Football Outsiders
Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis

2019 Football Outsiders Awards

Welcome to the 17th annual Football Outsiders Reader Awards balloting. Readers get to have their say in categories both conventional -- like MVP or Rookie of the Year -- and unconventional. We've got the "Keep Choppin' Wood" award for worst player of the year, awards for underrated and overrated players, and of course the "John Mellencamp Must Die" award for most annoying commercial.

As usual, we've made an executive decision not to include multiple players from the same team in any of the categories. We don't want to create a situation where any team has to split votes and thus a good candidate is denied the award.

This year, we've split the offensive MVP award into two categories. Analytics suggest strongly that no player at any other position can possibly be as valuable to his team as a quarterback. The league MVP award is primarily a quarterback award at this point, and based on analytics it should only be a quarterback award. So we've left the MVP voting to quarterbacks and we have a second category for offensive player of the year, non-QB.

Please refrain from writing things like "I don't know" or joke answers such as retired players. If you don't want to answer a question, leave it blank. Those joke answers make compiling the results take a lot of extra time and we would rather be doing something else.

If you enter two names in any of the open questions (other than offensive lineman, which asks for two names) we will not count your answer. We won't count answers for "any player on team X" or "any fullback" or some such thing.

Only ballots with at least half the questions answered will be counted in this year's awards.

Since we've been asked this question, we'll clarify: Please base your voting on the 2019 regular season only, not the playoffs.

Who is the 2019 NFL MVP?
Drew Brees, NO
Lamar Jackson, BAL
Patrick Mahomes, KC
Dak Prescott, DAL
Deshaun Watson, HOU
Russell Wilson, SEA
Who is the 2019 Offensive Player of the Year (non-QB)?
Ezekiel Elliott, RB, DAL
Chris Godwin, WR, TB
Travis Kelce, TE, KC
George Kittle, TE, SF
Christian McCaffrey, RB, CAR
Ronnie Stanley, OT, BAL
Michael Thomas, WR, NO
Darren Waller, TE, OAK
Who is the 2019 Defensive Player of the Year?
Shaquil Barrett, OLB, TB
Nick Bosa, DE, SF
Aaron Donald, DT, LAR
Stephon Gilmore, CB, NE
Cameron Jordan, DE, NO
Za'Darius Smith, OLB, GB
T.J. Watt, OLB, PIT
Tre'Davious White, CB, BUF
Who is the 2019 Offensive Rookie of the Year?
A.J. Brown, WR, TEN
Elgton Jenkins, G, GB
Josh Jacobs, RB, OAK
Erik McCoy, C, NO
Terry McLaurin, WR, WAS
DK Metcalf, WR, SEA
Kyler Murray, QB, ARI
Miles Sanders, RB, PHI
Who is the 2019 Defensive Rookie of the Year?
Josh Allen, DE, JAX
Nick Bosa, DE, SF
Brian Burns, OLB, CAR
Devin Bush, ILB, PIT
Darnell Savage, SS, GB
Devin White, ILB, TB
One name in each space, please. Do not pick defensive linemen; this category is for offensive linemen only. Thanks!
What is your choice for Unit of the Year in 2019?
Baltimore offensive line
Dallas offensive line
Green Bay offensive line
Kansas City wide receivers/tight ends
New England secondary
Pittsburgh defensive line/edge rushers
San Francisco defensive line/edge rushers
Tampa Bay wide receivers/tight ends
Who is 2019 NFL Head Coach of the Year?
Bill Belichick, NE
Brian Flores, MIA
Jim Harbaugh, BAL
Matt LaFleur, GB
Sean McDermott, BUF
Sean Payton, NO
Andy Reid, KC
Kyle Shanahan, SF
Mike Tomlin, PIT
Mike Vrabel, TEN
Who is 2019 Coordinator of the Year?
Todd Bowles, TB defense
Keith Butler, PIT defense
Kellen Moore, DAL offense
Greg Roman, BAL offense
Robert Saleh, SF defense
Arthur Smith, TEN offense
Who is 2019 Executive of the Year?
Brandon Beane, BUF
Bill Belichick, NE
Eric DeCosta, BAL
Brian Gutekunst, GB
John Lynch, SF
John Schneider, SEA
Rick Spielman, MIN
Brett Veach, KC
Who is your choice for the 2019 Keep Choppin' Wood Award (player who hurt his team most, on or off the field)?
Kalen Ballage, RB, MIA
Antonio Brown, WR, OAK/NE
Josh Gordon, WR, NE/SEA
Dwayne Haskins, QB, WAS
Trumaine Johnson, CB, NYJ
Xavier Rhodes, CB, MIN
Mitchell Trubisky, QB, CHI
Adam Vinatieri, K, IND
Who is your choice for the 2019 Keep Choppin' Game Film Award (most ineffective coach, head coach or coordinator)?
Adam Gase, NYJ head coach
Patrick Graham, MIA defensive coordinator
Freddie Kitchens, CLE head coach
Matt Patricia, DET head coach
Pat Shurmur, NYG head coach
Zac Taylor, CIN head coach
Who was the least deserving pick for the Pro Bowl (not including injury replacements)?
Mark Andrews, TE, BAL
Budda Baker, FS, ARI
Calais Campbell, DE, JAX
Frank Clark, DE, KC
David DeCastro, G, PIT
Jarvis Landry, WR, CLE
Aaron Rodgers, QB, GB
Darius Slay, CB, DET

Please note that votes in the next three categories can include players who are going to the Pro Bowl as either injury or Super Bowl roster replacements. Here is a link to the original Pro Bowl rosters that also marks which players were replacements and which players were on the original roster.

Some suggestions here: Kirk Cousins, Julian Edelman, Richie Incognito, Tyler Lockett, Erik McCoy, Dak Prescott, Mitchell Schwartz, Courtland Sutton, Darren Waller, or another player of your choice.
Some suggestions here: Josh Allen (Jaguars), Kenny Clark, Jamie Collins, Tremaine Edmunds, J.C. Jackson, Eric Kendricks, Jason McCourty, Za'Darius Smith, Marcus Williams (Saints), or another player of your choice.
Some suggestions here: Jamal Agnew (returns), Harrison Butker (kicker) , Nyheim Hines (returns), Tyler Matakvich (gunner), Steven Sims (returns), Derek Watt (gunner), Brandon Wilson (returns), or another player of your choice.
Note: Please don't pick a college player. A good rookie year is not a "breakout year." Also, please don't pick a player who missed most of 2019 due to injury but is already acknowledged as a star.
Please do not choose a player simply because he is likely to retire.
Which of the following teams is most likely next season's surprise Super Bowl contender?
Arizona
Atlanta
Carolina
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Denver
Detroit
Jacksonville
Las Vegas
Los Angeles Chargers
Miami
New York Giants
New York Jets
Tampa Bay
Washington
Which playoff team is most likely to miss the postseason in 2020?
Baltimore
Buffalo
Green Bay
Houston
Kansas City
Minnesota
New England
New Orleans
Philadelphia
San Francisco
Seattle
Tennessee
Which of these turnaround units is most likely to keep its improvement and fight off regression to the mean in 2020? (Listed with DVOA in 2018 and 2019)
Baltimore offense (15/1)
Dallas offense (24/2)
New England defense (16/1)
Oakland offense (25/9)
San Francisco offense (27/2)
San Francisco defense (23/2)
Tampa Bay defense (32/5)
Tennessee offense (22/6)
Which ad wins the "Get Your Story Straight" Award for best commercial or ad campaign during NFL games this season?
AT&T, Gordon Ramsey ("Use the cocktail stick!")
Head and Shoulders, "Mahomes vs. Polamalu"
KFC, "Rudy 2: He's Colonel Sanders now"
Madden NFL 20, "Superstar KO" (player loses Alvin Kamara to his best friend)
Progressive, "Progressive on Ice"
Samsung Galaxy, "Chewbacca Dog"
WWE Smackdown, "We're all superstars"
Which ad wins the "John Mellencamp Must Die" Award for worst commercial or ad campaign during NFL games this season?
Geico, "Jerome Bettis flag football"
H&R Block, "Money in minutes"
Microsoft Surface, "Mackenzie Book"
NFL.com, "Free phone football"
NFL Network, Thursday Night Rivalry series
NFL Shop, "The Champ is Here"
State Farm, Aaron Rodgers/Patrick Mahomes nightmare game
What was your favorite touchdown celebration of 2019?
DAL, Zeke Elliott doing "The Dak Dance"
IND, Quenton Nelson kegstand
NYJ, Ryan Griffin's sticky hands
SEA, boy band choreography
SF, Marquise Goodwin long jump