Four Downs: AFC South

Four Downs: AFC South
Four Downs: AFC South
Photo: USA Today Sports Images

by Ned Macey

Houston Texans

Biggest Hole: Outside linebacker

The Texans' primary problem last season was on defense, and their run defense was particularly weak, 30th in the NFL in Football Outsiders' advanced DVOA ratings. The Texans have spent a great deal of money on their defensive line, including the addition this offseason of free agent defensive end Antonio Smith. But what about the next line of defense?

Two years ago, the Texans drafted DeMeco Ryans, who is a solid middle linebacker. Their two outside linebacker positions, however, are extreme problems. They released veteran Morlon Greenwood, who had been the starter since 2005 before losing his job this season. On the current roster are Kevin Bentley, Xavier Adibi, and Zac Diles.

Adibi was a fourth-round pick last season and is a talented player who should be left alone as the weakside linebacker. Diles, a seventh-round pick in 2007, started the first half of last season before going down with a fractured tibia. Bentley is best left in a reserve role.

Texans rarely gave up big runs but were consistently gashed for positive gains, and a stout, run-stuffing linebacker is desperately needed. The veteran free agent market is not too promising, leaving mostly players who played in the Tampa-2 style, ranging from future Hall of Famer Derrick Brooks to part-time Colts starter Tyjuan Hagler. In the draft, the Texans would love for Brian Cushing of USC to fall to them. Cushing has ideal size and speed to pay strongside linebacker. If Cushing is gone, the Texans could take his teammate Clay Matthews, who is riskier because his technique is less developed and he may be better suited for a 3-4 defense.

Free Agency Recap

As noted above, the Texans made one big move this offseason to improve their woeful defense: They signed Antonio Smith away from the Cardinals to play defensive end. Smith played well in the playoffs, which may have raised his price. Still, he is a good player who will provide pass rush from the opposite side of Mario Williams. Anthony Weaver played out of position at defensive end and recorded zero sacks last season.

The only other free agent Houston signed was Dan Orlovsky, hoping to someday be known for more than running out of his own end zone by accident. Orlovsky is actually an interesting signing. He had a league average DVOA that was substantially better than teammates Jon Kitna (-19.9%) or Daunte Culpepper (-32.0%). Matt Schaub has yet to stay healthy as a starter, so Orlovsky could get a chance to get on the field. The space was available because the Texans shipped the erratic Sage Rosenfels to Minnesota for a fourth-round pick.

The Texans are hoping to get younger with the release of Weaver, Greenwood, and Ahman Green. The exception to the veteran exodus was safety Nick Ferguson. The ten-year veteran re-signed and is expected to start at this point.

Indianapolis Colts

Biggest Hole: Defensive tackle

The Colts are set with Dwight Freeney and Robert Mathis at the ends, but they have had a revolving door at defensive tackle. Through a combination of injuries and (in one case) off-the-field issues, the Colts have gone through Montae Reagor, Booger McFarland, Raheem Brock, Keyunta Dawson, Ed Johnson, and Eric Foster as starting defensive tackles over the past three seasons.

In 2007, McFarland was injured, and the Colts unearthed an undrafted free agent rookie in Ed Johnson to pair with Brock. With Johnson and fellow second-year player Keyunta Dawson, the Colts thought they had a talented tandem going forward. After Week 1 of 2008, however, Johnson was arrested for marijuana possession and subsequently released by the Colts. To replace Johnson, the Colts called on this year's undrafted rookie, Foster.

Foster played admirably for a player of his size and pedigree, but the man weighs only 265 pounds. The Colts' overall run defense was adequate, but according to Football Outsiders' defensive line stats, they ranked 27th against runs up the middle and 30th in power situations.

The Colts do not believe in free agency, so they will have to look to the draft for a solution. In the past, the Colts have been reluctant to invest draft picks on defensive tackles. Dawson and Quinn Pitcock, a 2007 third-round selection who suddenly quit after his rookie season, are the only defensive tackles drafted by the Colts since 2003. However, the Colts are likely to emphasize run defense more under new defensive coordinator Larry Coyer. They will retain the Tampa-2 system, but the Colts may not be so averse to a defensive tackle who takes up space.

The dream scenario would be if Peria Jerry of Mississippi fell to them. Jerry has the quickness to be an ideal Tampa-2 defensive tackle, but he is much bigger than Foster. If Jerry is gone, the Colts would have to settle for Evander Hood, who lacks the quickness they would prefer at the position. In that case, the Colts might consider waiting for the second round to grab someone like Auburn's Sen'Derrick Marks.

Free Agency Recap

The easiest job at Football Outsiders is writing the Colts' free agent recap. In an annual ritual, the Colts have signed no free agents of note and have let athletic but undersized linebackers (this year Freddie Keiaho and Tyjuan Hagler) reach the market. The Colts did re-sign the talented and still improving cornerback Kevin Hayden, and a late increase in the salary cap allowed them to keep center Jeff Saturday.

Marvin Harrison was released, as expected. Harrison is obviously no longer the player he was and may not be even a league-average receiver. The Colts will be fine with Anthony Gonzalez as the starter but now need a third receiver to replace Gonzalez.

Jacksonville Jaguars

Biggest Hole: Cornerback

The Jaguars' offensive decline last season was much noticed due to the shocking number of injuries to the offensive line. The team's bigger problem, however, was on defense, where they had the second-worst passing defense in football according to DVOA.

The Jaguars have only a decent pass rush, but their coverage was abysmal. Top cornerback Rashean Mathis is overrated by some but is certainly not the problem. Drayton Florence was a disaster and was eventually demoted to the nickel, with Brian Williams moving back from safety into a starting cornerback spot. Florence was released, leaving Mathis, Williams, and veterans Scott Starks and William James.

If Williams is returned to safety, as he should be, the Jaguars have a serious shortage. James and Starks should only be providing depth at this point in their careers. The Jaguars need to strengthen the position with a long-term investment and a first- or second-round pick. Mathis will be 29 years old before the season starts, and the Jaguars will likely want him to be their second cornerback in the coming years. The only cornerback worthy of a top-ten pick is Malcolm Jenkins, who unfortunately may be more of a safety. His skills seem similar to Reggie Nelson, the Jaguars' current starting free safety.

The Jaguars could try and trade down for Vontae Davis of Illinois, who has outstanding physical skills. Trading out of the top ten is difficult, and the Jaguars are likely going to have to take Jenkins or wait until the second round for a cornerback. Perhaps the availability of Mark Sanchez can get a team to take the plunge and make a trade with the Jaguars. Certainly, Jacksonville is one team where quarterback is not a hole on the roster.

Free Agency Recap

After a disappointing season, the Jaguars were not hesitant to say goodbye to a number of veterans on their team. They cut long-time stalwarts Fred Taylor and Mike Peterson. Last year's foray into free agency netted Florence and Joey Porter. A year later, both were released. Safety Gerald Sensabaugh signed with the Cowboys (and has been replaced by former Eagle Sean Considine). Underachieving wide receivers Reggie Williams and Matt Jones both will likely play for new teams next year (Jones team potentially being in the California Penal League).

Most of these departures were players past their peak or who never developed. The most interesting move made by the Jaguars was the decision not to re-sign left tackle Khalif Barnes and to replace him with long-time Eagles'tackle Tra Thomas. Over the past five seasons, Thomas has certainly been a better player than the inconsistent Barnes. Still, Barnes has flashed potential and will only be 27 years old next season. Thomas, meanwhile, turns 35 during the season and is obviously on the downside of his career.

The addition of Thomas runs contrary to the wave of veterans that left and is an odd move. Basically, Thomas may give the Jaguars one or two good seasons. That's even in doubt, as Thomas is shifting from a pass-happy scheme to a run-heavy offense.

Tennessee Titans

Biggest Hole: Wide receiver

The Titans released Derrick Mason in a cap savings move following the 2004 season. Mason had just posted his fourth straight 1,000-yard season, and since moving to Baltimore, he has three 1,000-yard seasons in four years. Mason ranked in the top 20 in Football Outsiders' DYAR stats every season from 2000 through 2004. Since he left, the Titans have had only one wide receiver ranked in the top 40 in DYAR, Justin Gage in 2007.

Following Mason's departure, the most yards gained in a season by a Tennessee receiver are the 750 gained by Gage in 2007. This past season, Gage led the team with 651 yards, while Brandon Jones had the most receptions by a receiver with 41. The two players with the most receptions were tight end Bo Scaife and running back Chris Johnson. Quite simply, the Titans cannot have an explosive offense with such limited playmakers.

The Titans' big foray into the free agent market was to sign the Steelers' third receiver, Nate Washington. Washington has big-play ability, but he has never caught more than 40 balls in a season. Short of bringing in one of the two past-his-prime Pro Bowlers, Marvin Harrison or Torry Holt, the free agent market is thin.

The Titans, with a good defense, good offensive line, and good running backs, simply have to draft a wide receiver in one of the first two rounds. It is hard to project what receivers will be available late in the first round. Of the prospects around that area, perhaps the best fit is Brian Robiskie from Ohio State. Washington and Gage can both make plays down the field, leaving room underneath for Robiskie to develop into a valuable possession receiver.

Free Agency Recap

Since Tennessee blew up the Steve McNair Titans following the 2004 season, they have been raiding other teams in free agency while mostly keeping their own players. Now, however, the Titans are again a very good team, and their players are suddenly desired.

The big name is obviously Albert Haynesworth. The best free agent on the market, he simply got more money from Washington than the Titans were willing to pay. Haynesworth was the Titans' best player, but the defense will remain strong without him. Internally, Jason Jones played well backing up Haynesworth. Also, the Titans added Jovan Haye from Tampa Bay. Haye, still in his prime at age 26, was a great signing at $4 million per season.

While Haynesworth is the big name, he was not the only Titans player to leave. Solid but unspectacular receiver Brandon Jones was signed by the 49ers. Nickel cornerback Chris Carr was signed by the Ravens. Cornerback Eric King followed defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz to Detroit. Third quarterback Chris Simms was signed by the Broncos.

Cornerbacks Reynaldo Hill and Tyrone Poole remain free agents. With the age of starter Nick Harper, the Titans will likely need to hit the leftover free agents or draft heavily to get depth in their secondary.


27 comments, Last at 05 Apr 2009, 1:07am

#1 by Mountain Time … // Mar 27, 2009 - 2:04pm

I could see the Colts drafting Brian Robiskie from Ohio State in the first round, if he's available.

Points: 0

#2 by Thomas_beardown // Mar 27, 2009 - 2:17pm

Most people have him as a 2nd round pick, so I think he should be available to the Colts.

Points: 0

#8 by shake n bake // Mar 27, 2009 - 7:46pm

I really like Robiskie and would LOVE him in the 2nd round, but I don't think he'd be the pick unless things really didn't break Indy's way. Their strategy for first round picks seems to be BPA at a need position. They will take the best available DT/OT/WR (maybe LB/CB) in the first round. I would put Robiskie behind Jerry, Ziggy Hood, Britton, Beatty, Nicks, Britt and Laurinatis among the guys that have a decent chance of being there at #27.

Robsikie is the 2nd round pick in my optimistic, but not totally out of touch with reality Colts draft (with Jerry in the first).

Points: 0

#3 by Kenneth (not verified) // Mar 27, 2009 - 2:47pm

Last year's foray into free agency netted Florence and Joey Porter

Certainly you mean Jerry Porter?

Points: 0

#10 by Bobman // Mar 27, 2009 - 11:41pm

I pity the fool who disrespects Joey Porter!

(and pity the team that employs Jerry....)

Points: 0

#4 by Key19 // Mar 27, 2009 - 3:41pm

I would love to see Keyunta Dawson get another shot as a starter this season. Not saying the Colts can't or shouldn't draft a DT, but I'm just saying I'd like to see him start at one of their two DT spots.

Points: 0

#9 by shake n bake // Mar 27, 2009 - 7:51pm

Dawson will be at the very least rotating in at the undertackle spot. If they get a DT in the draft then Dawson will probably split time with Eric Foster at the undertackle, with Brock finally getting out to DE where the Colts wanted him to take run downs for Mathis and spell Freeney.

Points: 0

#5 by Chris (not verified) // Mar 27, 2009 - 4:57pm

Isn't it Kelvin Hayden? The Jags picked up Joey Porter or Jerry Porter? It seems like every article has errors, does anybody proof read them ?

Points: 0

#15 by the silent speaker (not verified) // Mar 28, 2009 - 9:20pm

It seems like every article has errors, does anybody proof read them ?

This is a run-on sentence. You needed a semicolon (;) after "errors". Also, "proofread" is one word, not two.

Points: 0

#6 by rk (not verified) // Mar 27, 2009 - 5:07pm

Houston signed Shaun Cody, and Indianapolis signed Adam Seward.

Points: 0

#7 by Bryan Cook (not verified) // Mar 27, 2009 - 6:21pm

While every season the Titans are basically ORDERED by the analysts to draft a WR in the first round, they obviously never do it. In fact, earlier this week out of curiosity, I looked at Tennessee's draft choices from the last five years. Using the traditional draft pick value chart, the Titans would be using more draft value on a WR with their 1st round pick (#30) than they have used on EVERY WR DRAFTED IN THE PAST FIVE YEARS COMBINED.
Granted, the traditional value chart overvalues early picks and all, but I still don't see a Titans team risking a first-round pick on a wideout in a year where they were 13-3 in the previous season. As hard as the fans in Nashville beg them to commit and actually get a true #1 WR, they're obviously content with the way their offense has been mediocre for the past few years, which works in the regular season but gets them NOWHERE in the playoffs.
Most likely, they'll go for a LB or DE. Who am I kidding? They'll probably just draft another RB for no good reason. The Titans draft frustrates me every year.

Points: 0

#11 by Key19 // Mar 27, 2009 - 11:45pm

Personally, I'd rather have Chris Johnson than any WR from last year's draft. I really like Eddie Royal, but still...

Definitely would take Johnson over D-Jack (DeSean, not Darrell in case anyone thought that), Avery, Sweed, etc.

That said, I think not taking a WR in the top 2 rounds this year would be an error on their part. However, it wouldn't surprise me if they pull an Eagles and draft someone the fanbase is outraged about.

Points: 0

#17 by AlanSP // Mar 29, 2009 - 1:44am

Are you seriously complaining about drafting Michael Griffin and Chris Johnson? Those are two very valuable players who contributed a lot to the Titans' performance this year. Yes, Dwayne Bowe was available in 2007, but there's no way of knowing where he was on the Titans' draft board. For all we know, if they had taken a receiver, they might have gone with Robert Meachem or Dwayne Jarrett. Last year, everyone thought they were going to pick Devin Thomas and they went with Johnson instead. You're unhappy with how that worked out?

And yes, star running backs do in fact contribute to the offense. Johnson happened to get hurt in the playoff game. Stuff like that happens.

Points: 0

#20 by Chris UK (not verified) // Mar 30, 2009 - 3:17am

As a fantasy player who picked up Chris Johnson, I am puzzled as to why anyone would think they draft RBs for no good reason.

Points: 0

#12 by Bobman // Mar 27, 2009 - 11:46pm

California Penal League--excellent "Major League" reference now that we're heading into baseball season, and all too true.

Points: 0

#13 by Jason // Mar 28, 2009 - 5:45am

The Colts also have Antonio "Mookie" Johnson at DT, who they signed from the Titans practice squad last year. I really hate that he got away, but I was glad to see him get an opportunity with the Colts.

If I hit a grand slam on this hole-in-one the dominoes will fall like a house of cards. Checkmate.

Points: 0

#14 by shake n bake // Mar 28, 2009 - 1:03pm

Mookie is the reason the Colts can afford to pass on a DT if there's more value at their early picks. He let them get a lineup in where the DTs weren't both smaller than Freeney.

Points: 0

#16 by Purds // Mar 28, 2009 - 11:36pm

So, where the heck is Ed Johnson these days? I know the Colts cut him, and that he had a history in college, but he was a pretty effective DT for them for about a year. I can't understand why he hasn't resurfaced somewhere. This is the NFL, where guys get 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th ... shots. Why hasn't someone picked up Ed Johnson?

Points: 0

#18 by shake n bake // Mar 29, 2009 - 1:58pm

Joe Paterno had to call the Colts and personally vouch for Ed just to get him into a training camp. Apparently getting kicked off you college team counts as one of you NFL shots. Ed Johnson got (I believe) 3.

Points: 0

#25 by Bobman // Mar 31, 2009 - 6:02pm

I have wondered this for MONTHS. Even with a 4-week suspension hanging over him, you sign him for league minimum and see what he has. If he looks like a keeper, you wait the month. If not, you toss him aside. I thought he was very promising in the Colts system and his crimes are moderate compared to some others. It sounds as if he's had literally NO ACTION at all, and for a decent NFL caliber player, that's a bit odd. Then again, I know nothing of his previous offenses (college) and so maybe the NFL knows and dislikes his background a lot more than I.

After all, it's not like he broke into some girl's dorm room to pinch a loaf in her closet.... now THAT's really foul. A guy like that could NEVER play for the Colts.

Points: 0

#23 by Tom Gower // Mar 30, 2009 - 11:11am

I think I read something about him potentially facing a 4-game suspension, which would be a very good reason another team hasn't given him another shot.

Points: 0

#19 by td (not verified) // Mar 30, 2009 - 1:01am

khalif barnes is the guy who got pulled over doing 100+ on a highway in jax and started ranted about the 'kkk devils' profiling him. the jags actually have probably more arrests from the team than the bengals have had since they drafted chris henry. barnes was a solid tackle before last season, but last year he was terrible. the thomas signing makes it look like they dont know what they're doing.

Points: 0

#21 by Theo // Mar 30, 2009 - 8:32am

It makes sense for the Colts not to invest much in defensive tackles.
With Peyton Manning and his effective offense, cover 2 is the best option. Your biggest concern is to stop deep passes or quick scores to prevent potential comebacks by the other team.
All you need is 2 safeties, an edge rusher and diciplined linebackers.
Tackles are only needed to fill up a gap, so every penny spent to much on a tackle was better spent on a safety, an end or something on offense.

Points: 0

#26 by Bobman // Mar 31, 2009 - 6:12pm

As a Colt fan I beg to differ--we'd welcome a few quick strikes against us--that just gets Manning back on the field sooner. 5,000 yards and 52 TDs, here we come.

The thing that kills us is when a team holds the ball for 11 minutes on an 18-play drive. That forces our (and the league's IMO) best player to be an observer. If you look over the drive stats for the past few years, you will see that Manning has had the fewest drives of any 16 game starter by a long shot, because other teams bleed the clock.

The Colts want the other guys to throw--which is why they have Freeney/Mathis, some high-draft pick CBs, and a few punishing safeties. Their whole game plan is predicated on that scenario--Manning racks up a 14 point lead, other team has to pass, armageddon ensues. When the O stumbles a bit, it all unravels because it exposes the D's weakest aspect, and when the other guys run, it limits the O's chances to do their thing.

Points: 0

#27 by Monkey Business (not verified) // Apr 05, 2009 - 1:07am

The ideal Colts game plan reads like this:
- Establish lead.
- Force other team to abandon the run and throw.
- Inflict punishment in the form of sacks, interceptions, forced fumbles, and bone-crushing hits.

The problem is that opposing teams can run straight at the defense, play after play after play, and can effectively take the Indy offense out of the game. It's what happens when you have the best QB in football. He gets paid to put up points, and spend a lot of time holding a clipboard.

Points: 0

#22 by lobolafcadio // Mar 30, 2009 - 9:41am

Barnes was becoming a revolving door at left tackle and simply not worth the trouble.
The signing of Thomas allow the Jaguars to pick who they want at 8th and even to trade out of this spot regardless of position.
Thomas is a true stop-gap signing.
Don't forget Barnes was nearly losing his starting spot to Collier last fall before Collier was shot.
I truely hope the Broncos or the niners trade up with the jags to pick say a 3-4 OLB before the packers and allow the jags to pick twice this year in the secound round or twice in the first round next year.

Points: 0

#24 by td (not verified) // Mar 31, 2009 - 1:09am

Collier's shooting- uggh, what a terrible year

Points: 0

Save 10%
& Support the Writers
Support Football Outsiders' independent media. Use promo code WRITERS to save 10% on any FO+ membership and give half the cost of your membership to tip the team of writers.