Walkthrough: Interventions

Walkthrough: Interventions
Walkthrough: Interventions
Photo: USA Today Sports Images

by Mike Tanier

Did you recognize the pigeon playing special teams for the Raiders?

Parents with small children identified him immediately. He was Pigeon, the star of such preschool classics as The Pigeon Wants a Puppy, Don't Let the Pigeon Stay Up Late, and Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus. Al Davis remembers how useful pigeons from his combat experience in World War I (he flew a Fokker DVII), so he signed the free agent Pigeon, who waited over a week to report.

I contacted Pigeon through his spokesman, cartoonist and award winning children's author Mo Willems.

Walkthrough: Did you really join the Raiders?

Pigeon: Yes, I did it. I'd had enough of those Eagles. Think they're so big just because they're on money. I'm on the Woodstock poster!

Walkthrough: Will there be a book tie-in to your football appearance? Paper Pigeon, or A Few Seconds of Pigeon? Or Don't Let the Pigeon Assault an Assistant Coach?

Pigeon: I've been trying to branch out from children's books. I don't want to be pigeon-holed.

Oakland's Newest Star

Walkthrough: What about you, Mo? Did you have any input on Pigeon's decision?

Mo Willems: I saw this as a great Kids Book/Pro Football cross over. You'd be surprised how much Children's Lit and Football have in common. Besides this, nothing. But that's still more than I would have suspected.

Sounds like a man who has never read Walkthrough.

Jet Slump

Three straight losses were a disguised blessing for Mark Sanchez and the Jets. All of the Matt Ryan-Joe Namath talk has subsided. The New York media's attention is temporarily elsewhere. Expectations for Sanchez are now much more realistic: he can focus on winning some games, developing his skills, and keeping the Jets in the playoff picture instead of worrying about the specter of Namath.

Sanchez's five-interception performance last week was the result of several factors. It was the first bad weather game of his career, and he clearly had some trouble with the Meadowlands wind. Receivers Jerricho Cotchery and Brad Smith were both injured, so the Jets top receiver was Braylon Edwards, who was just signed a few weeks ago. Under the circumstances, any quarterback would struggle.

But how much of Sanchez's bad day can be chalked up to injuries, inexperience, and bad weather? Did the Bills reveal some fatal flaw in Sanchez's game? To find out, I watched the Jets-Bills game (it was torture), focusing on Sanchez's worst throws. I saw a rattled rookie who is going to make a few more mistakes, but I also saw a Jets team with too few experienced, reliable receiving targets to establish a passing game.

Figure 1: Jets Rollout Interception

Figure 1 shows Sanchez's interception early in the third quarter. The Jets run a play-action pass from a two-tight end set on second-and-11. With Dustin Keller (81) lined up between the left tackle and wing tight end Ben Hartsock (84), the Bills put safety George Wilson in the C-gap, inside right defensive end Aaron Schobel. Wilson's alignment, coupled with the fact that both cornerbacks are split wide to the right and there's a high safety, makes this an easy read, even for a young cornerback. This is man-free coverage, and the Jets play call, a waggle by Sanchez, is well-suited to exploit that coverage.

The problem is that no one gets open. Typically, Keller, running a corner route, is the first read on a rollout like this. Hartsock, running a quick shake route into the flat, is the second option. David Clowney (87), running a deep cross, is the third option, and a run by the quarterback is a fourth option. Keller doesn't get a clean release, and Wilson never strays from his assignment during the play action. Hartsock does not elude the linebacker covering him; he also releases poorly, bumping into Schobel and alerting the defender to drop into flat zone/quarterback spy coverage on the back side. Clowney drifts into the middle of the field but doesn't get open. Sanchez underthrows his pass (wind may have been a factor), and Wilson makes an athletic play.

Jets receivers, whose routes are outlined in red, could have done a much better job on this play. Hartsock should have taken his inside move further inside, or sold his linebacker that he was run blocking. Had he done either of those things, he could have given Sanchez a better outlet receiver. I don't know Clowney's exact route assignment, but when running a deep cross a receiver usually bends his route so he crosses in front of a deep middle safety. Clowney just drifts into him, and he's running like a third option who doesn't think he'll get the ball. Sanchez made a mistake, but better receivers would have given him better opportunities.

Figure 2: Jets Two-Man Route Pick

Figure 2 shows an interception from later in the quarter. This is another play-action pass, and the Jets work hard to sell it. Wayne Hunter (75) enters the game as a tackle eligible, Hartsock goes in motion toward the formation, and at the snap, left tackle D'Brickashaw Ferguson pulls left as if leading a sweep. The Bills have eight defenders crowding the box, and the play-action pulls them in while slowing the pass rush.

Sanchez only has two receivers on this route: Edwards on a go-route and Clowney on a deep cross. Sanchez stares Edwards down the whole way, drawing deep safety support. Edwards expects to turn outside and catch the ball on his far shoulder, but Sanchez's pass flutters to the inside. Free safety Byrd easily gets into position to intercept a jump ball.

Sanchez made a bad read (Clowney got inside his defender), locked onto his receiver, and threw a bad pass, but the play call is also questionable. Edwards is the only real playmaker running a pattern on this play. With Hunter as an eligible receiver, the Jets lose the ability to use a real tight end as an outlet receiver. Again, this is a personnel problem exacerbated by injuries. With Cotchery and Smith available, the Jets are far less likely to call two-man route combinations.

Figure 3: Near Pick on Slant

Figure 3 isn't an interception; it's a near pick at the end of the third quarter. Here, the Jets are making the best use of their available personnel. With Smith and Cotchery hurt, Leon Washington (29) is their second-best receiver, and he's isolated on the right side with the other receivers to the left. The Bills aren't trying to fool anyone with their pre-snap alignment. They appear to be in Cover 3, with Wilson as a deep defender to his side. Sanchez should have no problem hitting Washington on a skinny slant.

Sanchez's problem on this pass is -- let me cue Ron Jaworski here -- eye discipline. He starts looking to Washington's side before he completes his three-step drop. He leads the outside linebacker, who has responsibility in that flat anyway, right to Washington. Luckily, linebacker Keith Ellison only tips the pass. This is an example of a classic rookie mistake, the kind that is easy to correct.

Figure 4: Edwards Tip Pick

Sanchez's fourth-quarter interception doesn't initially seem like his fault (Fig. 4). The ball is tipped in the air by Edwards, then picked off by Reggie Corner. Sanchez does a better job with his eye discipline on this pass, looking toward Washington long enough to move linebacker Ellison away from Edwards.

The problem is that Sanchez makes the wrong read. The Bills are in Cover-3, with Corner slipping back at the snap into a deep zone. In that coverage, Washington will beat Ellison into the right flat, giving him an easy catch and a chance to run for extra yardage. On fourth-and-3 in a tie ballgame, Sanchez has to trust Washington to make three easy yards. Instead, he fakes, then works inside. Against a basic Cover-2 defense, that might be the right decision. It wasn't in this case. Edwards, of course, has a reputation as a pass dropper, and the problem is made worse by the fact that he and Sanchez are still developing their timing.

Sanchez is a very impressive rookie quarterback who will be able to win several more games this season once he has a full complement of offensive weapons. Offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer's overall game plan against the Bills was excellent: he established the run and stuck with it, calling pass plays that emphasized play action and protection. It's up to the players to execute, and when Sanchez wasn't battling the wind or making mistakes, Edwards and Keller were dropping passes, or Clowney and Hartsock were running bad routes. The problem will self-correct once Cotchery and Smith return. Until then, Sanchez can live without the Namath comparisons.

Around the League

In Frisco

MIKE SINGLETARY: Listen up, troops! Michael Crabtree just ended his hunger strike and signed with the team. I need a volunteer to get him in shape, preferably a quarterback, preferably someone with nothing better to do.

ALEX SMITH: Ooh! Ooh! I'll do it! I'll do it!

SINGLETARY: Hey that's great. Any other volunteers? Anyone? Don't be shy.

In Dallas

TIGER WOODS: Thank you for inviting me to this U2 concert, Mr. Jones. This new stadium is truly amazing. I found a gold-inlaid alabaster sculpture in the men's bathroom.

JERRY JONES: That's a urinal cake, son.

BONO: Hello Dallas! We're proud to be here. As you know, U2 and the NFL go way back. We performed at halftime of the Super Bowl after the 2001 season. We performed before the first game at the Super Dome after Hurricane Katrina. Thanks to us, America has no more foreign policy concerns, and all of New Orleans' post-flood problems have been solved!

TONY ROMO: Any hot blondes in this band?

STEPHEN MCGEE: Mr. Jones, thanks for bringing Tiger Woods to the practice facility so an obscure backup like me could meet him. He's the greatest athlete of all time in my opinion.

TIGER: That's nice kid. And you say you share a locker room with DeMarcus Ware?

Back in San Francisco

SINGLETARY: Anyone? I am still looking for a volunteer. Someone who can throw a spiral about 20 yards without fumbling.

SMITH: Please, coach. My wife is busy during the day anyway, so I can come and get in a workout.

ALEX SMITH'S WIFE: It's true, coach. I'm busy, and he's not. He's always underfoot, driving me nuts. All he does is stalk more successful quarterbacks on Facebook. Right, dear?

SMITH: Not now, babe. (typing into laptop) I'll show you who has more hits in Mafia Wars, Fitzpatrick.

In Washington

JASON CAMPBELL: I'm eager to learn my twelfth offensive system in the last 13 years. Who is the new play caller?

JIM ZORN: No one knows.

CAMPBELL: Coach Lewis, is it you?


ZORN: Sorry, kid. Sherm cannot really talk. His voice is so powerful that if he utters one word it will destroy a small city. He cannot call plays.

CAMPBELL: Who will call them then? Mr. Snyder?

DAN SNYDER: No kid, I am too busy deep-frying $100 bills and eating them with honey mustard dressing. We have a new guy. His identity is top secret, but he is a mastermind capable of creating and implementing outlandish schemes, the kind that can fool the whole country, at least for a short time.

CAMPBELL: I'm sold. I'll just wait for instructions in my helmet headset.

MYSTERIOUS VOICE: Jason, I want to you to hide in the garage while I launch this balloon.

Back in Dallas

JERRY: Go ahead, Tiger. Hit one off the giant scoreboard.

TIGER: If you say so, Mr. Jones.

Tiger strikes a golf ball with a driver. It crashes into the giant Cowboys scoreboard, which shatters into millions of tiny fragments.

TIGER: Oh my God! I'm so sorry!

JERRY: holding a remote controlThink nothing of it, son.

With a press of a button, an identical scoreboard unfolds from the stadium roof...

TIGER: That's amazing, Mr. Jones. But it's all so over-indulgent. All of this for a football team? One that can barely beat the Chiefs? Think of all the good we could do if we just invested the money it costs to build a giant scoreboard into something purposeful, like debt relief for Africa.

BONO: Screw that and pass me a nine iron.

Back in Frisco

SINGLETARY: Last call, troops. Arnaz Battle, you played quarterback in college, right? Maybe you can throw to Crabtree. Maybe one of the linemen can visit him.

SMITH: Coach, I know I disappointed the organization. I know you have no confidence in me. But I have made the Bay Area my home, and I am eager to help this team in any way I can.


SMITH: Yes coach. What do you need?

SINGLETARY: We'd like to transplant your knee ligaments into Frank Gore.

Elam Update

I am about 75 percent of the way through Monday Night Jihad, the Jason Elam and Steve Yohn thriller about Riley Covington, an Air Force officer turned linebacker who battles a group of terrorists led by "The Cheetah," an Iraqi deep-plant operative disguised as an Italian tight end named Sal Ricci.

If you read that last sentence and your head didn't explode, you'll be happy to know that my full review will appear next week. If you cannot wait until then, join the Facebook group Walkthrough Readers. I am sending out periodic updates about my progress as a form of therapy.

Even if you don't care about Elam's novel, you can still join the group.

The Sacking of Donovan McNabb

The Eagles got some good news when they learned Jason Peters' injury isn't serious. Peters will be back at left tackle this week, replacing King Dunlap, who sounds like a small-town machine politician from a Faulkner novel.

The bad news is that Peters isn't very good, and that the Eagles offensive line as a whole has taken a step back from last season. Worse yet, it's that time of year again: Andy Reid has officially abandoned the run. He won't call two consecutive handoffs again until the Eagles are below .500 and every fan in Philadelphia has ripped his own hair out.

There's nothing wrong with pass-heavy gameplans, of course, but Reid takes them to the extreme. When the Eagles leave their running game in the locker room, they start playing terrible situational football. It happened last season when they tied the Bengals. It happened on Sunday. If it keeps happening this season, the Eagles will fall too far behind the conference leaders to execute one of their patented December comebacks.

Figure 5: Eagles Sack 1

Figure 5 shows the Eagles facing third-and-10 from the Raiders' 27-yard line. The Eagles are in field position, but their offense is in disarray. Donovan McNabb burned two timeouts on the previous two plays, both of them incomplete passes. On one of the passes, he was hurried and barely got rid of the football. The Raiders called a timeout just before this play started, and it's clear that the Eagles offense has absolutely no rhythm. It's a great time for the Raiders to blitz.

I diagram a lot of blitzes, and I usually point out how great the scheme or the execution was. There's nothing special about this blitz. Gerard Warren (61), Richard Seymour (92), and Trevor Scott (91) all attack the offensive left side to pressure King Dunlap (65). Strong safety Tyvon Branch (33) follows them on a very late delayed blitz. The rush is muddy and imprecise, so the Eagles line initially picks it up very well. Right guard Max Jean-Gilles is even able to slide over to support the left-side pass protectors.

McNabb takes a two-step drop from shotgun, pumps quickly, then backpedals two more steps. Two receivers run short hitches, but McNabb is looking for Jeremy Maclin (18) up the seam. McNabb waits too long, and Dunlap is eventually overpowered by Seymour. The eight-yard sack takes the Eagles out of field goal range.

The Raiders did some things right on this play. Seymour was relentless after initial contact, and the secondary kept Maclin from breaking free. This sack, however, is all on McNabb and Andy Reid. It's an example of bad situational football.

Remember that the Eagles are in field goal range. They are on the road, facing a bad team, and their offense is playing poorly. They need points, but they don't necessarily need a touchdown. A three-yard completion on third-and-10 would yield points, as would a short scramble. An incompletion would result in a makable 45-yard field goal.

The figure shows most of the Raiders pass rush congested on the offensive left. That created a large hole up the field and to McNabb's right. McNabb probably would not have gained ten yards before the safeties converged, but he would have gained three or four. Passes to the hitch receivers, left open in short zone coverage, could have netted about five yards. McNabb instead waits for the deep pass, backpedaling despite the fact that his left tackle is trying to block an All-Pro.

Reid, meanwhile, refused to call a safer play to net three points. It's better to be aggressive and play for six in most situations, but the Eagles were in no position to gamble at this point in the game. Coming on the heels of a near sack and two misplaced timeouts, with Dunlap at left tackle and Brian Westbrook on the sidelines, a draw play was the best call, especially against a Raiders team that can be beaten by field goals.

Figure 6: Play-Action Sack

Figure 6 shows another example of bad situational football. It's second-and-2 in the third quarter. The Eagles have the ball at the 48-yard line. If you think the Eagles are going to run up the middle, get the first down, and try to grind down the field, you've never watched them when Reid was in pass-at-all-costs mode.

The Eagles run play-action from a two-tight end, two-back set. They use a seven-man protection scheme, with Alex Smith (82, I swear the Eagles got another tight end named Smith just to torture me) and Shady McCoy (29) as extra blockers. The Raiders only rush four defenders. There's no excuse for a Raiders sack.

As the diagram shows, three Eagles blockers triple-team Warren. Smith chips Jay Richardson (98), before leaking out into a route. Richardson bounces off Smith's block, works behind the Warren commission, and attacks the gap McCoy is supposed to protect. Richardson is freelancing, and McCoy doesn't expect a defensive end to come through his gap, so he whiffs badly. McNabb compounds the problem by backpedaling in an attempt to scramble, a tactic that worked for him seven years ago. The Eagles lose 13 yards and a great field position opportunity.

It's second-and-short, your offense is struggling, you have two healthy backs. Why go for the deep ball? Reid was tying the offense in knots to cover for Dunlap at this point. He rolled protection to the left and put two tight ends on the left side on some plays. On other plays, he even moved his backs to the line to chip outside rushers, as shown in Figure 7 (the next play in the game). The only thing Reid didn't do is run the ball on obvious running downs.

Figure 7: Eagles Max Protect

With Peters back, the Eagles will be able to run their regular offense. Their annual wake-up call about running the football may have come early this season. Reid usually doesn't bring the running game back until hope is nearly lost, often after McNabb has missed a few games and a backup has won a game or two with a stripped-down gameplan. The backup has already come and gone this season. The Eagles are a playoff team if they play smarter. When they are playing dumb, any team in the league can beat them.

Note: Pigeon art copyright 2009 by Mo Willems.


42 comments, Last at 26 Oct 2009, 10:23pm

3 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Gibril Wilson is a member of the Miami Dolphins, not the Buffalo Bills.

I see a George Wilson listed on the depth chart though.

"...makes this an easy read, even for a young cornerback."

I think we're talking about Quarterbacks here. Specifically Mark Sanchez.

Glad to see you recovered after that sticky start. Good article. Garage/balloon part was hilarious.

32 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

he was a wide reciever for several years with the team, wasn't picked up in 2007, then came on board as a street free agent after a string of injuries left them playing him as a safety in the disastrous MNF game against the cowboys where he picked off a pass (one of five that romo threw) for a TD.

he's a special-teams captain, but rarely sees the field except when injuries decimate the secondary.

1 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Right! At one point I think they used to wear the same number... I'll fix this for Mike.

4 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

And the fact that there are two G. Wilson safeties in the AFCE is bad enough. Especially when one is apparently a backup, so it's not like you're thinking "wait, there are two G. Wilsons." If not for my friend constantly harping about the Phins and how Gibril sucks, I would've probably made the same mistake myself.

5 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Well done Mr Tanier, I think this has been my favorite walkthrough this year.

To find out, I watched the Jets-Bills game (it was torture)

Between this and the Elam book, I feel sorry for you.

34 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

I thought that last weeks article was way better than this one. I find that interesting (though maybe I shouldn't as it doesn't seem all that noteworthy).

Still my favorite sports writer though.

8 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

That first statement is exactly how I've always imagined Bono would sound. And I think that's the first time I've heard someone other than me be willing to even so much as poke fun at him. (I will outright insult him, but that's just me.)

25 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

I refuse to listen to them.

Not only are they completely unfunny, but they have caused irreparable harm to the academic reputation of my undergraduate college (and especially to its otherwise-excellent film program). I refuse to promote them in any manner.

18 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Just like in the old Nike ad - Bono's football! Bono's golf! No wonder they had to raise the scoreborad - not enough room for thhose two huge egos AND an electronic monstrosity.

26 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Fair enough, though it does not comment on Bono's monumental ego, which is what actually bothers me about him (aside from his music).

9 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Al Davis remembers how useful pigeons from his combat experience in World War I (he flew a Fokker DVII)

Al Davis fought for the Germans? He's is even more evil than I thought.

Nice job. The game analysis is very well done, even if it involves two of the most poorly played games you're likely to see all season.

27 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

The game analysis is very well done, even if it involves two of the most poorly played games you're likely to see all season.

I see you've missed all of the Redskins games thus far. I hope they are never on national TV again.

"Just look at that pumpkin."
-John Madden, looking at the moon.

28 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Well, yeah, I've managed to avoid the Dreadskins thus far. Still, I see nothing of their record to suggest that they can compete with Jets-Bills or Browns-Bengals. Yet, the season is still young.

10 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Holy Jeez:

Sherm cannot really talk. His voice is so powerful that if he utters one word it will destroy a small city. He cannot call plays.

Plus you're working in current events now with Balloon Boy? Genius.

"King Dunlap, who sounds like a small-town machine politician from a Faulkner novel." And the gems keep right on coming.

That Elam book sounds fabulous! I have to buy two: one to read in the bathroom and one to... er, use in the bathroom.

29 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

"Sherm cannot really talk. His voice is so powerful that if he utters one word it will destroy a small city. He cannot call plays."

I always knew Snyder's ideal coach would be Inhuman.

I just didn't know it would be Black Bolt!

11 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Catch the pigeon, catch the pigeon!
Catch the pigeon, catch the pigeon!!
Catch the pigeon, catch the pigeon!!!

Catch that pigeon NOW!!!!

And repeat.

12 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Meanwhile, Brees' matchup saw him take on the league's best pass defense, a Giants team that had allowed opposing #1 and #2 receivers a combined 43 yards per game.


So nothing from Bill Barnwell about his advice on his ESPN fantasy column to bench Drew Brees this week?
To be fair to Bill, I was contemplating Brees versus Hasselbeck based on matchups, and he advised Brees. I'm relieved that I took his advice.


That wasn't Bill in the coffee shop was it?

13 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

I normally discount somewhat playcalling criticisms substantially, in that the critic often doesn't account for the limitations of players on the field. In this case, however, the playcaller has had substantial input over what kind of players are on the field for a very long time. If the playcaller still can't call running plays when they are warranted, something that has gone on for a long time, due to player limitations, it's largely the playcaller's own damned fault.

15 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Be fair - it was a Reid/McNabb team-up for failure. In the first Eagles play diagram, Reid called a play that had Maclin deep as the intended target, but McNabb completely ignored the two underneath receivers wide open in the soft zone. Both were talented WR's that could have made plays with the ball in their hands, so overlooking the short throw is doubly egregious.

Also, McNabb not having the awareness to know they are on the very edge of field-goal range (in a close game) or trying to call a time-out when the Eagles didn't have any or ignoring outlet passes to the TE and RB when a few yards really would've mattered or running a terrible hurry-up offense - that's even more of a problem. Again, calling too many passes was probably a bad idea, but McNabb played a significant part in making sure the calls were a disaster.

The bad offense was a team effort!

(also, thanks for the analysis, Mike - which fully supports and explains exactly what i was arguing in the DVOA rating thread...)

17 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions: pigeon

I thought this was for serious football fans. All this talk about the Oakland Pigeon and not one observation that he was the first one down the field and the only one who stayed in his lane. *That* boys, is coachin' em up.

22 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Ha! I shave my head. Harris-1, Reid-0. On the other hand, I do have a huge bruise from banging my forehead on the floor while screaming "Why?! Why won't they run the ball?"

Hail Hydra!

23 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Am I the only person that thought the Frisco Diaries was the funniest part of the article. The last part was killer, I am glad I hadn't just taken a drink just before I read it or else my laptop would be drenched with tea.

30 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

... Riley Covington, an Air Force officer turned linebacker who battles a group of terrorists led by "The Cheetah," an Iraqi deep-plant operative disguised as an Italian tight end named Sal Ricci.

Quick. Someone call Max Bialystock.

31 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions


SMITH: Yes coach. What do you need?

SINGLETARY: We'd like to transplant your knee ligaments into Frank Gore.

THis made my day, hilarious!

38 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Loved the pigeon bit too. Whole article was top notch. Thanks.

39 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Elam update: there's another one out, and a third due next year. I hope you we can enjoy them all together.

40 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

The "Frisco" segments don't seem quite as funny after Smith's performance in Houston, now do they?

41 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

Actually, they weren't that funny to start with.

Not to mention, there's a mini-dig at Ryan Fitzpatrick, and he started and won this week.

If I were an NFL QB, I might consider paying F.O. to take shots at me every week.

42 Re: Walkthrough: Interventions

It's even funnier now that Smith almost pulled off the comeback win and is now the starting QB for the 49ers...

Save 10%
& Support Mike
Support Football Outsiders' independent media and . Use promo code TANIER to save 10% on any FO+ membership and give half the cost of your membership to tip Mike.