Football Outsiders
Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis

ESPN: 10 Most Disappointing Fantasy Seasons

Continuing our series on NFL disappointments, today we look at players who burned their fantasy owners: Lots of guys struck by the Curse of 370, a couple disappointing quarterbacks, and the long-lost forgotten horrible 2001 season of Derrick Alexander.

View Full Article

Comments

5 comments, Last at 25 Jun 2011, 8:14pm

1 Re: ESPN: 10 Most Disappointing Fantasy Seasons

Even worse than the top 10 is having two of the top ten sink your keeper league team int he same year: http://brotherskeeperfantasyfootball.blogspot.com/2011/06/looking-ahead-2011-cyborg-pirate-ninjas.html

2 Re: ESPN: 10 Most Disappointing Fantasy Seasons

Seriously, how in the world did you miss 2005 Daunte Culpepper? I'm serious!

He went from about 5,000 yards & 40 TDs in '04 to 1500 yards, 6 TDs and 12 INT in '05.

4 Re: ESPN: 10 Most Disappointing Fantasy Seasons

Because players who are out due to injury don't continue to burn you. You cut them and move on. Daunte would have failed in the loser league for this very reason. He'd be a penalty each week after the Carolina game.

You need the ones to, while sucking, continue to taunt you with promises of unfulfilled expectations down to the very end.

3 Re: ESPN: 10 Most Disappointing Fantasy Seasons

I assume players who missed over half the season with injuries were excluded from the list? 2005 Daunte Culpepper would have been a good candidate (6 touchdowns, 12 interceptions), but he got hurt in Week 7.

I'd add:

1986 Marcus Allen
1995 Andre Rison
1999 Randall Cunningham (benched after game 6, however)

Did people really have high expectations for Scott Mitchell? He started out well filling in for Marino in 1993, but peaked early, faded, then hurt his throwing shoulder.