm

Empirical Jay Cutler or Theoretical Jay Cutler?

Theoretical Jay Cutler is really good, but the first-order approximation of him has been on milk cartons since 2009.

Login or Register to post comments

15 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Scott P. // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:54am

To be honest, I'm not seeing them winning the division even if they had Jim Kelly.

Login or Register to post comments

18 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by tjb // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:08am

Of course not. Jim Kelly is nearly 60.

Login or Register to post comments

33 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 9:04am

Do you see anyone winning the AFC East, ever, besides the Pats?

I pen them in every year.

I don't see Taylor in a SB because if Buffalo's front office, not because of him. Brady couldn't SB on that team.

Login or Register to post comments

1 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by xMRNUTTYx // Dec 31, 2017 - 11:57pm

"Pass to Cohen coming out of the backfield, tackled at the 1."

FYI: This is a variation on the 2 point conversion that they ran in the early part of the season that everyone (rightfully) went apeshit over. The difference was in execution- partly due to the Vikings defense.

I'm glad Fox is gone. I hope- without any realistic expectation- that Fangio is back. But Loggains is a really interesting case and this game showed it. I spent the entire year watching him call 1 or 2 or 5 plays that are legitimately unique and interesting. And the rest is... meh. The offensive talent obviously doesn't help but he seems like he's TRYING to be innovative. And this game really felt like a job interview for him. You look at those play calls in goal-to-go situations and wonder why a couple of Howard handoffs weren't called. So I wouldn't be surprised to see him with another NFL job even thought that offense overall was kind of bad...

Login or Register to post comments

10 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:03am

Re: Kaszmar's complaining about Tomlin sitting key players - When has Belichick been in the same position? Remember the 2009 finale where he decided to play everybody in a meaningless game and Welker tore his ACL? How smart was that decision?

Everybody including Tomlin knew it was very, very VERY unlikely that the Bryce Petty-led Jets were going to go to Foxbro and generate enough points for the game to still be interesting in the fourth quarter, let alone win. If even one of the players he sat got even just a little banged up, he would've been ripped for that, too. Damned if you do, damned if you...

Also, he was probably confident that the Steelers could still find a way to beat the Browns with who they had. Or that the Browns would still find a way to lose.

Login or Register to post comments

16 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:55am

Just two years ago the Pats were 12-2 after Week 15 and only needed one more win to get the #1 seed. They lost at the Jets and at Miami to finish the season. The effort in Miami was bizarre - they abandoned their regular playbook, putting extra effort trying to resuscitate a dying running game, and let the Dolphins steal a victory.

Resting his key players was the smart move for Tomlin. I have no doubt that Roethlisberger and Bell needed the rest, and it was reasonably predictable that (a) the Pats would beat the Jets anyway, and (b) they wouldn't need their own stars to beat the Browns. And it's not like they sat everybody, just a small number of veterans who no doubt could use the time off.

Login or Register to post comments

30 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Mountain Time ---- formerly Ninjalectual // Jan 01, 2018 - 8:27am

As a Broncos fan, I'll always have warm fuzzy memories of that week 17 Dolphins game coming out of nowhere xD

Login or Register to post comments

92 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ZDNeal // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:24am

Belichick is the current coach people just use to argue from stolen authority. They have no idea what Belichick would actually do with that set of players in that situation, but by claiming he would act as they think best they try and steal his authority to bolster their argument.

Login or Register to post comments

23 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:48am

Wes Welker tore his ACL/MCL without making contact with anyone on a soft cut - his knee was a timebomb. If it hadn't gone then, it would have gone the next week in Houston.

Login or Register to post comments

52 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Anger...rising // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:06pm

Yeah, thanks for your input, Dr. Dumbass. That's not how it works at all.

Login or Register to post comments

111 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Scott C // Jan 02, 2018 - 7:07pm

LOL. No.

Soft tissue injuries without contact, are one area of injury science that has gained a lot of info in the past decade.

If he rested for a week, his ligaments would have been strengthened and decreased the chance of injury. These things happen largely because of _overwork_ (plus some level of luck of course). Well, at least statistically about 50% of them can be attributed to overwork.

Login or Register to post comments

36 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Rocco // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:03am

Short list of things more likely to happen than Bryce Petty leading the upset in Foxboro:

-Ben or Bell getting hurt
-the backups beating Cleveland anyway
-Kate Upton knocking on my door wearing nothing but an overcoat

If you're relying on Bryce Petty you've already lost. Fly the white flag and get ready for the playoffs.

Login or Register to post comments

108 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RBroPF // Jan 02, 2018 - 4:00pm

Not starting some key players I think was a fine decision. Making them inactive so you couldn't change your mind if the situation played out unexpectedly seems like an unforced error.

Login or Register to post comments

11 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:44am

Think about the QBs playing in the AFC wildcard round this coming weekend: Bortles, Smith, Mariota, and Taylor. Does anybody think any of those guys can lead a team to a Super Bowl? I guess Smith is the closest, but that's not saying much.
Will any of these teams actively seek better QB play in the offseason? The Jags have a great young team - except at QB. The Bills and Titans just seem like playoff bracket filler waiting for the axe to fall.
Are these franchises going to be "happy just to be there" when it comes to the playoffs? If so, then some team like Denver is going to grab Kirk Cousins and be a real playoff force instead of these guys.

Login or Register to post comments

14 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:49am

You may not have noticed, but some here feel the Bills should be completely satisfied with Taylor as their starting QB.

Login or Register to post comments

17 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:03am

I noticed. If they are completely satisfied with only winning wild card berths and never smelling a Super Bowl, then that makes sense. It's the "happy to be in the playoffs" trap.

Tyrod Taylor is not a good passer. The claim that he's as good as Cousins is wholly without merit. The Bills won games this season in spite of their poor QB play, and they would be a real threat in the conference if they could replace Taylor with somebody competent. Even a Tannehill-level QB would be enough.

Through Week 16, Taylor had a -8.6% DVOA passing. He'd be the worst starter in the playoffs were it not for the Wentz injury.

Login or Register to post comments

19 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:15am

And wouldn't have a WC berth if not for blown coverage by the Ravens on a 4th and 12 play. Speaking of the Ravens, is Harbaugh in trouble? Should he be? Newsome, too? This makes 4 out of 5 without the playoffs since that SB.

Login or Register to post comments

46 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Alternator // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:20pm

The Bills wouldn't have needed a blown coverage by the Ravens if they hadn't decided that Nathan Peterman was a better QB than Tyrod Taylor, and given away a game because of it.

Login or Register to post comments

51 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by sbond101 // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:46pm

I get that people think the Bills were crazy/stupid for playing Peterman, but can we stop with the myth that they "gave away" the game. The Bills would have been significant underdogs on the road against the chargers at that point, were talking on the order of a 25% chance. If they had started Taylor there might have been a 25% chance that they didn't need to be bailed out by the Ravens - not exactly something transformative.

Login or Register to post comments

53 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Alternator // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:16pm

Peterman threw five interceptions in one half. The Bills deserve every shred of criticism they can possibly receive for thinking he was deserving of a start, and they gave away any chance of victory that day,, they still gave away the game.

Login or Register to post comments

80 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by JimZipCode // Jan 01, 2018 - 11:06pm

@Steve B #19:

On Ravens discussion boards, Harbaugh should be drawn & quartered. For half of the posters, Ozzie should be set adrift on a raft.

I dunno. Ravens were ravaged by injuries this season, esp on the O-line. The 1st-rd receiver pick from a couple years ago who lit it up in the offseason, suddenly imploded into nothingness. Their starting QB missed all of training camp with a back injury, and honestly looked like he was severely limited for the first ~2 months of the season. Either Harbaugh held that group together, kept them focused and took them on a run when Flacco got healthy again (and the schedule eased up) after the bye. Or Harbaugh is holding that group back.

It's hard to believe another head coach could have gotten much more out of that group of offensive players, post-injury. (Maybe a genius coordinator like Kyle Shanahan would have wrung more production from the passing game.) But of course Harbaugh is part of the reason the Ravens have that particular group of offensive players.

Dean Pees is retiring, which could help if the Ravens get someone like Pagano or Fangio to take the role. I know Pees is regarded as something of a defensive genius nationally, but to Ravens fans his signature is the 4th quarter defensive collapse.

To this particular Ravens fan, it seems too soon to jettison Harbaugh. If the Ravens hire an aggressive DC, if they get their injured linemen back, if they draft someone useful on offense, and if the playcalling tag-team of Mornhinweg & Greg Roman is able to build on some of the things the Ravens did well this season, the Ravens could actually be good in 2018. But, this was probably the easiest schedule they've had in years (2014?), and things look stale. I think Harbaugh goes on the warm-to-hot seat next season.

After next season is also the first year they could realistically separate from Flacco, without a huge cap penalty. If they draft a succession QB this year, that could tell us something about Harbaugh's security there. Ravens are only .500 since the SB, but it's hard to parse blame for it. Their 2013 and 2015 drafts were busts at the top: they got nothing in the first TWO rounds in each. That's a gigantic setback, players that should be key contributors right now. Add 2 to 4 playmakers to this roster, it's a whole different situation.

I guess the answer to your questions is, "I don't know." I can make arguments in both directions. His leadership is real, and the players respond & fight. At the same time, there's a fine line between a "steady hand" and a "stale message". He's clearly a good guy, seems to have his head on more-straight than most NFL coaches. I root for him; I mean specifically for him, not just the Ravens, I'd like to see him win big again. But the Ravens have some problems to address.

Login or Register to post comments

83 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by theslothook // Jan 02, 2018 - 1:23am

I have a hard time blaming Harbaugh for this Ravens season. As you mentioned - the team was ravaged by injuries and the defensive collapse pretty much spelled the end on what was otherwise a likely playoff birth. Maybe Shanny or McVay could have wrung more out of the offense, but I doubt the defense or special teams would be just as good, so on net - the ravens are likely to have been no better under either coach.

The real issue, as you correctly point out - is Flacco and his contract. Draft busts happen as you aren't going to hit on every pick, but thats why free agency exists to smooth over the jagged edges. That became far more onerous with Flacco in toe, although one could argue Flacco as the starter was far more damaging.

Given all of the above, I really don't see how firing Ozzie or Harbaugh is justified. The ravens have been one of the few teams that has had consistent success despite getting pretty sub par qb play for most of it. Its one thing to do what the Jags did this year but to maintain competitiveness year after year playing like that is pretty much unheard of.

This goes back to Tyrod Taylor. People who point to all the sbs helmed by subpar qbs as votes of confidence for Tyrod are missing the big picture. The bears made a sb with Grossman, but that didn't mean they were willing to keep him around indefinitely since he'd been there before. The goal is to be competitive year after year. Tyrod is average(or slightly above if you prefer), but no better with a pretty obvious ceiling. While that can get you to a sb if things break right, over the long haul, it ensures a consistent mediocrity. I'd be more sympathetic to Tyrod if the Bills had a supporting cast of the old 49ers or seahawks. But the bills aren't a middling team talent wise and Tyrod barely moves the needle there(if at all).

Login or Register to post comments

87 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by bravehoptoad // Jan 02, 2018 - 10:27am

IIRC, it was Steve Bisciotti who kept the Ravens from acquiring Kaepernick this off-season. is he the kind of owner who regularly interferes in personnel decisions?

Login or Register to post comments

20 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:38am

DVOA isn't a measure of player skill. Its a measure of unit effectiveness. You should know that at this point.

His receivers can't catch. At all. They're terrible. Not a single one of them is above replacement level - and until they replace the WRs, replacing Taylor is a giant waste of time.

The hybrid lovechild of Tom Brady and Peyton Manning couldn't win consistently with this team.

Login or Register to post comments

32 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by theslothook // Jan 01, 2018 - 8:57am

I disagree that a Brady or Manning couldn't win with this roster.

Short of the bills sporting a Seahawks roster circa 2013, Tyrod's ceiling effectively means division round at best but no farther. You can do a lot worse than Tyrod, sure, but if the goal is to win a sb, he's not good enough.

Login or Register to post comments

58 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:38pm

Two years ago - before the Bills started jettisoning talent, Tyrod Taylor was putting up a +10% DVOA - which isn't fantastic, but its good enough to win with. Its better than Kirk Cousins is putting up this year - and someone is going to give him $25M+ a year. Its better than Matt Stafford puts up every year. Its better than Aaron Rodgers put up this year before getting hurt. Its better than Dak Prescott, Cam Newton, Derek Carr, or Russel Wilson put up this year.

That has value. Teams go to superbowls with that sort of performance, and some of them win. You simply can't bet on pulling Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, or Aaron Rodgers out of the draft.

I mean shit, Eli Manning won two superbowls and made what, $300M off a career that only exceeded that +10% mark for 3 years, and was significantly worse than that for long periods. People are talking about him being a hall of famer.

Again - this is what keeps poor franchises poor - focusing on replacing the average quarterback while most of the roster is replacement level.

Login or Register to post comments

66 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:21pm

Yep, when you can win Super Bowls, or almost win Super Bowls, with Trent Dilfer, an aging Brad Johnson, Jake Delhomme, a Joe Flacco who gets hot for a few weeks, a zombie Peyton Manning, and Colin Kaepernick,then Tyrod Taylor can win a Super Bowl.

Login or Register to post comments

84 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by theslothook // Jan 02, 2018 - 1:27am

I agree you CAN win the sb with a lesser qb. The list you mentioned above sports plenty of them. But that I think is the wrong question. The right question is - can this qb provide you enough quality that you can keep getting to the playoffs year after year without needing a rock solid supporting cast?

I agree, when posed this way, the number of qbs effectively capable of doing this shrinks dramatically - but thats the point. One season's sugar rush goes away pretty fast. Does anyone expect the Jaguars to be that great next year? Or rather, if the Jags defense suffers a 25 percent decline, do we really think Bortles is capable of making up the difference?

Login or Register to post comments

85 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 02, 2018 - 1:57am

If you had phrased it that way, instead of saying that Tyrod Taylor's ceiling was the Divisional round, I would not have disagreed so quickly.

Login or Register to post comments

91 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:17am

" The right question is - can this qb provide you enough quality that you can keep getting to the playoffs year after year without needing a rock solid supporting cast?"

The problem is that you have to luck into the sort of guys who can answer yes to your question - going out and drafting a guy in the first round is more likely to get you someone who isn't meaningfully better than Taylor than it is to get you your Rodgers or Brady or Manning.

IE, its easier to put together that rock solid supporting cast than it is to meaningfully upgrade Taylor.

So you upgrade the supporting cast, and draft projects, and hope you catch lightening in a bottle on one - rather than continuing to waste 1st round picks and continuing to have your franchise wallow below .500. Buffalo needs upgrades everywhere - upgrading the roughly average QB shouldn't be a priority.

Their offensive line needs major investment (both guards and center are 30+). Their best WR is probably replacement level - and they all have the drops (31st in pass attempts, 10th in drops). McCoy is fantastic, but he'll be 30 next year, and that's ancient for a RB.

There's some talent on the defense, but not nearly as much as there was before Rex messed everything up.

Having a winning record has value. Making the playoffs has value. Winning the superbowl is awesome but even if you do everything right, you're probably not going to.

The Jags, in my mind, are a very different situation - their roster is drastically better than the Bills - they can afford to take shots at a QB at this point (and frankly, I think Taylor is a lot better than Bortles). They've got the supporting cast to accurately evaluate a QB, and to take advantage of small improvements.

Login or Register to post comments

114 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by theslothook // Jan 03, 2018 - 12:01am

I guess I disagree that it's easier to build a good team than it is to find a good qb. Plus good teams vanish fast. Good QBs and good coaches last a while.

Login or Register to post comments

26 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by PaddyPat // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:23am

I'm honestly quite confused by the Taylor hate on this thread, especially by smart commentators.

Taylor is something like a poor man's Russell Wilson. He has ranked as high as 8th in DVOA (2015) when he had a decent supporting cast that fit his strengths, and has seen his performance slowly crumble as the team has jettisoned offensive talent and played against his strengths. Is he an MVP-Level QB? No, of course not. But the Broncos won a Super Bowl in 2015 with Peyton Manning's corpse. The Giants did in 2007 with an Eli Manning performance far weaker than Taylor's 2015. Even in the modern passing league, a strong team can win a Super Bowl with a reasonable but not great quarterback.

I am not arguing that the Bills should not explore other passing options, but a lot of teams in this league would be extremely lucky to have Tyrod Taylor. Off the top of my head, I'd say this year's NYJ, MIA, BAL, CLE, IND, HOU, DEN, CHI, ARI, quite plausibly NYG and CIN, and for chunks of the year, GB and SF would have been better, more successful teams with Taylor than with who they were starting.

Login or Register to post comments

29 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Mr Shush // Jan 01, 2018 - 7:58am

Is it really meaningful to say that Taylor's better than the backups in Indy, Houston or Green Bay, or a starter who's already been replaced in San Francisco? No-one's suggesting that Taylor isn't significantly better than a typical backup.

Login or Register to post comments

47 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:32pm

Tyrod Taylor is nowhere near Russell Wilson's level. He's like a horribly inaccurate version of Russell Wilson. He's much closer to Jaccoby Brissett than Russell Wilson.

I've seen a lot of Tyrod Taylor over the past few years. Not as much as Bills' fans, but still that's a lot. He has serious accuracy issues and gets sacked a lot. You could argue that this is all the fault of everybody else on the offense. But the eyeball test says he's got accuracy problems. And he's one of the few QBs this season who averaged less than 200 yards passing per game. The others include Hundley, Trubisky, Kizer, Brissett, and the ghosts of Jay Cutler and Joe Flacco.

It doesn't take that long to recognize a QB who can play at an elite level. We've already seen what DeShaun Watson can do for a team. Without Watson, the Texans play at about the level of the Bills. With him, they play at an elite level. Russell Wilson turns garbage into miracles in Seattle. Taylor is never going to do that.

Login or Register to post comments

62 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:56pm

Without Watson, the Texans play at about the level of the Bills.

The Texans went 1-9 in games Watson didn't start.
They went 3-3 with him.

The Bills were 8-6 in games Taylor started.

Texas's best receiver is DeAndre Hopkins. Buffalo's best (healthy) receiver is Zay Jones.

I'll let you find where they sit on this table.

Login or Register to post comments

71 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by justanothersteve // Jan 01, 2018 - 5:46pm

Check the Texans #2 WR, Will Fuller, while you're at it.

Login or Register to post comments

34 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 9:07am

Given Brady and Roethlusberger's ages, I suspect all six AFC playoff teams will be trying to acquire better QB play next season.

Login or Register to post comments

48 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:33pm

Any smart team grabs QB talent whenever they see it.

Login or Register to post comments

63 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:57pm

Like the 49ers?

Login or Register to post comments

88 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by jtr // Jan 02, 2018 - 10:46am

>Given Brady and Roethlusberger's ages, I suspect all six AFC playoff teams will be trying to acquire better QB play next season.

Well, KC already made their talent grab with Mahomes. It's just a matter of whether he's going to be ready by week 1, or if it takes a bit longer. Wouldn't be surprised to see him take over for Alex Smith in the middle of next season, just like Kaepernick did in his second year.

Alex Smith: just good enough to hold off the rookie for 1.5 seasons.

Login or Register to post comments

99 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by cstoos // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:13pm

Smith just had his best season as a pro. Leading the NFL in QB rating. Passing for 4,000 yards.

Unless he seriously regresses, he won't lose his job mid-season. Problem with him is more salary cap related. Think he is $20mil next season.

So, he will either get traded or will be the starter for 1 more season. Probably no in-between without an injury.

Login or Register to post comments

102 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:49pm

4000 yards isn't really a benchmark for QBs anymore. The league average over the last 3 years is 3850 yards.

Login or Register to post comments

22 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:44am

So Tyrod Taylor never makes a bad throw or decision with the football?

Login or Register to post comments

24 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:48am

Awesome strawman bro.

Login or Register to post comments

25 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:56am

Saying "OMG his receivers!" isn't a straw man?

Login or Register to post comments

38 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Anon Ymous // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:32am

No, it isn't. Amusingly, though, you just offered yet another straw man in this comment. :)

Do you know what a straw man fallacy is?

Login or Register to post comments

56 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Steve B // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:03pm

Do you know what saying "it's everybody else's fault" is?

Login or Register to post comments

57 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 2:23pm

Even more strawmen! they're everywhere!

Login or Register to post comments

68 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Eddo // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:23pm

No, it's not. At best it's a reason for his lackluster statistics, and at worst it's a flat-out excuse. Most likely it is a contributing factor of some sort.

It's not a straw man argument. A strawman is when someone argues against something their opponent (for lack of a better term) hasn't actually said. Such as when someone says, "QB X isn't that bad," and then you rebut with, "Oh, so you think QB X is PERFECT?!"

And for the record I don't think Taylor is any better than about the 15th best QB - good enough to compete with, but not good enough to carry a team. The Bills' sin was that they clearly have a team that is capable of competing (as evidenced by their playoff berth) and they decided halfway through the season to give up and see what their late-round rookie could do.

Looking to upgrade at QB in the offseason is a good idea, but doing it midseason while your team is in playoff contention and your only option is a very raw, not-highly-drafted rookie is a pretty bad one.

Login or Register to post comments

93 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ZDNeal // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:35am

But also realizing, that finding a QB better than the 15th best is very hard to do. I'd argue that Taylor is about the same Case Keenum, and I'm all-in on Keenmentum. Playing QB roulette until you find Brady is a prescription for a lot of shitty seasons.

Login or Register to post comments

103 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:51pm

unable to follow nesting - ignore.

Login or Register to post comments

27 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Bright Blue Shorts // Jan 01, 2018 - 7:19am

Love how the Dallas-Philly commentary just ends with the score still tied at 0-0 at the end of the 3rd. It must have been dull.

Login or Register to post comments

55 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Bryan Knowles // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:41pm

A heck of a lot more dull than the Browns battling to try to avoid 0-16, at least! Meaningless gaaaame.

Login or Register to post comments

74 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by MilkmanDanimal // Jan 01, 2018 - 5:54pm

The final quarter of Browns-Steelers was incredibly exciting. I was cheering constantly, and I couldn't decide whether I wanted them to go 0-16 to properly commemorate that organizations true level of incompetence, or whether I wanted them to win to spare Cleveland fans any more misery.

Login or Register to post comments

94 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ZDNeal // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:37am

Could it match the drama of the first 0 XP 0 FG game without overtime?

Login or Register to post comments

28 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Bright Blue Shorts // Jan 01, 2018 - 7:58am

Congratulations to the Bills on finally getting back to the playoffs. They were my 2nd team for many years and I have a fondness for those 90s teams and their stellar cast of players.

The organisation's almost open disdain for Taylor that began in week 17 last year under the old regime and then continued even though he renegotiated his contract and will be around until end of next year just seems comical. Can Peterman really be seen as the plan for when he goes? At least Kirk Cousins is getting paid handsomely to be mucked about.

I don't quite know what to make of McDermott (and the GM). The decision to start Peterman was so abominally bad on so many levels that it's hard to really believe he knows what he's doing. The decision to get rid of all decent WR targets, the best run-stopper and play a scheme that Taylor doesn't fit is just mind boggling.

And yet they've reached the playoffs. But at 9-7 their record isn't that much better than it was under Rex Ryan (8-8, 7-9) and Doug Marrone (6-10, 9-7). That playoff spot may well be the worst thing that happens to them but at least fans in Buffalo finally get to cheer the team in the postseason this century :-)

To me, they still have question marks at the most important positions - GM, coach and QB.

Login or Register to post comments

31 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Mountain Time ---- formerly Ninjalectual // Jan 01, 2018 - 8:38am

You make completely valid arguments.

But on the other hand, this is a team that gave Joe Webb meaningful snaps at QB, and to me that makes up for some of it. IIRC Webb was not awful (nearly average even?) for a Minnesota team that did nothing at all to play to his strengths, treating him as some regular qb. Therefore I expected him to play well in a scheme actually designed for him. Obviously he's unlikely to get that on the Bills though for reasons already discussed.

Login or Register to post comments

54 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 01, 2018 - 1:23pm

Joe Webb was awful for the Vikings. It was only the awfulness of The Ponderous One which mitigated the wholly accurate perception of Webb's awfulness

Login or Register to post comments

96 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ZDNeal // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:57am

You need to basically play some sort of wishbone backfield for Joe Webb. Or 5 wide and hope the other team doesn't realize he's not going to throw.

Login or Register to post comments

35 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 9:09am

I really hope Taylor wins a wild card game and then holds out next year for a huge raise. Buffalo's ownership needs to be punished for the last year.

Login or Register to post comments

39 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by billsfan // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:39am

...and most of the two decades prior.

Login or Register to post comments

40 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 11:19am

Incompetence is one thing. Idiotic malice is another.

Login or Register to post comments

50 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by RickD // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:37pm

The notion of Tyrod Taylor holding out for anything is hilarious.

Login or Register to post comments

64 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Aaron Brooks Good Twin // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:59pm

A forced trade to Baltimore would be the ideal end game.

Buffalo gets their long-cherished Taylor-free existence.
Baltimore gets a cheap QB with experience on that team and can enjoy a Flacco-free existence.

Flacco gets picked up by some team instead of Kaepernick. It's wins all around.

Login or Register to post comments

37 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Dennis // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:31am

I haven't seen anyplace mention hiw the Ravens missed the playoffs because they accepted a penalty they should have declined. On the last drive, Cincy was had a first down incompletion and was called for an illegal shift. The loss of down is much more valuable to the defense at that point - cincy was still out of fg range so the 5 yards wouldn't make a difference in that regard. But Baltimore accepted the penalty so still first down. The Ravens stopped them the next three plays. If they declined the penalty it's game over. But instead it's 4th down and cincy has one more play, and sure enough, not only do they get the first down, it goes for a TD.

Login or Register to post comments

41 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by JMM // Jan 01, 2018 - 11:34am

Good catch. I mentioned it at the time, but forgot about it afterwards in all the hub-bub.

Login or Register to post comments

43 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Anon Ymous // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:10pm

Perhaps, but the change in situation likely leads Cincy to make different decisions, particularly with that many more plays and the significant difference in distance. Perhaps you could make that argument if it happened on 3rd and 20, but not first and 10.

Login or Register to post comments

81 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Dennis // Jan 01, 2018 - 11:26pm

Obviously you can't say for sure that the next three plays would have had the same result if they declined the penalty, but I doubt the play calling would have been much different. I don't think 5 yards in this situation is a "significant difference", and one down isn't "that many more plays." In any event, I'd love to see the percentages on getting a first down from 2nd and 10 compared to 1st and 15. It seems like the extra down has a much bigger effect than the five yards.

Login or Register to post comments

82 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Anon Ymous // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:06am

It isn't "one down" it's three. And 5 extra yards compared to the original 10 is a much bigger difference than you are indicating.

You may be right about declining being the better option, but it's unwise to think the subsequent plays would have gone similarly.

Login or Register to post comments

86 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by dryheat // Jan 02, 2018 - 9:53am

I thought the same thing, and then wondered if perhaps it was automatically enforced as a pre-snap penalty? I didn't see any communication between the referee and the Ravens sideline after the flag.

Login or Register to post comments

49 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by justanothersteve // Jan 01, 2018 - 12:36pm

The strangest thing about the upcoming playoffs is either the Bills or Jags will make the second round of the playoffs. Blake Bortles, playoff QB. I'm still processing that.

Login or Register to post comments

59 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by morganja // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:37pm

Panthers played as if they wanted the Saints in the first round. Strange how Cam Newton has days where everything he throws is off and high, and other days when he is accurate.

Login or Register to post comments

65 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Eddo // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:13pm

I would think the Panthers expected the Saints to beat Tampa Bay, so if they were paying to lose, it would have been to face the Rams, no?

Not that I think they were - they just had a somewhat off game on the road against a good opponent.

Login or Register to post comments

67 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:22pm

His footwork is terrible. Its better than it was in college, but still terrible. Its hard to be accurate when your base, hip rotation, drive, etc are inconsistent. Some days are better than others.

This is the big problem with guys who can win with their feet (or ridiculous arms) - they often don't need to be fundamentally sound to win - so they develop bad habits that are really hard to fix.

Login or Register to post comments

69 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 01, 2018 - 4:25pm

The Saga of Lazy Jay Cutler!

Login or Register to post comments

89 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by jtr // Jan 02, 2018 - 10:58am

Cam uses his crazy arm strength to make all sorts of crazy throws from insane positions and without being able to step into them. But then he'll often lean back and chuck it off his back foot even from a clean pocket. I love him as a highlight reel player because of the former, but if I was a Panthers fan the latter would absolutely drive me nuts.

Login or Register to post comments

90 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:09am

The rejoinder to this view is always how Favre did so much with poor mechanics, but I think this overlooks how much better Favre was when he had a coach, even one with whom he had no rapport, like The Chiller, who was willing to tear him a new one when he became too sloppy. It's no coincidence that the years between Holmgren leaving, and McCarthy arriving, are the worst in Favre's extremely long career.

Login or Register to post comments

95 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 02, 2018 - 11:38am

This reminds me of an interview that Chad Johnson/Ochocinco did after his brief stint in NE about how different the environment was compared to Cinci.

He was absolutely shocked how brutal Belichick was with Brady during film sessions and practice - he'd always been told that you absolutely do not criticize your quarterback, especially not in front of other players.

I think there are a good chunk of coaches out there that think quarterbacks are fragile things that need to have their ego protected.

Login or Register to post comments

97 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by BJR // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:07pm

Brady obviously responds well to such open and brutal criticism. Not all players will, and not just because they are precious snowflakes; people have different personalities. I would imagine Belichick treats every player according to how he thinks he will get the best effort out of them, as any good manager should, and that will involve treating some with a much softer touch.

Login or Register to post comments

98 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by aces4me // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:09pm

Or the manager (coach) has a style that works for him and a lot of players. The ones that don't respond don't stick and the ones that do respond excel.

Login or Register to post comments

100 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by jtr // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:16pm

Agreed. One detail that stuck with me from reading Collision Low Crossers (which is an inside look on 2011 Jets) is that Antonio Cromartie was so thin-skinned that he was almost impossible to coach. If someone critiqued him at all in a film session, he would throw a fit and storm out. Rex Ryan was able to navigate his personality, at least for a little while, and he formed an elite cornerback duo with Darrelle Revis that was the cornerstone of several years of excellent Jets defense. I suspect that Belichick would not have the soft touch to deal with Cro; he's more of a my-way-or-the-highway kind of coach. Belichick is also one of the few coaches in the league who is good enough to jettison talented players due to personality issues and still have a successful team--like Jamie Collins and Chandler Jones, for instance.

Login or Register to post comments

104 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Hoodie_Sleeves // Jan 02, 2018 - 1:31pm

The big problem with pandering to the Cromarties of the world is that it becomes effectively impossible to hold anyone accountable for poor performance without making your good employees feel like they're being singled out or treated unfairly.

I think everyone has been in that situation at work where you get chewed out for something that wasn't your fault - its absolutely terrible for morale.

Ryan's defenses have always struck me as very undisciplined - lots of personal fouls, late hits, and just general stupidity (the same sort of nonsense we see in Cinci with Lewis's teams). I mean, really, can you imagine one of Belichick's players picking up an official's flag and throwing it into the stands?

Login or Register to post comments

105 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Bright Blue Shorts // Jan 02, 2018 - 1:53pm

Just an aside ... Cromartie apparently now has 14 children - six with his wife and the other eight with seven different women. Clearly he doesn't have any performance issues but think that says a lot about where lack of discipline and accountability leads!

Login or Register to post comments

115 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by theslothook // Jan 03, 2018 - 12:06am

I thought he had a vasectomy, which nullified my previous hunch that he was intentionally trying to start a dynasty.

My god, he must have GOAT level sperm.

Login or Register to post comments

118 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by LionInAZ // Jan 04, 2018 - 6:00pm

"... can you imagine one of Belichick's players picking up an official's flag and throwing it into the stands?"

Yes, yes I can. Gronkowski.

Login or Register to post comments

101 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Will Allen // Jan 02, 2018 - 12:27pm

There is truth in this, but managing 60 highly paid people is much, much, more likely to be very successful when the best performer/one of the highest paid performers responds well to being openly and very publicly held accountable, in a very, very, frank manner. If such a person does not respond well to that treatment, especially the qb, then you should have some caution in tying him to the organization for the very long term.

Login or Register to post comments

106 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by sbond101 // Jan 02, 2018 - 2:05pm

There is so much obvious truth in this set of statements. Football is the ultimate team game in that 60 players being in the right places and executing there jobs competently will very consistently defeat a much more talented group of players who are not properly organized (out of position, not executing prescribed technique, etc...). As a result teams very rarely get sustained success out of players that cannot be coached hard (and those exceptions are limited to players whose failures do not compromise the integrity of a unit, e.g. a one-dimensional deep threat receiver, a kick/punt returner, or a true "man" corner on a team with an otherwise-solid run defense). It's a big part of what makes player-evaluation in the NFL such a difficult problem, and a big part of why addition-by-subtraction is such a big thing in the NFL. Teams would broadly be better off if gm's/owners realized that team integrity and standing behind your coach is almost always more important than any talented player (including any non-HOF QB).

Login or Register to post comments

109 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by big10freak // Jan 02, 2018 - 4:33pm

Setting Mike Sherman's awful work as GM his one really positive moment was realizing since he could not get his HOF qb to accept any coaching he made Ahman Green the focal point of the offense after the bye week in 2003. Favre's pass attempts dropped by 70 from the previous year and Green gained almost 1900 yards.

(Sherman gave away his brilliance by the worst tactical decision of any Packers coach of the last 20 years when he didn't try and get the first down against the Eagles in the playoffs.)

But getting back to Sherman/Favre Mike just could not get 4 to take him seriously. So everyone else was coached. Except Favre. And it wasn't like Sherman was a candy9ss. The man took on Warren Sapp after Sapp cheapshotted Chad clifton (almost ending Clifton's career)

Alas, Sherman sabotaged himself via his inability to get Favre to take things more seriously.

Login or Register to post comments

60 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Chip // Jan 01, 2018 - 3:47pm

Re: Knowles / Fox

Yes, fans were excited about Fox and rightfully so. His successful track record as a "restructuring / turnaround" coach was exactly what was needed after the Trestman/Emery debacle. The Bears were late in the HC recruiting process bc they had to hire a GM first. And he was the most talented remaining candidate after a surprising early playoff exit.

His tenure has been marred by injuries: 16 on IR in 2017, incl. 10 likely wk 1 starters (with another 6 cleared from IR with injury settlements). 21 on IR in 2016.

The injury bug makes it difficult to evaluate Ryan Pace and Fox to a lesser extent.

That said, it's time to move on from Fox with a focus on an offensive mind. He had a good run and his greatest strength is likely in assembling strong coaching staff. But his lack of OFF focus with Trubisky, conservative game plans (run, run, pass, punt), conservative 4th down approach, etc., did him in.

Login or Register to post comments

70 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by brecherdc // Jan 01, 2018 - 5:30pm

If yall are going to put "(AAA)" next to Pittsburgh, you probably should do the same with with Rams.

(And maybe put the final score there too?)

Login or Register to post comments

73 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Andrew Potter // Jan 01, 2018 - 5:51pm

So short was the 49ers-Rams segment that I completely missed the header in editing. Fixed.

Login or Register to post comments

75 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by Bryan Knowles // Jan 01, 2018 - 6:42pm

This is because I normally send, like, 20 emails about a 6-10 team. This may be a more useful skill next season.

Login or Register to post comments

72 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by justanothersteve // Jan 01, 2018 - 5:49pm

None of the staff watched Packers@Lions, or at least commented on it. This is probably for the best.

Login or Register to post comments

79 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ChrisS // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:49pm

I watched it.

Login or Register to post comments

107 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by JoeyHarringtonsPiano // Jan 02, 2018 - 2:10pm

Not sure you can take much away from that game, other than that Brett Hundley is really bad. I suppose you can criticize Dom Capers and his defense for giving up 35 points, but I don't think they played particularly terribly (outside of a handful of long passes). Their offense kept putting them in awful spots.

When evaluating Caldwell's last season, it should be kept in mind that he got a bit lucky by having two Aaron Rodgers-free games against the Packers.

Login or Register to post comments

110 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ChrisS // Jan 02, 2018 - 6:25pm

I hate when a team gets a 15 yard penalty so they kick from the 50 yard line and then just kick the ball through the end zone. The Lions did not do this, they kicked high and short to the 5-10 yard line and GB started the drive at the 15 (hurrah for small victories). GB's on-side kick to start the game was great and also a very under-utilized play. The Lions 2 point conversion was also a thing of beauty, direct snap to Abdullah (as Stafford moved down the line calling out audibles) going right, flip to Golden Tate going the opposite direction, pass to Stafford wide open in the end zone. Prettiest play of the year for the Lions (I guess I love me some special teams).

Login or Register to post comments

112 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by PatsFan // Jan 02, 2018 - 8:04pm

It was even more annoying in the 2007 NE/BAL game where Bart Scott had a conniption and picked up two unsportsmanlike conduct penalties, leading NE to kick off from the BAL 35. Belichick had Gostkowski kick it into the stands. Really wish he had done an onsides kick.

Login or Register to post comments

116 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by JoeyHarringtonsPiano // Jan 03, 2018 - 7:50am

Yea that 2pt conversion was fun, but why did they save all those plays for when they had nothing to play for? Makes me wonder if it was Caldwell that was holding Cooter back from being a more aggressive play caller, because he was too worried about something bad happening.

Login or Register to post comments

119 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by LionInAZ // Jan 04, 2018 - 6:08pm

Unlucky in that Case Keenum put up his Josh McCown epic season. Ridiculous.

Worse is wasting a 5-1 division record by blowing games against vulnerable opps outside the division.

Login or Register to post comments

76 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by liquidmuse3 // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:23pm

Kind of a dick comment about Rick Smith, Rivers. And I guess picking the defensive player of his generation (JJ Watt) outside the top ten doesn’t merit mention.

Login or Register to post comments

120 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by LionInAZ // Jan 04, 2018 - 6:12pm

Nonsense. Rivers showed sympathy for his situation and praised good decisions, while pointing out bad choices. Unless you think signing Osweiler to a huge contract didn't counteract the good choice of drafting Watt.

Login or Register to post comments

77 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by liquidmuse3 // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:23pm

Kind of a dick comment about Rick Smith, Rivers. And I guess picking the defensive player of his generation (JJ Watt) outside the top ten doesn’t merit mention.

Login or Register to post comments

78 Re: Audibles at the Line: Week 17

by ChrisS // Jan 01, 2018 - 10:48pm


Login or Register to post comments