Getting More from Christian McCaffrey and Davante Adams

Carolina Panthers RB Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers RB Christian McCaffrey
Photo: USA Today Sports Images

NFL Week 4 - Christian McCaffrey has 50 carries this season. Of those carries, 29 have gone between the tackles.

Great work, Ben McAdoo and Matt Rhule! When we think of McCaffrey, all of us automatically think, "traditional between-the-tackles punch press." The Carolina Panthers offense is sure to be optimized by McCaffrey plunging into the line on 60% of his rushes!

Walkthrough has been attracting lots of new readers these days, so let's clarify: that's sarcasm.

McCaffrey, who missed practice this week with a quad injury, is second in the NFL in carries marked as "left inside," "middle," or "right inside" by Sports Info Solutions. Jonathan Taylor leads the NFL with 37 such rushes. Taylor has 61 total carries, so he is plunging into the line on 60.6% of his rushes, often inside zone concepts.

Taylor weighs 20 more pounds than McCaffrey. Also, the Indianapolis Colts offense is—let's be nice—still ironing out the kinks entering Week 4. It's not a model of efficiency right now.

McCaffrey is averaging 5.4 yards per rush between the tackles, but that's because of one 49-yard run against the Giants. Take it away and his average drops to 3.9; still not terrible, but there are better ways to get 3.9 yards than exposing CMC to 10 wallops up the middle per game.

Meanwhile, McCaffery has run to the outside just five times this season. Because, hey, he's not the type of elusive playmaker who operates well in space. (Also sarcasm.)

Nick Chubb leads all running backs with 23 carries to the outside. Derrick Henry—DERRICK HENRY—is second among non-quarterbacks with 21. McCaffrey has as many outside runs as Tyler Allgeier, Justice Hill, Joshua Kelly, and, er, Mac Jones.

Folks, McAdoo and Rhule may not know how to use Christian McCaffrey properly.

What about the passing game, you say? McCaffrey has just 10 receptions on 14 targets for 57 yards, but perhaps McArhule have whipped up all sorts of devilry for their dual-threat running back that just hasn't quite paid off yet. For example, CMC is getting lots of work from the slot, right?

Nope. McCaffrey has two catches for 10 yards on two targets from the slot. Based on my rewatch of the Saints game, he did not line up in the slot once in Week 3.

Are the Panthers splitting him wide? Nope. Zero targets. No snaps that I saw.

They must be using motion, sliding McCaffrey all over the formation to get him mismatched against linebackers, right? Nope: one target when in motion, for a loss of 5.

Well, surely they are giving McCaffrey chances to operate down the field! Nope: one target of 5 or more air yards, incomplete.

McCaffrey has caught five screen passes on five targets. Three targets and one catch (that 5-yard loss) came on "swing" passes in the Sports Info Solutions database. Three targets and two catches came in the flats. You get the idea; the McCaffrey passing game is downright rudimentary.

McCaffrey's simplistic, suboptimal usage pattern is almost certainly McAdoo's doing; Rhule and his past coordinators had creative plans for McCaffrey when he was available to them. It's also almost comically silly. Think about it. Baker Mayfield had a truncated offseason. He doesn't have a full handle on the playbook or well-tuned timing with his receivers, and it shows. So how would you manufacture offense in those situations? Emphasizing CMC, of course. And how would you do so? Probably by motioning McCaffrey all over the formation, tossing him the ball on quick sweeps, having him run option routes from the slots, and basically telling Baker, "Just find Christian and dump it off to him."

If all you have seen of the Panthers are the highlights, you may not realize how weak their offense is: 25th in DVOA, 31st in the first quarter. Their DVOA rises to second in the fourth quarter, but that's largely because their three biggest plays—McCaffrey's 49-yard run, a Mayfield bomb to Robbie Anderson, Laviska Shenualt's catch-and-run to ice the Saints win—are all lumped in a small fourth-quarter sample. The Panthers have a bad offense masked by the fact that they have played some opponents whose offenses are just as bad or worse.

Fantasy gamers may not care very much how McCaffrey gets the ball as long as he gets it a lot. But c'mon: this isn't how he's supposed to be used, and it may already be taking its toll on a 205-pound all-purpose guy with a long injury history. And if the Panthers can't move the ball more consistently, there will be lots of 15-for-50 rushing, 5-for-30 receiving afternoons in McCaffrey's future. If he manages to stay on the field.

McCaffrey should be part of the solution. But if McAdoo and Rhule keep treating him like a fullback, it'll be a problem for both the Panthers and folks who made McCaffrey RB1 in fantasy.

The Davante Adams Riddle

Davante Adams has caught just seven passes for 48 yards in his last two games after going 10-141-1 in the season opener. Las Vegas fans have noticed. The Raiders faction of my Twitter timeline is full of musings like, "Why isn't Derek Carr throwing to Adams?"; "Why isn't Josh McDaniels featuring Adams?"; and "We're Raiders fans, shouldn't we be used to this sort of thing by now?"

Walkthrough does not have answers to any of those questions. But we do have data. Adams ranks 51st in DYAR right now; his -1 DYAR indicates that he's producing like a replacement-level receiver. His 50% catch rate—17 catches on 34 targets—is tied with CeeDee Lamb for the second-worst rate among receivers with 20-plus targets. Only Brandin Cooks is below them.

Adams' average depth of catch (per Sports Info Solutions, the source for all non-FO stats) is just 6.6 yards, 29th in the NFL. A low depth-of-catch figure can indicate a dink-and-dunk target, or it can illustrate a team's "feed the superstar the ball" strategy. Cooper Kupp's depth of catch is currently 5.8 yards; Ja'Marr Chase is at 5.9 (not including last night's game against Miami). The Rams and Bengals are feeding Kupp and Chase the ball on shorter routes to get their offenses moving. The difference is that Kupp and Chase are catching 80% and 60% of their targets to Adams' 50%. Also, no one should be holding the Bengals offense up as an exemplar of anything through three games.

Sports Info Solutions also has a little metric called On-Target Catch Rate, which measures the number of catchable passes that the receiver caught. Adams' rate is 100%: no drops, no contested catches that went the other way. If Carr gets the ball anywhere near him, Adams catches it.

Carr just isn't throwing the ball to Adams, however, as this breakdown illustrates. And when he does throw it, the pass is often off-target: friend-of-Walkthrough Doug Farrar noted on Twitter that Carr is just 1-of-6 when targeting Adams 20-plus yards downfield.

This is a good time to take a deep breath and restack the situation. Carr-to-Adams worked great in Week 1. They're BFFs. Carr was an effective deep passer last year to guys such as Zay Jones. Adams is getting open, getting featured in the offense (10 targets last week) and getting the ball in the red zone (one touchdown per week). Adams' production will almost certainly snap back. Walkthrough isn't recommending any Week 4 Adams props because: a) the Broncos rank third in the NFL at stopping No. 1 wide receivers; and b) there weren't many posted yet at our favorite sites at press time. But we're still bullish on Adams moving forward.

We're also bullish on the Raiders snapping back on offense once McDaniels, Carr, Adams, Darren Waller, and Hunter Renfrow find the same page. The problem right now is that the sportsbooks agree: the Raiders were 2.5-point favorites against the Broncos at press time.

We're not touching that "which scuffling offense figures things out first?" action. But eventually, both scuffling offenses are likely to get better.

A Walkthrough Paid Advertisement

Do you, yes YOU, need a left tackle? Then come right down to Howie Wowie's House of Dillard, located just minutes from the Walt Whitman Bridge! We have certified, pre-owned left tackles in our showroom RIGHT NOW. Hold on, there's the phone!

(on phone) Hey Joe! Sorry to hear that. You need a Dillard? We've got one left! So you had better hurry down the turnpike with your checkbook and a second-round pick! Yes, I said second.

He hung up. But he'll call back. That's right folks: Howie Wowie's House of Dillard has everything you need to stave off a left tackle emergency: a former first-round pick with starting experience who wasn't half bad in 2021. And he comes with Howie's Regret-Free Guarantee, void in Indiana and 22 other states. Hold on, another call.

(on phone) Tommy Telesco? Great to hear from you. Storm WHO? Oh buddy, you need to fly out here right away. We've only got one left, and Joe Douglas is on his way down the turnpike with a second-round pick. Yep, I said second. But listen, I like you, so if you offer a second and fourth right now we'll call it a deal. Think about it. Ta-ta, TT.

The wheeling and dealing here at Howie Wowie's never stops. And there's more in our showroom than just left tackles. Stop by the showroom and … oh, I absolutely MUST take this call.

(on phone) Hello Mickey! Why, I DO happen to have a preowned Gardner Minshew. You're just in time, too: John Lynch called me this morning! Just let me run your credit rating…

Jameis Winston's First-Half Blues

Here are Jameis Winston's passing breakdowns by quarter through three games:

Jameis Winston by Quarter, 2022
Qtr Att Comp Yards YPA TD INT Sack DYAR DVOA
First 18 10 65 3.4 0 0 1 -54 -53.3%
Second 28 17 144 5.1 0 0 5 -114 -63.0%
Third 21 13 118 5.6 0 0 2 1 -10.1%
Fourth/OT 48 33 534 11.1 4 5 3 177 45.0%

The Saints offense goes from 26th to 30th to 26th to third in DVOA from the first quarter to the fourth. Much of Winston's fourth-quarter production comes on a remarkable 11 passing plays of 20-plus yards. But as always there are interceptions to consider—one of them a Hail Mary, but the others comeback killers.

Walkthrough has no idea what to make of this, except that it further confirms our Theoretical Jameis hypothesis: Winston's reputation as a still-viable starter comes from cutting and pasting together the times when he looks like a true franchise quarterback and hand-waving away the other 75% of his playing time.

None of this may matter on Sunday morning against the Vikings. Winston did not practice on Wednesday or Thursday. Both Winston and Dennis Allen downplayed the situation, but Allen also made sure Taysom Hill got some snaps behind Andy Dalton. Remember when Taysom Hill wasn't going to play quarterback anymore? LOL. Any-who, Michael Thomas didn't practice on Wednesday or Thursday either. It's safe to assume that the Saints offense isn't going to suddenly get better this week.

Walkthrough grabbed Vikings (-3) while Winston's status was still cloudy. We don't expect the line to move too much when Taysom is announced as the starter. Dalton! We mean Dalton. Taysom's just gonna get about half the snaps.

The Zach Wilson Attack is Back!

Are you excited for Zach Wilson's return to the New York Jets huddle? No? Had you forgotten all about Zach Wilson? That's OK. He's rather forgettable.

Wilson had some loose 'n' lumpy rookie performances at the start of the 2021 season. He then suffered a PCL injury. Mike White, Josh Johnson, and Joe Flacco replaced Wilson for four games, and it was quite a lifetime's journey of a month: the New York tabloids were so ginned up for a Wilson-White controversy that they needed cold showers after White's four-interception meltdown against the Bills.

Wilson returned for the final seven games of the season, and neither Robert Saleh nor Mike LaFleur had the stomach for any more excitement. LaFleur relaunched his offense in tutorial mode, and from Week 12 on, Wilson ranked:

  • 30th among all starting quarterbacks in completion rate at 54.0% (minimum 100 attempts; Baker Mayfield and Mike Glennon were below him).
  • 29th in yards per attempt at 5.8 (Ben Roethlisberger, Sam Darnold, Glennon).
  • 31st in sack rate at 10.5% (Darnold).
  • 32nd (last) in average throw depth at 6.3 yards per attempt.

You get the picture.

Wilson threw an interception on the fifth play of the Jets preseason. He tore a meniscus in his right knee when scrambling a little too thirstily on the very next drive. That brings us to now. Wilson returns to replace Flacco, who ranks a very Flacco-esque 25th in DVOA and DYAR and scratched out a comeback against the Browns.

The tabloids are taking their little purple pills in anticipation of a very, very sad little controversy if Wilson stumbles. And sometimes, the tabloids speak to us the way the point spread speaks to us. Wilson has produced almost nothing but poor play and injuries. Yes, it's still very early in his career, but it's not hard to smell instant dissatisfaction in the wind, especially in Jets country, where controversies often turn into self-fulfilling prophecies. And Saleh is on record: he reads the papers. A coach who "keeps receipts" is a coach who can get swept up in a drama.

Wilson will be short three left tackles for the foreseeable future: George Fant joined Duane Brown and Mekhi Becton on the IR. That leaves longtime backup Connor McDermott on the left side, with Connor McGovern on the right side, because the Jets love filling their roster with duplicates. The left tackle crisis will make the Jets offense even more conservative, which will play against Wilson's theoretical strength as a deep passer. Jets quarterback situations are rarely fair, but they are always Jets quarterback situations.

Walkthrough wants to buy into the "Jets have improved" conversation. So far, all we have seen are some scattered big plays against the Browns and lots of soup mix. We also want to root for Wilson, but we weren't that impressed with him at BYU, and the best thing for the Jets might be a quick resolution if he's just headed down the Darnold path.

Trevor Lawrence's Sideline Itch

One reason why Trevor Lawrence is off to such an impressive start is the fact that he is doing an exceptional job completing passes along the sidelines. Lawrence has completed a league-high 80% of his 23 passes marked "left" or "right" (outside the numbers, essentially) of 5 to 15 yards in air length in the Sports Info Solutions database.

Yes, that's a rather custom-finagled stat. It's tricky to tease this data to illustrate a point without Cooper Rush or somebody sample-sizing his way into the conversation. So let's come at this another way. On "out" routes in the SIS database, Lawrence is 16-of-18 for 127 yards. Only Kyler Murray has more completions and yards. Lawrence has other sideline completions listed as comebacks or curls. He has also gotten some production from short swing passes, but much of his sideline production comes on intermediate routes.

Lawrence's success along the short-to-intermediate sidelines forces opponents to defend the whole field. Some offenses get surprisingly little out of these segments of the field: 49ers quarterbacks completed just 30 passes in this range last year, and the Bears, Packers, 49ers, Rams, and Dolphins have all attempted 10 passes or less along the short-to-intermediate sidelines. Sideline passing efficiency isn't a must, but it's a delicious part of a well-nourished offense.

The Eagles appear well-suited to stop Lawrence from picking them apart at the edges because: a) Darius Slay and James Bradberry are playing well; and b) there are some defensive holdovers (such as Slay) from the Doug Pederson era. The Jaguars offense currently looks a lot like the Playoff Foles offense, complete with a smattering of RPO. The Eagles should be ready for that.

There may also be a little helium in the Jaguars' balloon after a Week 3 blowout which was fueled in large part by a pair of early turnovers deep in Chargers territory. The house isn't nibbling on the Jaguars just yet: they're +6.5 at Philly, which is way too close to our FO+ picks to play.

That said, Lawrence is certainly trending in the right direction, all of those crisp passes to the sideline are a very encouraging sign, and we expect the Jaguars to be a tough out all year long.


22 comments, Last at 03 Oct 2022, 11:54am

#1 by Badfinger // Sep 30, 2022 - 10:13am

Had you forgotten all about Zach Wilson?

 Never! How dare you!!

Points: 0

#8 by Badfinger // Sep 30, 2022 - 3:41pm

It turns out I was actually thinking about Mike White. We apologize with regret for this error.

Points: 0

#2 by Travis // Sep 30, 2022 - 10:15am

That leaves longtime backup Connor McDermott on the left side, with Connor McGovern on the right side, because the Jets love filling their roster with duplicates.

Connor McGovern (not to be confused with the Cowboys guard of the same name) is the Jets' center; 4th-round rookie Max Mitchell starts at right tackle.

Points: 0

#3 by Pat // Sep 30, 2022 - 10:33am

Do you, yes YOU, need a left tackle? Then come right down to Howie Wowie's House of Dillard, located just minutes from the Walt Whitman Bridge!

Damnit, Mike, don't give Howie any ideas! Almost through Dillard's IR period without needing a backup tackle, and you're friggin jinxing it.

Philly went super-light at tackle on the active roster with Dillard on IR and the guys they tried to stash on the practice squad keep getting pilfered (two tackles have been snatched off the Eagles practice squad so far, plus a guard). If Mailata gets hurt, I'm not even sure who they'd put there. No one else on the roster's actually played left tackle.

I don't think Dillard moves this year. It's not worth the risk.

Points: 0

#5 by serutan // Sep 30, 2022 - 3:18pm

  When  I read that section of the article I thought "Only an Eagles fan could come up with something like that when the team is playing so well."

Points: 0

#6 by horn // Sep 30, 2022 - 3:20pm

Agreed unless you like the idea of, say....Jack Driscoll at LT?

I sure don't. Keep Dillard. 1st round pick and I'll listen.

Points: 0

#9 by Pat // Sep 30, 2022 - 3:48pm

Probably actually Sills. Driscoll's basically a backup RG/RT, Sills is a backup LG/LT. That's where they were in preseason.

It's not like this makes me more comfortable, though! I mean, I'll trust Stout to the ends of the earth, but man am I crossing my fingers until Dillard's back off IR.

Points: 0

#10 by Aaron Brooks G… // Sep 30, 2022 - 5:06pm

Agreed unless you like the idea of, say....Jack Driscoll at LT?

Maybe? I mean Jack Driscoll sure that gave that big monkey what-for up in NYC.

Points: 0

#20 by Pat // Oct 02, 2022 - 1:27pm


!*^(!^!&(#^@*$$*^$#(^$%($!! Soooo freaking close!

aside: apparently it was Driscoll as backup LT.

Points: 0

#4 by sharky19 // Sep 30, 2022 - 11:33am

One of the most frustrating part of being in this longterm relationship with Carr as a raiders fan is when people label him as accurate but too conservative. I think his inconsistent accuracy is his worst quality by far, and I think that's reflected in the poor redzone numbers these last few years.

Points: 0

#7 by horn // Sep 30, 2022 - 3:22pm

and I similarly wouldn't move Minshew without a godfather offer. Even if Hurts hurt his ankle and was gone for 2 weeks that could be the diff btw 1seed and the bye, and 2-3 seed and traveling to TB or GB again. 

Points: 0

#14 by Pat // Sep 30, 2022 - 7:13pm

Minshew would be a bit of a silly trade: he's a QB, he'll be a qualifying FA next year anyway. No need to trade him to get a pick.

Points: 0

#16 by rpwong // Oct 01, 2022 - 3:33pm

Yeah, it drives me nuts that so many teams would rather have a backup QB who won't threaten the starter over one who can actually win games if the starter gets injured.

Points: 0

#19 by Pat // Oct 02, 2022 - 9:38am

Minshew's in the last year of his rookie contract. His advantage isn't that he's like, super-awesome. He's way cheap for what he offers.

Should the Eagles sign him to a free-agent contract after this year? Heck no.

Points: 0

#21 by rpwong // Oct 02, 2022 - 11:45pm

I didn't say he's super awesome, but I absolutely think they should resign him. He's an athletic and capable backup who could win games with this roster and knows the system. If your goal is to win the Super Bowl, you should absolutely want a decent backup who will keep you in contention if and when the starter gets injured.

Points: 0

#22 by Pat // Oct 03, 2022 - 11:54am

Unless they can get him for close to vet minimum (nope) he's just not worth it. They need as much money as they can get next year to deal with replacing all the starters they're losing plus Hurts's extension. Plus they're losing Dillard as well and there's a good chance Opeta signs elsewhere too.

And it's not really a "Roseman will find cap space" thing because they pushed it hard for this year.

Points: 0

#12 by TomC // Sep 30, 2022 - 6:39pm

Speaking of Eagles LTs, I was amazed-but-then-not to see Jason Peters playing guard for Dallas Monday. I guess if I were sitting on a dock somewhere in east Texas, and someone called me offering X million dollars to suit up for a week, I'd be pretty tempted. 

Points: 0

#13 by Pat // Sep 30, 2022 - 7:11pm

Peters was supposed to play guard in the season which shall not be named until Dillard got hurt. Even then they were thinking about having Mailata at LT but he just wasn't ready. So playing guard isn't super surprising.

I also think Peters just likes playing. It kinda bugs me that it seems like it's lowering opinion on him (Mike's recent "is Jason Peters a Hall of Famer" section, for instance - but not the only one) because yeah, he's probably slightly below average now. Big deal. Still a totally reasonable NFL player. Let him play.

Points: 0

#15 by BroncosGuyAgain // Sep 30, 2022 - 8:32pm

McCaffrey had, I think, a couple of very productive seasons earlier in his career.  Might have had MVP votes.  If his relative lack of production this year is because the coaches like to run him "between the tackles" (and the vast majority of all NFL runs are "between the tackles") wouldn't the obvious test of your hypothesis be to compare the percentage of such runs to that of the really successful years?

Points: 0

#17 by rpwong // Oct 01, 2022 - 3:47pm

Regardless of productivity, the total lack of creativity is confounding. The moments we remember are when CMC took a swing pass and weaved through everyone to the end zone, not when he went up the middle and ran over people. It's the opposite for Derrick Henry.

It's no different from running end arounds with your slowest WR while throwing jump balls to your shortest WR. You can do it, but you're probably not getting the best out of either of them.

Points: 0

Save 10%
& Support Mike
Support Football Outsiders' independent media and Mike Tanier. Use promo code TANIER to save 10% on any FO+ membership and give half the cost of your membership to tip Mike.